arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Justin Halberda

69 papers · 2002–2025

2002: 12003: 02004: 02005: 12006: 12007: 02008: 62009: 12010: 42011: 72012: 62013: 72014: 22015: 12016: 72017: 42018: 32019: 22020: 52021: 32022: 12023: 22024: 42025: 1
2002peak 7 in 20112025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 69 RSS

Developmental change in the acuity of the "number sense": The approximate number system in 3-, 4-, 5-, and 6-year-olds and adults.

Justin Halberda, Lisa Feigenson

Statistics and Probability · Developmental Psychology · · cited 974× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Behavioral, neuropsychological, and brain imaging research points to a dedicated system for processing number that is shared across development and across species. This foundational Approximate Number System (ANS) operates over multiple modalities, forming representations of the number of objects, sounds, or events in a scene. This system is imprecise and hence differs from exact counting. Evidence suggests that the resolution of the ANS, as specified by a Weber fraction, increases with age such that adults can discriminate numerosities that infants cannot. However, the Weber fraction has yet to be determined for participants of any age between 9 months and adulthood, leaving its developmental trajectory unclear. Here we identify the Weber fraction of the ANS in 3-, 4-, 5-, and 6-year-old children and in adults. We show that the resolution of this system continues to increase throughout…

Impaired Acuity of the Approximate Number System Underlies Mathematical Learning Disability (Dyscalculia)

Michèle M. M. Mazzocco, Lisa Feigenson, Justin Halberda

Statistics and Probability · Child Development · · cited 553× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Many children have significant mathematical learning disabilities (MLD, or dyscalculia) despite adequate schooling. The current study hypothesizes that MLD partly results from a deficiency in the Approximate Number System (ANS) that supports nonverbal numerical representations across species and throughout development. In this study of 71 ninth graders, it is shown that students with MLD have significantly poorer ANS precision than students in all other mathematics achievement groups (low, typically, and high achieving), as measured by psychophysical assessments of ANS acuity (w) and of the mappings between ANS representations and number words (cv). This relation persists even when controlling for domain-general abilities. Furthermore, this ANS precision does not differentiate low-achieving from typically achieving students, suggesting an ANS deficit that is specific to MLD.

Preschool acuity of the approximate number system correlates with school math ability

Melissa E. Libertus, Lisa Feigenson, Justin Halberda

Statistics and Probability · Developmental Science · · cited 498× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Previous research shows a correlation between individual differences in people's school math abilities and the accuracy with which they rapidly and nonverbally approximate how many items are in a scene. This finding is surprising because the Approximate Number System (ANS) underlying numerical estimation is shared with infants and with non-human animals who never acquire formal mathematics. However, it remains unclear whether the link between individual differences in math ability and the ANS depends on formal mathematics instruction. Earlier studies demonstrating this link tested participants only after they had received many years of mathematics education, or assessed participants' ANS acuity using tasks that required additional symbolic or arithmetic processing similar to that required in standardized math tests. To ask whether the ANS and math ability are linked early in life, we…

Number sense across the lifespan as revealed by a massive Internet-based sample

Justin Halberda, Ryan Ly, Jeremy Wilmer +2 more

Statistics and Probability · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · · cited 488× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

It has been difficult to determine how cognitive systems change over the grand time scale of an entire life, as few cognitive systems are well enough understood; observable in infants, adolescents, and adults; and simple enough to measure to empower comparisons across vastly different ages. Here we address this challenge with data from more than 10,000 participants ranging from 11 to 85 years of age and investigate the precision of basic numerical intuitions and their relation to students' performance in school mathematics across the lifespan. We all share a foundational number sense that has been observed in adults, infants, and nonhuman animals, and that, in humans, is generated by neurons in the intraparietal sulcus. Individual differences in the precision of this evolutionarily ancient number sense may impact school mathematics performance in children; however, we know little of its…

Preschoolers' Precision of the Approximate Number System Predicts Later School Mathematics Performance

Michèle M. M. Mazzocco, Lisa Feigenson, Justin Halberda

Statistics and Probability · PLoS ONE · · cited 420× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Approximate Number System (ANS) is a primitive mental system of nonverbal representations that supports an intuitive sense of number in human adults, children, infants, and other animal species. The numerical approximations produced by the ANS are characteristically imprecise and, in humans, this precision gradually improves from infancy to adulthood. Throughout development, wide ranging individual differences in ANS precision are evident within age groups. These individual differences have been linked to formal mathematics outcomes, based on concurrent, retrospective, or short-term longitudinal correlations observed during the school age years. However, it remains unknown whether this approximate number sense actually serves as a foundation for these school mathematics abilities. Here we show that ANS precision measured at preschool, prior to formal instruction in mathematics…

Acquisition of English Number Marking: The Singular-Plural Distinction

Sid Kouider, Justin Halberda, Justin N. Wood +1 more

Statistics and Probability · Language Learning and Development · · cited 230× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

We present data from a preferential looking method to investigate when infants have mapped singular and plural markers in English onto the semantic distinction between singleton sets and sets with more than 1 individual. Twenty- to 36-month-old children heard sentences that marked number in 1 of 2 ways: (a) redundantly with verb morphology, lexical quantifiers, and noun morphology (“Look, there ARE SOME blicketS”/“Look, there IS A blicket”) or (b) only with noun morphology (“Look at the blicketS”/“Look at the blicket”). Twenty-four-month-old infants, but not 20-month-old infants, looked at the screen that matched the carrier sentence with respect to singular–plural distinction when number was expressed on the verb, on the noun, and with quantifiers. Detailed looking-time analyses suggest that the arrays begin to be differentiated on the child’s hearing are or is. Twenty-four-month-olds…

Links Between the Intuitive Sense of Number and Formal Mathematics Ability

Lisa Feigenson, Melissa E. Libertus, Justin Halberda

Statistics and Probability · Child Development Perspectives · · cited 228× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Humans share with other animals a system for thinking about numbers in an imprecise and intuitive way. The Approximate Number System (ANS) that underlies this thinking is present throughout the lifespan, is entirely nonverbal, and supports basic numerical computations like comparing, adding, and subtracting quantities. Humans, unlike other animals, also have a system for representing exact numbers. This linguistically mediated system is slowly mastered over the course of many years and provides the basis for most of our formal mathematical thought. A growing body of evidence suggests that the nonverbal ANS and the culturally invented system of exact numbers are fundamentally linked. In this article, we review evidence for this relationship, describing how group and individual differences in the ANS correlate with and even predict formal math ability. In this way, we illustrate how a…

Multiple Spatially Overlapping Sets Can Be Enumerated in Parallel

Justin Halberda, Sean F. Sires, Lisa Feigenson

Statistics and Probability · Psychological Science · · cited 214× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A system for nonverbally representing the approximate number of items in visual and auditory arrays has been documented in multiple species, including humans. Although many aspects of this approximate number system are well characterized, fundamental questions remain unanswered: how does attention select which items in a scene to enumerate, and how many enumerations can be computed simultaneously? Here we show that when presented an array containing different numbers of spatially overlapping dots of many colors, human adults can select and enumerate items on the basis of shared color and can enumerate approximately three color subsets from a single glance. This three-set limit converges with previously observed three-item limits of parallel attention and visual short-term memory. This suggests that participants can select a subset of items from a complex array as a single individual…

Developmental change in the acuity of approximate number and area representations.

Darko Odic, Melissa E. Libertus, Lisa Feigenson +1 more

Statistics and Probability · Developmental Psychology · · cited 186× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

From very early in life, humans can approximate the number and surface area of objects in a scene. The ability to discriminate between 2 approximate quantities, whether number or area, critically depends on the ratio between the quantities, with the most difficult ratio that a participant can reliably discriminate known as the Weber fraction. While developmental improvements in the Weber fraction have been demonstrated for number, the developmental trajectory of improvement in area discrimination remains unknown. Here we investigated whether the development of area discrimination parallels that of number discrimination. We tested forty 3- to 6-year-old children and adults in both a number and an area discrimination task in which participants selected the greater of 2 quantities across a range of ratios. We used formal psychophysical models to derive, for each participant and each age…

The Meaning of ‘Most’: Semantics, Numerosity and Psychology

Paul M. Pietroski, Jeffrey Lidz, Tim B. Hunter +1 more

Statistics and Probability · Mind & Language · · cited 141× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract: The meaning of ‘most’ can be described in many ways. We offer a framework for distinguishing semantic descriptions, interpreted as psychological hypotheses that go beyond claims about sentential truth conditions, and an experiment that tells against an attractive idea: ‘most’ is understood in terms of one‐to‐one correspondence. Adults evaluated ‘Most of the dots are yellow’, as true or false, on many trials in which yellow dots and blue dots were displayed for 200 ms. Displays manipulated the ease of using a ‘one‐to‐one with remainder’ strategy, and a strategy of using the Approximate Number System to compare of (approximations of) cardinalities. Interpreting such data requires care in thinking about how meaning is related to verification. But the results suggest that ‘most’ is understood in terms of cardinality comparison, even when counting is impossible.

Hysteresis affects approximate number discrimination in young children.

Darko Odic, Howard S. Hock, Justin Halberda

Statistics and Probability · Journal of Experimental Psychology General · · cited 126× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Perceptual decisions are often affected not only by the evidence gathered during a trial but also by the history of preceding trials. This effect--termed perceptual hysteresis--provides evidence for how perceptual information is represented and how it is used. The present research focuses on how the difficulty of preceding trials affects subsequent ones--we find that how well 5-year-old children perform in a 2-alternative forced-choice numerical discrimination task depends on whether they have had a prior history of easier discriminations or a prior history of harder discriminations. Furthermore, this effect is modulated by the feedback children receive. In 3 experiments, we demonstrate that these effects are not related to practice or loss of interest due to negative feedback, or simply to trial difficulty or discriminability. Instead, children appear to have state-dependent confidence…

Acquisition of the Cardinal Principle Coincides with Improvement in Approximate Number System Acuity in Preschoolers

Anna Shusterman, Emily Slusser, Justin Halberda +1 more

Statistics and Probability · PLoS ONE · · cited 95× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Human mathematical abilities comprise both learned, symbolic representations of number and unlearned, non-symbolic evolutionarily primitive cognitive systems for representing quantities. However, the mechanisms by which our symbolic (verbal) number system becomes integrated with the non-symbolic (non-verbal) representations of approximate magnitude (supported by the Approximate Number System, or ANS) are not well understood. To explore this connection, forty-six children participated in a 6-month longitudinal study assessing verbal number knowledge and non-verbal numerical acuity. Cross-sectional analyses revealed a strong relationship between verbal number knowledge and ANS acuity. Longitudinal analyses suggested that increases in ANS acuity were most strongly related to the acquisition of the cardinal principle, but not to other milestones of verbal number acquisition. These findings…

The Development of “Most” Comprehension and Its Potential Dependence on Counting Ability in Preschoolers

Justin Halberda, Len Taing, Jeffrey Lidz

Statistics and Probability · Language Learning and Development · · cited 93× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Quantifiers are a test case for an interface between psychological questions, which attempt to specify the numerical content that supports the semantics of quantifiers, and linguistic questions, which uncover the range of possible quantifier meanings allowable within the constraints of the syntax. Here we explore the development of comprehension of most in English, of particular interest as it calls on precise numerical content that, in adults, requires an understanding of large exact numerosities (e.g., 23 blue dots and 17 yellow is an instance of “most of the dots are blue”). In a sample of 100 children 2 to 5 years of age we find that (a) successful most comprehension in cases with two salient subsets is achieved at 3 years, 7 months of age, and (b) most comprehension is independent of knowledge of large exact number words; that is, knowledge of large exact number words is neither…

Bidirectional, Longitudinal Associations Between Math Ability and Approximate Number System Precision in Childhood

Leanne Elliott, Lisa Feigenson, Justin Halberda +1 more

Statistics and Probability · Journal of Cognition and Development · · cited 70× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Research suggests that individual differences in math abilities correlate with approximate representations of quantity that are supported by a primitive Approximate Number System (ANS). However, relatively little research has addressed the direction of this association in early childhood. Here we examined the development of the ANS and math ability longitudinally in 3- to 5-year-old children. Children were observed at three time points roughly six months apart; they completed a nonsymbolic numerical comparison task that measured ANS precision and a standardized math assessment. A series of cross-lagged panel models was then estimated to explore the associations between ANS precision and math ability over time. Bidirectional associations between ANS precision and math ability emerged: Early ANS precision was related to children’s later math skills, and early math ability also…

Young children's understanding of “more” and discrimination of number and surface area.

Darko Odic, Paul M. Pietroski, Tim B. Hunter +2 more

Statistics and Probability · Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning Memory and Cognition · · cited 56× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The psychology supporting the use of quantifier words (e.g., "some," "most," "more") is of interest to both scientists studying quantity representation (e.g., number, area) and to scientists and linguists studying the syntax and semantics of these terms. Understanding quantifiers requires both a mastery of the linguistic representations and a connection with cognitive representations of quantity. Some words (e.g., "many") refer to only a single dimension, whereas others, like the comparative "more," refer to comparison by numeric ("more dots") or nonnumeric dimensions ("more goo"). In the present work, we ask 2 questions. First, when do children begin to understand the word "more" as used to compare nonnumeric substances and collections of discrete objects? Second, what is the underlying psychophysical character of the cognitive representations children utilize to verify such sentences?…

Why do we differ in number sense? Evidence from a genetically sensitive investigation

Maria Grazia Tosto, Stephen A. Petrill, Justin Halberda +9 more

Statistics and Probability · Intelligence · · cited 54× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Basic intellectual abilities of quantity and numerosity estimation have been detected across animal species. Such abilities are referred to as ‘number sense’. For human species, individual differences in number sense are detectable early in life, persist in later development, and relate to general intelligence. The origins of these individual differences are unknown. To address this question, we conducted the first large-scale genetically sensitive investigation of number sense, assessing numerosity discrimination abilities in 837 pairs of monozygotic and 1422 pairs of dizygotic 16-year-old twin pairs. Univariate genetic analysis of the twin data revealed that number sense is modestly heritable (32%), with individual differences being largely explained by non-shared environmental influences (68%) and no contribution from shared environmental factors. Sex-Limitation model fitting…

Memory for multiple visual ensembles in infancy.

Jennifer M. Zosh, Justin Halberda, Lisa Feigenson

Statistics and Probability · Journal of Experimental Psychology General · · cited 48× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The number of individual items that can be maintained in working memory is limited. One solution to this problem is to store representations of ensembles that contain summary information about large numbers of items (e.g., the approximate number or cumulative area of a group of many items). Here we explored the developmental origins of ensemble representations by asking whether infants represent ensembles and, if so, how many at one time. We habituated 9-month-old infants to arrays containing 2, 3, or 4 spatially intermixed colored subsets of dots, then asked whether they detected a numerical change to one of the subsets or to the superset of all dots. Experiment Series 1 showed that infants detected a numerical change to 1 of the subsets when the array contained 2 subsets but not 3 or 4 subsets. Experiment Series 2 showed that infants detected a change to the superset of all dots no…

Understanding the mapping between numerical approximation and number words: evidence from Williams syndrome and typical development

Melissa E. Libertus, Lisa Feigenson, Justin Halberda +1 more

Statistics and Probability · Developmental Science · · cited 36× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

All numerate humans have access to two systems of number representation: an exact system that is argued to be based on language and that supports formal mathematics, and an Approximate Number System (ANS) that is present at birth and appears independent of language. Here we examine the interaction between these two systems by comparing the profiles of people with Williams syndrome (WS) with those of typically developing children between ages 4 and 9 years. WS is a rare genetic deficit marked by fluent and well-structured language together with severe spatial deficits, deficits in formal math, and abnormalities of the parietal cortex, which is thought to subserve the ANS. One of our tasks, requiring approximate number comparison but no number words, revealed that the ANS precision of adolescents with WS was in the range of typically developing 2- to 4-year-olds. Their precision improved…

Emergence of the Link Between the Approximate Number System and Symbolic Math Ability

Jinjing Wang, Justin Halberda, Lisa Feigenson

Statistics and Probability · Child Development · · cited 31× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Experimentally manipulating Approximate Number System (ANS) precision has been found to influence children's subsequent symbolic math performance. Here in three experiments (N = 160; 81 girls; 3-5 year old) we replicated this effect and examined its duration and developmental trajectory. We found that modulation of 5-year-olds' ANS precision continued to affect their symbolic math performance after a 30-min delay. Furthermore, our cross-sectional investigation revealed that children 4.5 years and older experienced a significant transfer effect of ANS manipulation on math performance, whereas younger children showed no such transfer, despite experiencing significant changes in ANS precision. These findings support the existence of a causal link between nonverbal numerical approximation and symbolic math performance that first emerges during the preschool years.

Compromised approximate number system acuity in extremely preterm school‐aged children

Kerstin Hellgren, Justin Halberda, Lea Forsman +2 more

Statistics and Probability · Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology · · cited 26× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

AIM: The aim of this study was to compare the approximate number system acuity in children born extremely preterm aged 6 years 6 months and typically developing, age-matched peers. METHOD: This population-based follow-up study included 65 children born before 27 gestational weeks (35 males, 30 females; mean gestational age 25.4 wks [SD 1.1 wk]; mean birthweight 789 g [SD 158 g]) and 47 typically developing children (24 females, 23 males) at the age of 6 years 6 months. A battery of cognitive tests was administered, including a computerized test for measuring approximate number system acuity and tests for general cognition, working memory, processing speed, and visual attention. Approximate number system outcome measures were means of Weber fraction (w) values and response time in milliseconds. RESULTS: The 43 extremely preterm children in whom usable data were obtained performed…

The Impact of Action Video Game Training on Mathematical Abilities in Adults

Melissa E. Libertus, Allison S. Liu, Olga Pikul +4 more

Statistics and Probability · AERA Open · · cited 25× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Playing action video games has previously been linked to improvements in attentional control, the ability to choose what to attend and what to ignore that relies on a frontoparietal network of the brain. Here we asked whether action video game training would impact a range of mathematical abilities that rely on similar brain regions. Twenty-four adults completed extensive cognitive testing before, after 25 hr, and after 40 hr of video game training. Half of the participants trained on an action video game, the other half trained on a nonaction video game. Action video game training yielded no significant improvements in foundational number-processing skills and attentional control in this study but some improvements on standardized assessments of complex mathematics. Thus, although action video game play is clearly not an intervention of choice when considering mathematical skills, the…

Eye movements reveal distinct encoding patterns for number and cumulative surface area in random dot arrays

Darko Odic, Justin Halberda

Statistics and Probability · Journal of Vision · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Humans can quickly and intuitively represent the number of objects in a scene using visual evidence through the Approximate Number System (ANS). But the computations that support the encoding of visual number-the transformation from the retinal input into ANS representations-remain controversial. Two types of number encoding theories have been proposed: those arguing that number is encoded through a dedicated, enumeration computation, and those arguing that visual number is inferred from nonnumber specific visual features, such as surface area, density, convex hull, etc. Here, we attempt to adjudicate between these two theories by testing participants on both a number and a cumulative area task while also tracking their eye-movements. We hypothesize that if approximate number and surface area depend on distinct encoding computations, saccadic signatures should be distinct for the two…

Effects of Visual Training of Approximate Number Sense on Auditory Number Sense and School Math Ability

Melissa E. Libertus, Darko Odic, Lisa Feigenson +1 more

Statistics and Probability · Frontiers in Psychology · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Research with children and adults suggests that people's math performance is predicted by individual differences in an evolutionarily ancient ability to estimate and compare numerical quantities without counting (the approximate number system or ANS). However, previous work has almost exclusively used visual stimuli to measure ANS precision, leaving open the possibility that the observed link might be driven by aspects of visuospatial competence, rather than the amodal ANS. We addressed this possibility in an ANS training study. Sixty-eight 6-year-old children participated in a 5-week study that either trained their visual ANS ability or their phonological awareness (an active control group). Immediately before and after training, we assessed children's visual and auditory ANS precision, as well as their symbolic math ability and phonological awareness. We found that, prior to training…

Epistemic Limitations and Precise Estimates in Analog Magnitude Representation

Justin Halberda

Computational Theory and Mathematics · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter presents a re-understanding of the contents of our analog magnitude representations (e.g., approximate duration, distance, number). The approximate number system (ANS) is considered, which supports numerical representations that are widely described as fuzzy, noisy, and limited in their representational power. The contention is made that these characterizations are largely based on misunderstandings—that what has been called “noise” and “fuzziness” is actually an important epistemic signal of confidence in one’s estimate of the value. Rather than the ANS having noisy or fuzzy numerical content, it is suggested that the ANS has exquisitely precise numerical content that is subject to epistemic limitations. Similar considerations will arise for other analog representations. The chapter discusses how this new understanding of ANS representations recasts the learnability…

Set representations required for the acquisition of the “natural number” concept

Justin Halberda, Lisa Feigenson

Statistics and Probability · Behavioral and Brain Sciences · · cited 18× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Rips et al. consider whether representations of individual objects or analog magnitudes are building blocks for the concept natural number . We argue for a third core capacity – the ability to bind representations of individuals into sets. However, even with this addition to the list of starting materials, we agree that a significant acquisition story is needed to capture natural number.