arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Mark Bray

172 papers · 1981–2026

1981: 11982: 11983: 11984: 11985: 21986: 31987: 41988: 01989: 01990: 11991: 41992: 21993: 11994: 01995: 21996: 31997: 21998: 41999: 22000: 22001: 32002: 12003: 22004: 12005: 42006: 42007: 42008: 12009: 32010: 22011: 52012: 12013: 82014: 72015: 32016: 92017: 62018: 82019: 72020: 102021: 62022: 172023: 52024: 42025: 52026: 10
1981peak 17 in 20222026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 172 RSS

Levels of Comparison in Educational Studies: Different Insights from Different Literatures and the Value of Multilevel Analyses

Mark Bray, R. Murray Thomas

Political Science and International Relations · Harvard Educational Review · · cited 414× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Research in the field of comparative education has traditionally focused on studies across world regions and countries. In this article, Mark Bray and R. Murray Thomas argue that this approach often yields incomplete and unbalanced perspectives on educational studies because it fails to consider salient differences among states, districts, schools, classrooms, and individuals. The authors illustrate the need for a broader conceptualization of comparative education and propose multilevel analysis as a more comprehensive model of research that can integrate insights gleaned from single-level approaches.

Private supplementary tutoring: comparative perspectives on patterns and implications

Mark Bray

Demography · Compare A Journal of Comparative and International Education · · cited 286× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Private supplementary tutoring has long been a major phenomenon in parts of East Asia, including Japan, Hong Kong, South Korea and Taiwan. In recent times it has grown dramatically in other parts of Asia and in Africa, Europe and North America. The factors underlying the growth of private tutoring vary, but in all settings it has major implications for learning and livelihood. Families with the necessary resources are able to secure not only greater quantities but also better qualities of private tutoring. Children receiving such tutoring are then able to perform better in school, and in the long run to improve their lifetime earnings. By contrast, children of low‐income families who do not receive such benefits may not be able to keep up with their peers and may drop out of school at an earlier age. Tutoring also of course has a direct impact on the livelihoods of the tutors, providing…

Comparative research on shadow education: Achievements, challenges, and the agenda ahead

Zhang Wei, Mark Bray

Demography · European Journal of Education · · cited 212× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This paper reviews research on private supplementary tutoring, widely known as shadow education, during the initial decades of the present century. It takes as its starting point the first global study of the phenomenon, published in 1999, though notes some scattered national and subnational literature prior to that date. During the initial two decades, great expansion of the research on shadow education brought more depth and stronger awareness of commonalities and differences in different cultures. From initial mapping and identification of factors shaping demand came work on ecosystems with deeper sociological and economic analyses, together with greater attention to research methods. The agenda ahead will need to keep up with changing times, e.g., through the impact of technology, and develop stronger interdisciplinarity to explore additional domains. It will also need…

Shadow Education in Europe: Growing Prevalence, Underlying Forces, and Policy Implications

Mark Bray

Demography · ECNU Review of Education · · cited 174× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Purpose: Private supplementary tutoring, widely known as shadow education, has long been visible in East Asia, and now has spread to other parts of the world including Europe. This article maps the phenomenon, showing variations within Europe and analyzing its growth, underlying forces, and policy implications. Design/Approach/Methods: The article assembles a regional picture from available national sources. It focuses on the 28 members of the European Union. Findings: Within Europe, four subregions may be identified. Most prominent for the longest duration has been Southern Europe, pushed by political forces and cultural factors. In Eastern Europe, shadow education became prominent following the collapse of the Soviet Union and accompanying economic and social structures during which teachers and others had to earn extra incomes. In Western Europe, the advent of marketization alongside…

Researching shadow education: methodological challenges and directions

Mark Bray

Demography · Asia Pacific Education Review · · cited 152× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Research on shadow education has considerably increased in volume and has helped to improve understanding of the scale, nature, and implications of the phenomenon. However, the field is still in its infancy. Literature on shadow education reflects confusion over terms and parameters, and data suffer from challenges in securing evidence from actors who may be unwilling or unable to respond to enquiries in a clear manner. Particular care is needed in cross-national and cross-cultural comparisons. Nevertheless, the trajectory of improvement in both conceptualisation and instrumentation gives ground for confidence that shadow education will be progressively better documented and better understood.

Schooling and Its Supplements: Changing Global Patterns and Implications for Comparative Education

Mark Bray

Demography · Comparative Education Review · · cited 149× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Schooling has become a standard component in the daily lives of families, and education is typically the largest item in government budgets. Many scholars have documented the spread of schooling and have analyzed the implications of that spread. Recent decades have brought great expansion of supplementary education alongside schooling. Some of this supplementary education mimics schooling as a shadow, and some complements schooling with elaborate and/or different curricula. The supplementary education is commonly a substantial component of household budgets. This essay examines the nature of changing patterns of schooling and supplementary education around the world. It views the topic through the lenses of (in)equalities, remarking on bidirectional influences between schooling and its supplements. Among major intensifying forces in supplementary education have been governmental…

Shadow Education: Comparative Perspectives on the Expansion and Implications of Private Supplementary Tutoring

Mark Bray

Demography · Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences · · cited 141× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recent decades have brought intensification of what in some settings has been called the shadow education system of supplementary private tutoring. Pupils in regular fee-free public schools attend supplementary fee-paying classes after school, at week-ends and during vacations. This practice has received official comment in China as well as in other countries. Tutoring is especially evident during the period leading up to major examinations, but for some pupils occurs at all levels of education systems. The practice has long been ingrained in the cultures of East Asia, and is now increasingly evident in West and Central Asia, in Europe, in North America, and in Africa. Moreover, new types of tutoring over the internet are being provided across national boundaries. In this respect, tutoring is blurring geographic boundaries.

Micro-neoliberalism in China: public-private interactions at the confluence of mainstream and shadow education

Wei Zhang, Mark Bray

Demography · Journal of Education Policy · · cited 138× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

With its shift to a market economy gathering speed from the 1990s, the Chinese Government embarked on an agenda that brought neoliberal forces into almost all sectors including education. The policies underpinned China’s spectacular economic growth, but in education have had consequences that arguably are problematic.Drawing on a mixed-methods study in Shanghai, this paper examines ‘micro-neoliberalism’ in China’s education system, i.e. privatization and marketization at the individual, family, and institutional levels, with focus on blurring boundaries between public schooling and private supplementary tutoring. Some dimensions of these processes resulted from deliberate macro-level policies to decentralize control of schooling, raise performance, and empower private education. Other dimensions arose from the market behavior of individuals, families, and institutions that countered…

Equalising schooling, unequalising private supplementary tutoring: access and tracking through shadow education in China

Zhang Wei, Mark Bray

Demography · Oxford Review of Education · · cited 114× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The global expansion of mass schooling has greatly increased opportunities for low-income families, and governments have devoted much effort to equalising access and quality in education systems. Alongside regular schooling, the so-called shadow education system of private supplementary tutoring has grown rapidly across the world. The fact that rich families can purchase more and better quality shadow education undermines the achievements of increased equality of opportunities in formal schooling. Drawing on a mixed-methods study in Shanghai, China, the article shows how shadow education has offset school equalisation policies through differentiation of access and through sorting mechanisms. Shadow education occupies a space beyond strict government control in which privileged families and elite schools ignore and mediate the equalisation policies, seeking competitive advantages. Uneven…

Behind the façade of fee-free education: shadow education and its implications for social justice

Mark Bray, Ora Kwo

Demography · Oxford Review of Education · · cited 107× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Most governments, at an official level, espouse the principles of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Among its statements is that education shall be free, at least in the elementary and fundamental stages. Yet while the façade of government education systems presents an image that instruction is free of charge, families across the world increasingly find it necessary to invest in the so-called shadow education system of private supplementary tutoring. The spread of shadow education, which is no longer confined to relatively prosperous families, has far-reaching implications for social inequalities and therefore social justice. It is a hidden form of privatisation behind the façade of public education systems; and the fact that shadow education is seen by many families as unavoidable appears to be incompatible with the spirit of the Universal Declaration. The question then…

Determinants of demand for private supplementary tutoring in China: findings from a national survey

Junyan Liu, Mark Bray

Demography · Education Economics · · cited 86× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Private tutoring has expanded and intensified in China. However, no government statistical data or other empirical studies fully capture its extent and characteristics. This paper analyses private tutoring received by students in Grades 1–12 as indicated by a nationwide representative survey entitled China Family Panel Studies. The paper employs a Hurdle model to examine determinants of demand for tutoring, focusing on factors related to students and their parents. The first step is concerned with the decision to receive tutoring or not; and the second step explores factors influencing expenditures on tutoring among those who decide to receive it.

Measurement Issues in Research on Shadow Education: Challenges and Pitfalls Encountered in TIMSS and PISA

Mark Bray, Magda Nutsa Kobakhidze

Demography · Comparative Education Review · · cited 81× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Expanding numbers of researchers are focusing on the scale and impact of private supplementary tutoring. Such tutoring is widely called shadow education, since much of its curriculum mimics that of regular schooling. Although shadow education has expanded significantly worldwide and is now recognized to have far-reaching significance, research faces methodological and conceptual challenges. This article focuses on analyses of shadow education data from the Third (or Trends in) International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) and the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA). An initial problem arises from definitions of shadow education and therefore from research focus. Further challenges arise from the initial phrasing and then translation of items in international questionnaires. The article notes that some studies have been grounded in problematic data, which has led…

Financing Education in Transitional Societies: Lessons from Russia and China

Mark Bray, Nina Borevskaya

Demography · Comparative Education · · cited 74× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recent years have brought emerging theoretical propositions about the nature of educational change in societies undergoing transition from socialism to market economies. Focusing particularly on the financing of education, this article examines patterns in Russia and China in the light of this literature. It shows that although transitions in the two countries have displayed major differences, they have also displayed significant similarities. These similarities have been evident despite the fact that changes in Russia and China have been made independently of each other. This has largely been because of the impact of market forces, though it has also reflected broader forces of globalisation.

Marketized private tutoring as a supplement to regular schooling: Liberal Studies and the shadow sector in Hong Kong secondary education

Claudia Chan, Mark Bray

Demography · Journal of Curriculum Studies · · cited 73× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Around the world, increasing numbers of students receive after-school private supplementary tutoring. Such tutoring may be provided through informal channels or by companies; and it may be received one-to-one, in small groups, or in large classes. The tutoring is commonly called shadow education since its content mimics that of regular schooling. The spread of shadow education is part of a global shift of balance with increased roles for the private sector. Hong Kong is among the societies in which shadow education enrolment rates are particularly high. Much shadow education focuses on techniques for performance in external examinations, and is not consistent with the emphases stressed by teachers and the government. This paper focuses on a newly-introduced subject called Liberal Studies in which the tensions are especially visible. Although the official curriculum emphasizes creativity…

Postcolonial patterns and paradoxes: language and education in Hong Kong and Macao

Mark Bray, Ramsey D. Koo

Sociology and Political Science · Comparative Education · · cited 73× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The literature on postcolonialism covers a diverse set of geographic areas, cultures, timeframes, and economic and political circumstances. Within the context of this literature, this article focuses on two territories which underwent colonial transition right at the end of the twentieth century, and moved not to sovereignty but to reintegration with their motherland. Language in education systems has long been recognized not only as a very significant indicator of power relations in societies but also as a very important instrument for continuity and/or change. Hong Kong's education sector is a complex arena for language, in which English, Cantonese and Putonghua each play different and changing roles. Macao's education sector has all of these factors plus additional complexities arising from the place of Portuguese. The article notes various paradoxes in the ways that patterns…

A changing environment of urban education: historical and spatial analysis of private supplementary tutoring in China

Zhang Wei, Mark Bray

Demography · Environment and Urbanization · · cited 67× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recent decades have brought dramatic urbanization to China. Between 1978 and 2018, the urban population rose from 17.9 per cent to 59.6 per cent of the total. Urbanization has many implications, including for education. China’s government has long been concerned about imbalances in access to and quality of schooling, and new imbalances have been introduced through market forces in the so-called shadow education sector of private supplementary tutoring, arising from both demand and supply. Urban families in particular seek private supplementary tutoring, and tutorial companies favour densely populated areas for higher enrolments. China has the world’s largest school system and most extensive shadow provision. This paper conceptualizes the space of shadow provision in educational, social and geographical terms. It highlights the changing scale and nature of private tutoring, observes the…

The hidden curriculum in a hidden marketplace: relationships and values in Cambodia’s shadow education system

Mark Bray, Magda Nutsa Kobakhidze, Zhang Wei +1 more

Demography · Journal of Curriculum Studies · · cited 66× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The concept of hidden curriculum has become well established. It addresses the contexts of learning, the actions of students’ peers and teachers, and other domains which shape learning but are not part of official syllabuses. The concept of a hidden marketplace for private tutoring, widely known as shadow education, is less established but also becoming part of general understanding of the complementarities of regular and supplementary instruction. This paper brings the two literatures together to examine the values transmitted, mostly unintentionally, by shadow education in Cambodia. Most of this shadow education is delivered by regular teachers, commonly to their existing students and in their existing schools. The paper considers the impact of shadow education not only on the students who do receive it but also on those who do not. Patterns in Cambodia differ from those in more…

Community Initiatives in Education: Goals, dimensions and linkages with governments

Mark Bray

Education · Compare A Journal of Comparative and International Education · · cited 66× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recent years have brought increasing advocacy of community participation in education. This has been a particularly common theme in policy documents, not only of governments but also of international agencies. Among the main goals has been a desire to spread the burden of resourcing, though advocates also commonly have in mind the volume, relevance and impact of schooling. However, policies often fail to differentiate between different types of communities. Further, the communities' knowl edge bases and motives for engaging in educational work may be very different from the governments'. Thus, while in some situations communities and governments collaborate in harmony, other situations lead to dissonance. This paper notes experiences in a range of countries, and stresses the need for policies to take account of the diversity of circumstances.

Comparative Education in Greater China: Contexts, characteristics, contrasts and contributions

Mark Bray, Gui Qin

Education · Comparative Education · · cited 65× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Greater China is an umbrella term used to cover Mainland China, Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macau. This article reviews the evolution of comparative education in these four societies, noting major forces which have shaped the field. The article observes and comments on similarities and differences within the four societies. It has been prepared as a response to the millennial special issue of the journal, and notes some lessons and contributions from the field in Greater China to the global field of comparative education.</br>[Copyright of Comparative Education is the property of Routledge. Full article may be available at the publisher's website: </br>http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03050060120091256]

Evolving micro-level processes of demand for private supplementary tutoring: patterns and implications at primary and lower secondary levels in China

Junyan Liu, Mark Bray

Demography · Educational Studies · · cited 61× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recent decades have brought global expansion of private supplementary tutoring, and China is among countries in which patterns have been especially dramatic. National survey data indicate that 29.8% of primary and lower secondary students had received private supplementary tutoring in 2014, with proportions rising at higher levels of the school system. However, such statistics present only a snapshot of demand and might suggest that decisions to invest in tutoring are one-off in nature. This paper draws on interviews to show changing patterns of demand by individual parents at different times. Factors influencing parental choices include not only cost and availability of time but also children’s academic performance, children’s different stages of schooling and education system reforms. Over time parents may expand or reduce their demand, change balances between academic and…

Responsibilised parents and shadow education: managing the precarious environment in China

Junyan Liu, Mark Bray

Demography · British Journal of Sociology of Education · · cited 60× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Growing literatures highlight global shifts in education brought by spreading neoliberal values and marketisation. Parallel literatures address parenting styles. Parents, these literatures observe, are increasingly made responsible and/or voluntarily take responsibility for educational inputs alongside mainstream schooling. Much parental investment is in the so-called shadow education sector of private supplementary tutoring. Examining Chinese patterns, this paper notes longstanding high enrolment rates in both academic and non-academic supplementary education prior to government restrictions that brought a sharp marketplace jolt. The paper then employs parental interview data to show the rationales for such investment despite efforts by the Chinese authorities to retain schooling as a fully-sufficient form of education. The strengthened government policy altered the picture, but it…

Different Paths to Neo‐Liberalism? Comparing Australia and New Zealand

Mark Bray, Pat Walsh

Public Administration · Industrial Relations A Journal of Economy and Society · · cited 57× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Australia and New Zealand are best known for their systems of industrial relations based on compulsory arbitration. However, recent years have seen trends in both countries toward neo‐liberalism—trends that represent the end of compulsory arbitration. This paper traces the path taken toward neo‐liberalism, the speed of the journey, and the destination reached in both countries. In attempting to explain the differences between them, it is institutional factors—industrial and political—that are given highest priority.

Third-party facilitators in interest-based negotiation: An Australian Case Study

Johanna Macneil, Mark Bray

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Industrial Relations · · cited 53× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article proposes a new theoretical framework to explain the role of third-party facilitators in interest-based negotiation, and applies the framework in a qualitative case study of a collective bargaining process at an aluminium smelter in Australia. The theoretical framework describes the activities of third parties in terms of the objectives they seek to meet to support bargaining, and the consulting approach they deploy to do so. The case study demonstrates that third parties undertake a range of distinct activities to facilitate bargaining between management and unions, dominated by, although not limited to, a ‘process’ approach to consulting. Moreover, third parties support the development of three types of relationship: their own with the individual parties, as well as relationships between the parties and within each party. While the framework needs confirmation in future…

School factors underlying demand for private supplementary tutoring in English: urban and rural variations in Bangladesh

Rafsan Mahmud, Mark Bray

Demography · Asia Pacific Journal of Education · · cited 51× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Private supplementary tutoring has long existed in Bangladesh, as elsewhere in the world, but in recent decades has become much more visible. Much tutoring “shadows” or reproduces formal schooling as fee-based academic teaching outside school hours. This paper focuses on school factors that shape demand for private supplementary tutoring in English at the secondary level, drawing on data gained from both quantitative and qualitative methods. The paper is especially concerned with urban and rural variations, noting that rates of tutoring are greater in urban areas but that many factors converge to create similarities. Private tutoring in English is highly demanded because English is a compulsory course; and in addition to being a subject in its own right, it assists in the learning of other subjects. While private tutoring may support the academic learning of some pupils, it also has…

Education and Colonial Transition: The Hong Kong experience in comparative perspective

Mark Bray

Sociology and Political Science · Comparative Education · · cited 50× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

While in some respects the nature of Hong Kong's colonial transition seems unique, several parallels exist with transitions elsewhere. This paper begins by identifying major differences and similarities in the macro-framework. It then turns specifically to the education sector, noting that the parallel operation of multiple education systems within the boundaries of a single country is quite common and, therefore, that models already exist for continued plurality of the type that might be envisaged for Hong Kong and the rest of China. Examining changes at various points in time, the paper observes that some reforms were made in Hong Kong's educational provision well ahead of the commencement of colonial transition and far in advance of parallel points in the history in other colonies. The paper then turns to specific changes which occurred during the period 1984-1997 and to commentary…