A comparison of youth‐driven and adult‐driven youth programs: Balancing inputs from youth and adults
Reed Larson, Kate Walker, Nickki Pearce
Abstract This article examines the unfolding of experiences in youth programs that differed in the degree of youth and adult influence over program activities. In‐depth qualitative data were obtained over a three‐ to four‐month cycle of activities in two “youth‐driven” and two “adult‐driven” programs for high‐school–aged youth. All had been identified as high quality, and in all of the programs, the adults were sensitive and respectful to the youth. Rather than finding that one approach was categorically better than the other, our analyses suggested that each provided distinct developmental experiences, and that each presented somewhat different day‐to‐day challenges to the adults. In the youth‐driven programs, the youth experienced a high degree of ownership and empowerment, and they reported development of leadership and planning skills. In the adult‐driven programs, the adults…