arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Jorge Contesse

27 papers · 2008–2025

2008: 22009: 02010: 02011: 32012: 12013: 02014: 02015: 02016: 12017: 32018: 22019: 52020: 12021: 32022: 22023: 12024: 12025: 2
2008peak 5 in 20192025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 27 RSS

The international authority of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights: a critique of the conventionality control doctrine

Jorge Contesse

Law · The International Journal of Human Rights · · cited 44× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article discusses the constitutional turn in the Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ recent jurisprudence, exemplified in the adoption of the conventionality control doctrine. Building on previous work and inquiring for the first time into the legal theory of Judge Sergio García Ramírez, who created the doctrine, I show that conventionality control lacks solid legal footing and reveals a problematic understanding of the Inter-American Court as a regional constitutional tribunal. I propose, therefore, an alternative account of the doctrine that rests more on state practice. Reviewing how two states, Peru and Argentina, have internalised the Inter-American Court’s case law on amnesty laws – a prominent feature of the court’s jurisprudence – I argue that the court should embrace such domestic developments to, first, provide a robust justification for its assertion of international…

Contestation and deference in the Inter-American human rights system

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · Rutgers University Community Repository (Rutgers University) · · cited 39× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article discusses the Inter-American human rights system’s adjudication model in light of some of the conjectures on subsidiarity as a principle for international governance -- that is, the degree of deference it grants to the assessment of a situation by the member state concerned. I inquire about the system’s role as arbitrator of human rights cases within its jurisdiction, examining the dynamics of subsidiarity within the system’s changing context. I find that the Inter-American Court of Human Rights tends to employ a maximalist model of adjudication. Such a model leaves little room for states to reach their own decisions and can be explained as largely resting upon the political context where the Court came to exist, almost four decades ago. I argue that there is a challenge ahead for the Court, namely, to reconcile both claims: on the one hand, states’ demands for higher…

Resisting the Inter-American Human Rights System

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · eYLS (Yale Law School) · · cited 24× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In a decision that shocked the inter-American human rights world, the Argentinean Supreme Court in February 2017 refused to comply with an InterAmerican Court of Human Rights decision ordering it to revoke a domestic judgment. At issue was a case in which Argentina's Supreme Court had affirmed a civil judgment that found two journalists liable for defamation for publishing stories about an unacknowledged child of former President Carlos Menem in 2001. Ten years later, the Inter-American Court found that the Argentinean Supreme Court's affirmation of the civil judgment against the journalists violated the journalists' right to freedom of expression under the American Convention on Human Rights-the region's core human rights treaty. The InterAmerican Court ordered Argentina's Supreme Court to "revoke the decision in its entirety." In 2016, Argentina's president asked the Supreme Court to…

It's Not OK: New Zealand's Efforts to Eliminate Violence Against Women

Jorge Contesse, Jeanmarie Fenrich

Sociology and Political Science · eYLS (Yale Law School) · · cited 21× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This Report presents the findings of this research effort. It consists of three parts: Part I sets out the normative framework on domestic violence, both at the international and national level, and explains the relevant norms that govern the relationship between Maori and the Crown. Part II begins with a background discussion regarding the level of domestic violence in New Zealand. It then proceeds to detail the problems with the domestic law and implementing regulations addressing domestic violence, both with the law as written and problems with the law and regulations as implemented or enforced, the "implementation gaps." It presents the delegation's findings with respect to a range of problems women face when they are victims (and/or survivors) of domestic violence. It also documents the problems activists and workers face when they address these situations. Some of these problems…

The final word? Constitutional dialogue and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights

Jorge Contesse

Law · International Journal of Constitutional Law · · cited 11× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this Article, I discuss the ways in which the Inter-American Court of Human Rights addresses cases adopting a novel approach to legal adjudication — one that relies on domestic notions of constitutional law carried out by domestic jurisdictions. Most scholarship on the inter-American human rights system assumes a top-down approach, whereby the Court merely dictates what countries must do. I argue that a new, bottom-up approach is in place and, further, is required to advance the Court’s legitimacy, especially in the face of criticism by countries, legal scholars and advocates for the Court’s decisions as an illegitimate intervention into domestic affairs. To this end, I critically examine the conventionality control doctrine, whereby domestic judges are expected to decide as if they were “inter-American human rights judges,” and I discuss two decisions that shed light on how the…

The Rule of Advice in International Human Rights Law

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · American Journal of International Law · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Advisory jurisdiction is a ubiquitous feature of international human rights adjudication. Yet the attention of legal scholars is almost entirely devoted to contentious jurisdiction. This Article aims to fill that gap in the literature. By introducing two models of advisory jurisdiction, and analyzing the example of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights—the world's most active international advice-giver—the Article shows how international human rights courts may utilize advisory proceedings to influence state conduct, in a mechanism the Article calls “ruling through advice.” The Article also shows how human rights courts may attempt to guide states and national courts by means of an “anticipatory adjudication” mechanism. Using the Inter-American Court's groundbreaking advisory opinion on same-sex marriage as a case study, the Article argues that, despite the domestic implementation of…

Sexual orientation and gender identity in Inter-American human rights law

Jorge Contesse

Law · North Carolina Journal of International Law · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Sexual orientation and gender identity are legally-protected categories in international human rights law and in the law of many States. For the past two decades, States, regional, and the universal human rights systems have expanded the understanding of anti-discrimination law in ways that to many seemed unexpected. Until 2000, no country had legalized same-sex marriage. Less than twenty years later, more than two dozen countries recognize same-sex marriage and many more recognize same-sex civil unions. Along with the recognition of sexual orientation as a prohibited ground of discrimination, gender identity has also become a legally significant concept for human rights law. In Latin America, a region traditionally labeled as socially conservative, sexuality laws have also undergone unprecedented changes. Such legal developments cannot be understood without an examination of the role…

Case of Barrios Altos and La Cantuta v. Peru

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · American Journal of International Law · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

On May 30, 2018, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (Court) ordered Peru to review the presidential pardon granted to former president and dictator Alberto Fujimori, who had been convicted and imprisoned for his role in serious human rights violations. The Peruvian Supreme Court obliged and, after examining the merits of the presidential pardon through a special procedure set up to assess the pardon's conformity with international human rights law, invalidated the pardon, effectively reinstating Fujimori's imprisonment for crimes against humanity.

Indigenous Peoples in Chile: The Quest to become a Constitutional Entity

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · Studies in law, politics, and society · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter discusses the legal and political process whereby indigenous peoples in Chile have demanded, and failed to be granted, constitutional recognition. By identifying indigenous peoples as groups that suffer from both misrecognition and maldistribution, I demonstrate political authorities' and legal scholars' lack of understanding toward indigenous peoples' demands since the resumption of democracy, in the late 1980s. I discuss the way in which indigenous peoples ultimately resort to the law from outside, i.e., international human rights law, to challenge the local understandings and the contours of a Constitution that fails to include the most disadvantaged group in Chilean society.

Rights and Guarantees of Children in the Context of Migration and/or in need of International Protection (Inter-Am. Ct. H.R.)

Jorge Contesse

Sociology and Political Science · International Legal Materials · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

On August 19, 2014, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (the Court) issued its Advisory Opinion on the “Rights and Guarantees of Children in the Context of Migration and/or in need of International Protection” (the Opinion). This key Opinion is the first time that the Court has addressed states’ obligations to protect the rights of migrant children, in response to a joint submission by four members of the Organization of American States (OAS).

Human Rights as Transnational Law

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · AJIL Unbound · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In 1916, at the first meeting of the then newly created American Institute of International Law, jurists from different countries adopted a declaration stipulating that “[i]nternational law is at one and the same time both national and international.” 1 A century later, Latin American international human rights law clearly reflects that idea. Since the adoption of the American Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Man in 1948, and especially since the 1950s, with the creation of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, and later with the adoption of the American Convention on Human Rights in 1969, human rights in Latin America have been, are, and will continue to be an essentially regional phenomenon of international law. By examining the Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ case law, this essay analyzes the way in which Latin America has articulated transnational human rights…

Autoridad y disenso en la Corte Interamericana de Derechos HumanosAuthority and dissent in the Inter-American Court of Human Rights

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Constitutional Law · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Legal scholars have paid significant attention to backlash and resistance against international tribunals. In general, the phenomenon is examined as coming from the outside, that is, from states dissatisfied with certain judgments. Resistance, however, may also come “from within,” when members of the tribunal themselves not only have interpretive disagreements, but challenge the way in which the Court shapes its authority. In this short work, I briefly examine two areas in which this interaction occurs and connect it to the more recent context of resistance against the Inter-American human rights system in order to begin a discussion about how the Court’s expansive interpretations may expand its jurisprudence, but ultimately at the cost of exposing the Court’s authority.

Judicial Interactions and Human Rights Contestations in Latin America

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Dispute Settlement · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The Inter-American Court of Human Rights is one of the world's most active human rights tribunals. Through an impressive history of case law, the Court has exerted significant influence upon Latin American states. In recent years, however, states and domestic national courts have challenged the Inter-American Court's authority in more complex and potentially more damaging ways than in the past. By exploring how the Inter-American Court of Human Rights has expanded its reach upon states, and how states engage in turn, the Article examines ways of interaction that can enhance or debilitate the Court's authority and influence on states. The Article explores recent dissents as a potential mode of resistance, especially when coupled with states' unease towards international adjudication and suggests ways in which the Court may respond to such challenges in order to protect and…

The Downfall of a Constitutional Court

Jorge Contesse

Law · DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Constitutional Court of Chile faces the worst crisis in its history. It largely stems from the way the Court has exercised its powers in recent years. A blend of judicial activism and an utter disdain for rules has seriously undermined the Court’s reputation and the current shows that the Court has probably risen in prominence for the wrong reasons.

Introduction to the Symposium on the American Convention on Human Rights and its New Interlocutors

Jorge Contesse, Alexandra Huneeus

Political Science and International Relations · AJIL Unbound · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

There is never a lack of those who clamor that there is a crisis afoot in the IAS. See Eduardo Ferrer, "La Corte Interamericana Siempre ha Vivido en Crisis", EL PAIS (July 24, 2018) (recording the President of the Inter-American Court affirming that the Court has always been in crisis, which is also to say that there is nothing particularly unusual in the Court's current situation). For an example of a similar sense of crisis from an earlier era, see

The Rise and Fall of a Constitutional Moment: Lessons from the Chilean Experiment and the Failure of Bachelet's Project

Sergio Verdugo, Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This comment discusses the recent constitution-making process pursued in Chile by former President Michelle Bachelet. It argues that the process failed because of the lack of sufficient political agreements and an ill-designed bottom-up mechanism of constitution-making. Despite high levels of popular support for a new Constitution, the comment suggests that Bachelet's failed process has in fact harmed and weakened the viability of a new Constitution in Chile.

Critical Disconnects

Janice K. Gallagher, Jorge Contesse

Sociology and Political Science · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The year 2011 should have been a watershed for Mexican human rights. Mexico’s Supreme Court historically strengthened human rights protections by adopting progressive doctrines grounded in international law, the country modernized its criminal justice system, and civil society united in its calls for justice. Despite these changes, one decade later Mexico finds itself in an unprecedented human rights crisis. How do we understand the spectacular and tragically costly failure of Mexico’s judicial system to strengthen human rights protections and break patterns of impunity over the past decade? The chapter argues that this disconnect stems from two intersecting dynamics: first, the Mexican state’s historically weak, fragmented, federal nature has resulted in the institutionalization of mechanisms that enable impunity, in particular through the work of a powerful and unaccountable…

Conservative Governments and Latin America's Human Rights Landscape

Jorge Contesse

Law · AJIL Unbound · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In 2009, as the American Convention on Human Rights turned forty, Left-wing governments ruled in almost all Latin American countries. The democratization wave that began in the late 1980s had produced a seemingly hegemonic turn to the Left—the so-called “Pink Tide.” A decade later, the political landscape was radically different. With only a few exceptions, Right-wing governments are in power throughout Latin America. The implications of the conservative wave have been felt in a number of areas—including human rights. This essay explores the ways in which the new conservative governments of Latin American have tried to curb the inter-American human rights system and examines the potential long-term consequences that their efforts may have on the regional system and the protection of human rights. It then suggests possible avenues for sound engagement between states and the system…

The Civil Marriage and the Constitution: the Constitutional Court decision on same-sex marriage in Chile

Jorge Contesse Singh

Law · DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article briefly discusses the Chilean Constitutional Court’s decision regarding the definition of marriage in Chile, which reserves the right to marry exclusively to a man and a woman. The article grounds the discussion on a robust conception of the equal dignity of individuals and analyzes the separate opinions of the justices of the Court, emphasizing some technical legal issues such as the prevalence of separate opinions and the references to international human rights law in almost all of them. The article argues that, considering the development of international human rights law and the crafting of claims as fundamental rights claims, it is only a matter of time before the legislature addresses the issue of same-sex marriage, following the Court’s statement that it is the legislature’s duty to do so.

The Human Rights Institutions of Latin America

Jorge Contesse

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Jorge Contesse provides a historical review of the work of Latin America’s two most prominent human rights institutions, the Inter-American Commission and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. The chapter discusses formal and informal institutional rules. It explains two distinctive doctrines of Latin American international law—the incompatibility of self-amnesties with international law and the doctrine of conventionality control. Contesse celebrates the vitality of these bodies, particularly in the struggle against military dictatorships. But, he also cautions that the Court’s overzealous interpretations of its mandate in recent years could eventually weaken the human rights system by undermining its legitimacy. The chapter briefly examines developments in the Court’s jurisprudence concerning the justiciability of social rights and the Court’s emphasis on a common law of…

Inter-States Disputes Under the Inter-American Human Rights System

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · International Human Rights Law Review · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Under the inter-American human rights system, inter-State disputes seem largely irrelevant. Such irrelevance contrasts with the European human rights system, where the amount of inter-State disputes is significant (and growing), and is similar to the African human rights regime, where there is a very low number of inter-State disputes. In more than four decades since the entry into force of the American Convention on Human Rights, there are only two inter-State disputes brought before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights—one of the two bodies that, along with the Inter-American Court, make up the regional human rights system. The virtual inexistence of inter-State complaints, however, does not mean an absence of human rights disputes among members of the Organization of American States ( oas ). In fact, States resort to other mechanisms to process their disputes.…

Conventionality Control and the Limits of Pro Persona Jurisprudence

Jorge Contesse

Law · The Italian Review of International and Comparative Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract In Conventionality Control of Domestic Law: Constitutionalised International Adjudication and Internationalised Constitutional Adjudication , Yota Negishi advances a theory of conventionality control, a doctrine of interaction between international human rights law and national law, that puts at the center of such interaction the pro persona principle. This commentary analyses Negishi’s work, highlighting its major contributions and noting what it sees as problematic areas of the theory, in particular, the over reliance on the principle, and its use as a mechanism to allocate judicial competences. The commentary notes how the Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ use of the principle can explain some of its most expansive caselaw, a caselaw that has come under scrutiny by members of the Court and that deserves serious attention by legal scholars.

Settling human rights violations

Jorge Contesse

Political Science and International Relations · View · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the past few decades, human rights courts have been widely established around the world, sparking the interest of legal scholars who devote significant attention to state accountability for human rights violations. Academic centers exclusively dedicated to the study of international courts have appeared, and conferences on the role of international adjudication now abound. International law has become a juricentric discipline. With the enormous attention afforded to the international human rights judiciary, critical aspects of non-judicial human rights decision-making are often neglected. One understudied mechanism is that of friendly settlements, whereby victims of human rights violations, acting under the “good offices” of regional human rights bodies, enter into direct negotiations with respondent states toward a consensual resolution to a human rights dispute. Despite its…