arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Keith Banting

62 papers · 1979–2025

1979: 41980: 01981: 01982: 01983: 11984: 11985: 01986: 01987: 11988: 11989: 01990: 01991: 01992: 11993: 11994: 01995: 01996: 01997: 11998: 11999: 02000: 02001: 22002: 22003: 12004: 12005: 22006: 52007: 02008: 12009: 22010: 32011: 12012: 32013: 22014: 22015: 62016: 22017: 12018: 02019: 22020: 12021: 32022: 42023: 02024: 12025: 3
1979peak 6 in 20152025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 62 RSS

Multiculturalism and the Welfare State: Recognition and Redistribution in Contemporary Democracies

Keith Banting, Will Kymlicka

Political Science and International Relations · RePEc: Research Papers in Economics · · cited 429× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In many Western democracies, ethnic and racial minorities have demanded, and sometimes achieved, greater recognition and accommodation of their identities. This is reflected in the adoption of multiculturalism policies for immigrant groups, the acceptance of territorial autonomy and language rights for national minorities, and the recognition of land claims and self-government rights for indigenous peoples. These claims for recognition have been controversial, in part because of fears that they make it more difficult to sustain a robust welfare state by eroding the interpersonal trust, social solidarity and political coalitions that sustain redistribution. Are these fears of a conflict between a "politics of recognition" and a "politics of redistribution" valid? This volume is the first systematic attempt to empirically test this question, using both cross-national statistical analyses…

Immigration, Multiculturalism, and the Welfare State

Will Kymlicka, Keith Banting

Sociology and Political Science · Ethics & International Affairs · · cited 217× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Popular opposition to immigration is rooted in many factors. In this essay, we focus on one specific issue that has become prominent in recent debates—namely, the fear that the welfare state is being undermined by the impact of increasing ethnic and racial diversity. There are actually two concerns here: first, that ethnic and racial diversity as such makes it more difficult to sustain redistributive social policies because it is difficult to generate feelings of national solidarity and trust across ethnic and racial lines, and second, that the “multiculturalism” policies adopted to recognize or accommodate immigrant groups tend to further undermine national solidarity and trust. If either of these hypotheses were true, the very idea of a “multicultural welfare state,” a welfare state that respects and accommodates diversity, would be almost a contradiction in terms. We review the…

Do multiculturalism policies erode the welfare state? An empirical analysis

Keith Banting, Richard Johnston, Will Kymlicka +1 more

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 180× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter introduces a new framework for testing the recognition/redistribution hypothesis. It develops an index of twenty-three different types of MCPs that have been adopted for three different types of minority groups (immigrants, national minorities, and indigenous peoples). Western countries are then categorized in terms of their level of MCPs. Whether countries with higher levels of MCPs have faced an erosion of the welfare state as compared to countries with lower levels of MCPs is tested. It is shown that there is no negative correlation between the strength of a country's commitment to MCPs and its ability to sustain welfare spending or economic redistribution. The chapter also examines the heterogeneity/redistribution hypothesis, and shows that this too is overstated. In general, the size of immigrant groups, national minorities, and indigenous peoples in Western countries…

Canadian Multiculturalism: Global Anxieties and Local Debates

Keith Banting, Will Kymlicka

Sociology and Political Science · British Journal of Canadian Studies · · cited 151× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In much of the world, and particularly in Europe, there is a widespread perception that multiculturalism has failed, and Canada has not been immune to these rising global anxieties. A number of commentators have argued that smug complacency is blinding Canadians to growing evidence of stresses and failures in ethnic relations in their country. In this article, we explore this evolving debate. We briefly review the global backlash against multiculturalism, and why some commentators see warning signs in Canada as well. We then look at the evidence about how the multiculturalism policy in Canada operates, and about trends in immigrant integration and ethnic relations. We show that there are indeed stresses and strains within Canadian multiculturalism, with real issues that require serious attention. But we misdiagnose the problems, and their remedies, if we read the Canadian experience…

Is There a Progressive's Dilemma in Canada? Immigration, Multiculturalism and the Welfare State

Keith Banting

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 138× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract. There is a widespread fear in many western nations that ethnic diversity is eroding support for the welfare state. This article examines such fears in the Canadian context. In-depth analysis of public attitudes finds remarkably little tension between ethnic diversity and public support for social programs in Canada. At first glance, then, the country seems to demonstrate the political viability of a multicultural welfare state. But this pattern reflects distinctive features of the institutional context within which public attitudes evolve. The Canadian policy regime has forestalled tension between diversity and redistribution by diverting adjustment pressures from the welfare state, absorbing some of them in other parts of the policy regime, and nurturing a more inclusive form of identity. These institutional buffers are thinning, however, potentially increasing the danger of…

Canada: nation-building in a federal welfare state

Keith Banting

Sociology and Political Science · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 116× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

'In Canada, three distinct models of federalism govern different social programmes: classical federalism, with programmes run exclusively by one level of government; shared costs federalism, with the federal government financially supporting provincial programmes; and joint-decision federalism, where formal approval by both levels of government is mandatory before any action can take place. Each of these models creates different decision rules, altering the mix of governments and ideologies at the bargaining table, redistributing power among those who have a seat at the table, and requiring different levels of consensus for action. The result has been three separate kinds of interactions between institutions and policy during the postwar era of welfare state expansion. As in the era of expansion, the new politics of social policy in the 'silver age' had to flow through the three…

Introduction Multiculturalism and the welfare state: Setting the context

Keith Banting, Will Kymlicka

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 90× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This introductory chapter provides an overview of two recent debates on the relationship between ethnic diversity, multiculturalism, and the welfare state. Some commentators argue that increasing levels of ethnic and racial heterogeneity make it difficult to sustain a welfare state (the ‘heterogeneity/redistribution trade-off’). This chapter reviews the evidence that has been emerged in previous research for both claims, which is shown to be inconclusive. There are many unanswered questions about the conditions under which the heterogeneity/redistribution and recognition/redistribution trade-offs may exist, about the causal mechanisms that underpin them, and about the possible strategies for reducing them. The subsequent chapters in this volume fill in some of these important gaps in our knowledge, drawing on cross-national statistical analyses, case studies, and theoretical reflections.

Ethnoreligious Identity, Immigration, and Redistribution

Stuart Soroka, Matthew Wright, Richard Johnston +3 more

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Experimental Political Science · · cited 87× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Do increasing, and increasingly diverse, immigration flows lead to declining support for redistributive policy? This concern is pervasive in the literatures on immigration, multiculturalism and redistribution, and in public debate as well. The literature is nevertheless unable to disentangle the degree to which welfare chauvinism is related to (a) immigrant status or (b) ethnic difference. This paper reports on results from a web-based experiment designed to shed light on this issue. Representative samples from the United States, Quebec, and the “Rest-of-Canada” responded to a vignette in which a hypothetical social assistance recipient was presented as some combination of immigrant or not, and Caucasian or not. Results from the randomized manipulation suggest that while ethnic difference matters to welfare attitudes, in these countries it is immigrant status that matters most.…

Do Multiculturalism Policies Erode the Welfare State

Keith Banting, Will Kymlicka

Political Science and International Relations · Econstor (Econstor) · · cited 87× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The past 30 years have witnessed a dramatic change in the way Western democracies deal with ethnic minorities. In the past, ethnic diversity was often seen as a threat to political stability, and minorities were subject to a range of policies intended to assimilate or marginalize them. Today, many Western democracies have adopted a more accommodating approach. This is reflected in the widespread adoption of multiculturalism policies for immigrant groups, the acceptance of territorial autonomy and language rights for national minorities, and the recognition of land claims and self-government rights for indigenous peoples. We refer to these policies as 'multiculturalism policies' or MCPs. The adoption of MCPs has been controversial, for two reasons. The first is a philosophical critique, which argues that MCPs are inherently inconsistent with basic liberal-democratic principles. Since the…

Migration and welfare state spending

Stuart Soroka, Richard Johnston, Anthony Kevins +2 more

Sociology and Political Science · European Political Science Review · · cited 85× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Is international migration a threat to the redistributive programmes of destination countries? Existing work is divided. This paper examines the manner and extent to which increases in immigration are related to welfare state retrenchment, drawing on data from 1970 to 2007. The paper makes three contributions: (1) it explores the impact of changes in immigration on social welfare policy over both the short and medium term; (2) it examines the possibility that immigration matters for spending not just directly, but indirectly, through changes in demographics and/or the labour force; and (3) by disaggregating data on social expenditure into subdomains (including unemployment, pensions, and the like), it tests the impact of immigration on different elements of the welfare state. Results suggest that increased immigration is indeed associated with smaller increases in spending. The major…

The Welfare State and Canadian Federalism

Rick Williams, Keith Banting

Political Science and International Relations · Labour / Le Travail · · cited 79× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The first edition of The Welfare State and Canadian Federalism focused on the impact of federalism on social policy during a period of economic growth and expanding social expenditures. The revised edition extends the analysis by asking how the federal syatem has shaped the social policy response to neo-conservatism, recession, and restraint. It analyses policy trends in detail; examines the implications of constitutional changes, including the Charter; and highlights the continuing role of federalism.

Minority nationalism and immigrant integration in <scp>C</scp>anada

Keith Banting, Stuart Soroka

Sociology and Political Science · Nations and Nationalism · · cited 70× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Immigrant integration is currently a prominent issue in virtually all contemporary democracies, but countries in which the historic population itself is deeply divided – particularly those with substate nations and multiple political identities – present some interesting questions where integration is concerned. The existence of multiple and potentially competing political identities may complicate the integration process, particularly if the central government and the substate nation promote different conceptions of citizenship and different nation‐building projects. What, then, are the implications of minority nationalism for immigrant integration? Are the added complexities a barrier to integration? Or do overlapping identities generate more points of contact between immigrants and their new home? This article addresses this question by probing immigrant and non‐immigrant…

And No One Cheered: Federalism, Democracy and the Constitution Act

Patrick J. Monahan, Keith Banting, Richard Simeon

Law · The American Journal of Comparative Law · · cited 61× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Journal Article Keith Banting and Richard Simeon: And No One Cheered: Federalism, Democracy and the Constitution Act Get access And No One Cheered: Federalism, Democracy and the Constitution Act. Edited by KeithBanting and RichardSimeon. Toronto: Methuen Publications, 1983. Pp. xii. 376. Patrick J. Monahan Patrick J. Monahan *Assistant Professor of Law, Osgoode Hall Law School, Toronto, Canada. Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Google Scholar The American Journal of Comparative Law, Volume 32, Issue 2, Spring 1984, Pages 393–396, https://doi.org/10.2307/840474 Published: 01 April 1984

Degrees of Freedom: Canada and the United States in a Changing World

David C. Hendrickson, Keith Banting

Sociology and Political Science · Foreign Affairs · · cited 60× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The book's primary aim is to determine whether Canada and the United States have become more similar as their economies have become more integrated and their societies more diverse. The authors conclude that, although powerful economic and social pressures clearly constrain national governments and lead to convergence in some areas, distinctive cultural and political processes preserve room for distinctive national responses to important problems of the late twentieth century. Authors include Keith Banting, Paul Boothe (University of Alberta), Marsha Chandler (University of Toronto), George Hoberg, Robert Howse (University of Toronto), Christopher Manfredi (McGill University), George Perlin (Queen's University), Douglas Purvis (Queen's University), Richard Simeon, and Elaine Willis (consultant, Toronto).

The Nonprofit Sector in Canada: Roles and Relationships

Rose Anne Devlin, Keith Banting

Urban Studies · Canadian Public Policy · · cited 58× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The size and complexity of the not-for-profit sector, the role of religious organizations in the delivery of social services, the distinctive roles of not-for-profits in caring for the elderly in Ontario and Quebec, the advocacy role of ethno-cultural organizations at the national level, and accountability dilemmas facing not-for-profit organizations are just some of the topics tackled in this book, illustrating the rich diversity of the not-for-profit sector.

Shared Membership Beyond National Identity: Deservingness and Solidarity in Diverse Societies

Allison Harell, Keith Banting, Will Kymlicka +1 more

Sociology and Political Science · Political Studies · · cited 52× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Liberal nationalists argue that identification with the nation promotes feelings of mutual obligation, including support for redistribution. Existing attempts to test this hypothesis have focused on whether the higher sense of national identity among the majority increases support redistribution. We argue for a twofold shift in focus. First, beyond the majority’s own national identity, we need to explore their perceptions of whether minorities share this identity. Second, we need to shift from one-dimensional ideals of ‘identity’ to more complex ideas of attachment and commitment. Do members of the majority view minorities as committed to the nation and willing to make sacrifices for it? Drawing on a custom-designed online survey in Canada, we show that three salient out-groups (Aboriginal peoples, French-speaking Canadians and immigrants) are seen by majority respondents as less…

National Identity and Support for the Welfare State

Richard Johnston, Keith Banting, Will Kymlicka +1 more

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 52× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract. This paper examines the role of national identity in sustaining public support for the welfare state. Liberal nationalist theorists argue that social justice will always be easier to achieve in states with strong national identities, which, they contend, can both mitigate opposition to redistribution among high-income earners and reduce any corroding effects of ethnic diversity resulting from immigration. We test these propositions with Canadian data from the Equality, Security and Community survey. We conclude that national identity does increase support for the welfare state among the affluent majority of Canadians and that it helps to protect the welfare state from toxic effects of cultural suspicion. However, we also find that identity plays a narrower role than existing theories of liberal nationalism suggest and that the mechanisms through which it works are different.…

Social Citizenship and Federalism: Is a Federal Welfare State a Contradiction in Terms?

Keith Banting

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks · · cited 49× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Social citizenship and federalism represent two defining features of contemporary governance. Yet, at first glance at least, these two concepts seem to exist in deep tension. The promise of social citizenship is the equality of treatment of citizens, to be achieved through common social benefits and public services available to all citizens throughout a country. The promise of federalism is regional diversity in public policies, reflecting the preferences of regional communities and cultures. Balancing these contradictory logics would seem especially important in countries with federal institutions and mature welfare states.KeywordsWelfare StateFederal StateSocial AssistanceIncome TransferIncome SecurityThese keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Understanding national identity

Keith Banting

Political Science and International Relations · Ethnic and Racial Studies · · cited 45× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Every day, the news headlines testify to importance of national identities. Brexit, the US presidential election, the rise of anti-system populist parties all seem to reflect a volatile mix of econ...

Is there really a backlash against multiculturalism policies? New evidence from the multiculturalism policy index

Keith Banting, Will Kymlicka

Political Science and International Relations · RECERCAT (Consorci de Serveis Universitaris de Catalunya) · · cited 44× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In much of the western world, and particularly in Europe, there is a widespread perception that multiculturalism has ‘failed’ and that governments who once embraced a multicultural approach to diversity are turning away, adopting a strong emphasis on civic integration. This reaction, we are told, “reflects a seismic shift not just in the Netherlands, but in other European countries as well” (JOPPKE 2007). This paper challenges this view. Drawing on an updated version of the Multiculturalism Policy Index introduced earlier (BANTING and KYMLICKA 2006), the paper presents an index of the strength of multicultural policies for European countries and several traditional countries of immigration at three points in time (1980, 2000 and 2010). The results paint a different picture of contemporary experience in Europe. While a small number of countries, including most notably the Netherlands…

Reform of Retirement Income Policy: International and Canadian Perspectives

James E. Pesando, Keith Banting, Robin Boadway

Demography · Canadian Public Policy · · cited 42× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Canada is hardly unique in this respect. Countries around the world are engaged in similar debates, and their experience holds important lessons. Through the perspectives of international and Canadian researchers, Reform of Retirement Income Policy focuses on many key reform issues: future income prospects for the elderly, roles of the public and private sectors, fairness and intergenerational equity, affordability and economic impacts, public expectations, and political constraints. Contributors include Bob Baldwin (Canadian Labour Congress), Keith G. Banting (Queen's), Ken Battle (Caledon Institute of Social Policy), Gordon Betcherman (Ekos Research), Robin Boadway (Queen's), Thomas J. Courchene (Queen's), James Cutt (Victoria), James Davies (Western), Andrew Dilnot (Institute of Fiscal Studies, England), Estelle James (World Bank), Newman Lam (Victoria), Harvey Lazar (Queen's), Jack…

The Multicultural Welfare State: International Experience and North American Narratives

Keith Banting

Political Science and International Relations · Social Policy and Administration · · cited 41× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Contemporary debates are increasingly pessimistic about the impact of ethnic diversity on support for the welfare state. A growing number of analysts argue that greater ethnic diversity in Western democracies is weakening public support for redistribution, and that this underlying tension is exacerbated by the adoption of robust multiculturalism policies. The purpose of this essay is to summarize early findings from several studies that bear on the questions at the heart of such debates. These studies analyse the implications of immigration and multiculturalism policies for the welfare state across OECD countries, and also focus more closely on the experience of two distinctively multicultural countries, the United States and Canada. The evidence points to more complex relationships than often assumed. OECD countries with large foreign‐born populations have not had more…

The Puzzling Persistence of Racial Inequality in Canada

Keith Banting, Debra Thompson

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 33× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article examines the failure of Canadian public policy in addressing racial economic inequality directly. Our analysis contends that Canada's key policy regimes were established in the postwar era, when approximately 96 per cent of Canadians were of European descent. As a result, the frameworks, problem definitions and policy tools inherited from that era were never intended to mitigate racial economic inequality. Moreover, this policy inheritance was deeply shaped by liberal universalism, which rejected racial distinctions in law and policy. These norms were carried forward into the more racially diverse Canada of today, where they have steered attention away from the use of racial categories in policy design. As a result, racial inequality was not a central priority during major policy reforms to core policy regimes in recent decades. In theoretical terms, our analysis…

A Distinctive Culture? The Sources of Public Support for Immigration in Canada, 1980–2019

Keith Banting, Stuart Soroka

Sociology and Political Science · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 30× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Canada has often been seen as immune from the powerful backlash against globalization and immigration that has driven political shifts elsewhere. This article challenges this belief, at least in part, by tracing the evolution of public attitudes toward immigration and analyzing the factors that have shaped the trajectory for over three decades. Drawing on nearly forty years of Environics Focus Canada surveys, combined with annual data on macro-economics and immigration flows, findings here suggest that Canadians’ tolerance toward immigration responds to immigration flows and is heavily influenced by macro-economic conditions.

Transatlantic convergence? The archaeology of immigrant integration in Canada and Europe

Keith Banting

Demography · International Journal Canada s Journal of Global Policy Analysis · · cited 30× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

At first glance, Canada and Europe seem to be diverging dramatically in their approach to immigrant integration. While support for a multicultural approach seems to remain strong in Canada, a potent backlash pervades European debates. This paper argues that beneath the image of transatlantic divergence, there are important elements of convergence. First, the retreat from multiculturalism in Europe is more complete at the level of discourse than policy. With a few notable exceptions, multicultural policies have remained stable or even grown stronger since 2000. In many countries, new integration programs are being layered over multicultural initiatives introduced in earlier decades. Second, many of the new integration policies celebrated as evidence of a U-turn away from multiculturalism resemble programs that have long been part of immigrant integration in Canada. As a result…