arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Jonathan Riley

65 papers · 1967–2024

1967: 11968: 01969: 01970: 01971: 01972: 01973: 01974: 21975: 01976: 01977: 11978: 01979: 01980: 01981: 01982: 01983: 01984: 01985: 11986: 01987: 01988: 01989: 21990: 21991: 21992: 11993: 01994: 01995: 01996: 11997: 01998: 11999: 12000: 02001: 52002: 32003: 22004: 02005: 32006: 32007: 42008: 22009: 22010: 22011: 12012: 52013: 12014: 52015: 12016: 52017: 22018: 12019: 02020: 02021: 02022: 02023: 22024: 1
1967peak 5 in 20012024

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 65 RSS

Liberal Utilitarianism: Social Choice Theory and J. S. Mill's Philosophy.

Prasanta K. Pattanaik, Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · The Economic Journal · · cited 81× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Journal Article Liberal Utilitarianism: Social Choice Theory and J. S. Mill's Philosophy Get access Liberal Utilitarianism: Social Choice Theory and J. S. Mill's Philosophy. By JONATHAN RILEY. (Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 1988. Pp. xiv + 398. £25.00, US $39.50 hardback. ISBN 0 521 30692 2.) Prasanta K. Pattanaik Prasanta K. Pattanaik University of Birmingham Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Google Scholar The Economic Journal, Volume 99, Issue 397, 1 September 1989, Pages 876–878, https://doi.org/10.2307/2233789 Published: 01 September 1989

J. S. Mill's Liberal Utilitarian Assessment of Capitalism Versus Socialism

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Utilitas · · cited 70× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

John Stuart Mill argued, in his Principles of Political Economy (1848, 7th edn., 1871), that existing laws and customs of private property ought to be reformed to promote a far more egalitarian form of capitalism than hitherto observed anywhere. He went on to suggest that such an ideal capitalism might evolve spontaneously into a decentralized socialism involving a market system of competing worker co-operatives. That possibility of market socialism emerged only as the working classes gradually developed the intellectual and moral qualities required for worker co-operatives to succeed against private firms. Workers would tend to reject the hierarchical wage relation as they developed the requisite personal qualities, he believed, and capitalists, facing escalating wages for skilled labour as a result of the diminishing supply of high-quality workers for hire, would tend to lend their…

Interpreting Mill's Qualitative Hedonism

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · The Philosophical Quarterly · · cited 56× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Against Schmidt‐Petri's claim, I argue that John Stuart Mill is committed to the view that one pleasure is higher in quality than another if and only if at least a majority of those people who are competently acquainted with both always prefer the one no matter how much of the other is offered. I support my reading with solid textual evidence; none such is provided by Schmidt‐Petri in support of his contrary interpretation that qualitative superiority exists whenever the experienced prefer less of one pleasure to more of another. The decisive objection to this is its incompatibility with the hedonistic requirement that more pleasure ought to be preferred to less, a requirement so fundamental that it would be uncharitable to suppose that Mill lost sight of it in his doctrine of higher pleasures.

Mill's Neo-Athenian Model of Liberal Democracy

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 55× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

John Stuart Mill, like his friend and fellow utilitarian radical George Grote, expresses deep admiration for the Athenian democracy of the fifth and fourth centuries b.c. (CW X, XI, XVIII, and XIX). They both argue that the ancient Athenian political system (as they understand it in light of the limited sources of information) provides valuable lessons for the citizens of modern representative democracies. Mill in particular tries to show what a representative democracy would look like if its system of institutions was designed in accord with the spirit of Athens, and he claims that such a well-constructed representative democracy would be the best form of government for any civilized society, that is, any society whose citizens typically are "capable of rational persuasion" through free discussion and debate.

Mill's political economy

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 49× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

John Stuart Mill undertook to rehabilitate the utilitarian radicalism of Bentham and his followers, "to show that there was a Radical philosophy, better and more complete than Bentham's, while recognizing and incorporating all of Bentham's which is permanently valuable". To carry out his grand project, he studied the insights into will, imagination, and character offered by German Idealists (including Goethe, Kant, and Schiller) and their British disciples (notably Coleridge, Frederick Maurice, John Sterling, and Carlyle). He was also far more open than his utilitarian predecessors to egalitarian social Utopias of the sort proposed by French 'socialists' (including Saint-Simon, Fourier, Comte, and Louis Blanc). Moreover, at his death in 1873, he was lampooned as a 'feminine philosopher' for his insistence that justice demanded equal rights for women as well as men independently of race…

Interpreting Berlin’s Liberalism

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · American Political Science Review · · cited 44× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

I argue that Isaiah Berlin’s pluralistic liberalism is best interpreted as a sophisticated form of liberal rationalism, as Berlin himself suggests. His value pluralism, even if it is viewed (as his critics typically view it, with considerable justification) as claiming that any choice between conflicting incommensurable values cannot be a rational choice, does not subvert his liberalism. Rather, this agonistic pluralism emanates from his liberal rationalism, which pictures reason as too weak to resolve conflicts of incommensurables. Yet, reason remains strong enough to discover that certain basic liberal values, including those associated with some minimum core of equal rights, are far more important than any competing values created by mankind. Berlin apparently sees his pluralistic liberal rationalism as a genuine rationalism that, in stark contrast to mainstream utopian rationalisms…

Defending Cultural Pluralism

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Political Theory · · cited 39× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Evaluation de la philosophie politique d'I. Berlin, entre l'interpretation d'une defense esthetique du pluralisme culturel chez G. Kateb, d'une part, et l'interpretation d'un rationalisme liberal chez J. Gray, d'autre part. L'A. montre que Berlin defend un pluralisme culturel limite fonde sur la priorite des droits individuels et l'appreciation esthetique des etres humains.

Isaiah Berlin’s “Minimum of Common Moral Ground”

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Political Theory · · cited 31× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Isaiah Berlin’s political thought consistently combines tragic value pluralism with moral priority for a minimum sphere of individual liberty which is defined and protected by a core set of basic human rights. His fundamental concept of a common moral minimum includes multiple components, including the idea that there is a common moral world of plural and conflicting incommensurable objective values and the idea that humans share a common nucleus of needs and interests centered on the overriding goal of human survival. The basic human rights have priority over competing values because the rights are essential for human survival. They determine a common threshold of human decency: decent societies must respect the rights, which are in principle mutually harmonious under ordinary conditions, although emergencies can arise in which some of the rights must be sacrificed to respect others.…

‘One Very Simple Principle’

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Utilitas · · cited 28× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

John Gray, much influenced by Isaiah Berlin and building on work by the late John Rees and the late Fred Berger, has recently stated three ‘fatal’ objections which virtually all analysts seem to find persuasive against John Stuart Mill's classic doctrine of liberty. First, Gray thinks it ‘an obvious objection to Mill's project that conceptions of harm vary with competing moral outlooks, so that no Principle of Liberty whose application turns on judgements about harm can expect to resolve disputes between exponents of opposed moral perspectives’. Even if we overlook Mill's strange silence in the matter and supply him with a reasonable definition of harm (such as damage to certain vital human interests or rights), it remains clear that the liberty principle ‘is not, and cannot be, the very simple principle Mill sought’. For ‘Mill's principle is in its very nature radically incomplete. It…

J. S. Mill's Doctrine of Freedom of Expression

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Utilitas · · cited 27× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Mill's free speech doctrine is distinct from, yet compatible with, his central principle of ‘purely self-regarding’ liberty. Using the crucial analogy with trade, I claim that he defends a broad laissez-faire policy for expression, even though expression is ‘social’ or other-regarding conduct and thus legitimately subject to social regulation. An expedient laissez-faire policy admits of exceptions because speakers can sometimes cause such severe damage to others that coercive interference with the speech is justified. In those relatively few contexts where interference is called for, however, the central principle of self-regarding liberty sets absolute limits to the scope of society's regulatory authority. Regulation can never amount to an outright ban of any type of expression that can be consumed by the individual without direct and immediate harm to others. Nevertheless, and perhaps…

Individuality, Custom and Progress

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Utilitas · · cited 25× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

If harm is restricted to mean perceptible damage suffered by an agent against his wishes, so that his mere dislike with no evidence of injury is excluded, then Mill's liberty principle arguably is ‘one very simple principle’ as he claims. But even so, what of John Gray's charge that the liberty principle relies on a ‘radically defective’ notion of individuality or autonomy that is incompatible with every civil society's cultural and moral traditions? If he is correct about this, then Mill's principle lacks appeal even if it can be stated in a definite and coherent manner.

Rights to Liberty in Purely Private Matters

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Economics and Philosophy · · cited 25× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

John Stuart Mill provides a classic defense of individual and group rights to liberty with respect to purely private or self-regarding matters: The only part of the conduct of any one, for which he is amenable to society, is that which concerns others. In the part which merely concerns himself … directly, and in the first instance, … his independence is, of right, absolute.… From this liberty of each individual, follows the liberty, within the same limits, of combination among individuals; freedom to unite, for any purpose not involving harm to others: the persons combining being supposed to be of full age, and not forced or deceived. (1859, pp. 224–26)

Toward an Understanding of the Fourth Crusade as an Institution

Jonathan Riley‐Smith

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 22× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter shows how an understanding of the command structure of the “pilgrim” contingent helps to explain why it was able to survive partial disintegration and reach Constantinople. The size of the fleet and the small estimates of knights suggest that the impressions of the Muslims were exaggerated and that the force comprised between 8,000 and 10,000 men, about a quarter of the size of that projected for the Fourth Crusade, although very substantial for the period. So the plans for the Fourth Crusade constitute the most ambitious proposal for a trans-Mediterranean invasion conceived in the central Middle Ages. The Fourth Crusade was the first to reveal feature of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, a core of persistent crusaders who would turn up over and over again in different theaters of war. The Fourth Crusade was originally planned on a breathtaking scale. A huge army was…

Mill’s Greek Ideal of Individuality

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks · · cited 18× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In On Liberty, John Stuart Mill defends “a Greek ideal of selfdevelopment,” which apparently involves a mixture of two elements: “ ‘Pagan self-assertion’ is one of the elements of human worth, as well as ‘Christian self-denial’ “ (OL.iii.8).1 This Greek ideal, he says, “blends with [...] the Platonic and Christian ideal of self-government” in so far as both ideals prescribe that individuals should voluntarily sacrifice their selfish concerns when necessary to obey moral rules of justice that distribute equal rights and correlative duties for the common good. Indeed, an individual should be forced, if necessary, to obey such rules of justice: “As much compression as is necessary to prevent the stronger specimens of human nature from encroaching on the rights of others, cannot be dispensed with” (OL.iii.9).2 But the Greek ideal also includes an element of self-assertion and thus does not…

Mill’s absolute ban on paternalism

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

John Stuart Mill is commonly said to prescribe an absolute ban on paternalism. But this is true only if paternalism is understood as coercive interference with a competent person’s conduct solely for his own good. While he has multiple arguments for his view, Mill says that his most important argument is what may be called the provisional epistemic argument, according to which a competent individual, though not always prudent, is the best judge of her own good as she conceives it, and should be permitted to choose any self-regarding action which she judges is needed to attain it, provided she is in possession of any readily available public information (which others may need to supply through advice and warning) about the condition of external objects (such as a public bridge but also her own body and reputation) so that she can do as she wishes in accord with her feasible intentions.…

Rights to Liberty in Purely Private Matters: <i>Part II</i>

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Economics and Philosophy · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A claim that certain purely private matters should be beyond the reach of society's laws, moral rules, and other customs is central to the distinctive liberalism of John Stuart Mill. On Liberty, perhaps the most eloquent defense of individual liberty ever written, laments the hostility allegedly displayed in modern mass societies toward “the right of each individual to act [in private matters] as seems good to his judgement and inclinations” (1859, p. 271n.). In Mill's view, a free society must design its institutions with due regard for what he terms “individuality.” That is, public authority, whether in the form of law, customary opinion, or economic power, must be self-limiting so that it does not interfere with the rights of individuals to choose as they like with respect to such private concerns as religious faith, reading materials, living companions, and consumption of drugs and…

Mill’s extraordinary utilitarian moral theory

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Politics Philosophy & Economics · · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

D.G. Brown’s revisionist interpretation, despite its interest, misrepresents Mill’s moral theory as outlined in Utilitarianism . Mill’s utilitarianism is extraordinary because it explicitly aims to maximize general happiness both in point of quality and quantity. It encompasses spheres of life beyond morality, and its structure cannot be understood without clarification of his much-maligned doctrine that some kinds of pleasant feelings are qualitatively superior to others irrespective of quantity. This doctrine of higher pleasures establishes an order of precedence among conflicting kinds of enjoyments, including moral as well as non-moral kinds. In particular, as he indicates in Utilitarianism, Chapter V, the higher kind of pleasure associated with the moral sentiment of justice, namely, a feeling of ‘security’ for vital personal concerns that everyone has and that ought to be…

What are Millian Qualitative Superiorities

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · University of Zagreb University Computing Centre (SRCE) · · cited 12× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In an article published in Prolegomena 2006, Christoph Schmidt-Petri has defended his interpretation and attacked mine of Mill’s idea that higher kinds of pleasure are superior in quality to lower kinds, regardless of quantity. Millian qualitative superiorities as I understand them are infinite superiorities. In this paper, I clarify my interpretation and show how Schmidt-Petri has misrepresented it and ignored the obvious textual support for it. As a result, he fails to understand how genuine Millian qualitative superiorities determine the novel structure of Mill’s pluralistic utilitarianism, in which a social code of justice that distributes equal rights and duties takes absolute priority over competing considerations. Schmidt-Petri’s own interpretation is a non-starter, because it does noteven recognize that Mill is talking about different kinds of pleasant feelings, such that the…

Is Mill an Illiberal Utilitarian?

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Ethics · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Piers Norris Turner’s recent interpretation of John Stuart Mill’s philosophy transforms Mill into an illiberal utilitarian, against the textual evidence. Mill rejects Turner’s standard utilitarian, or “expansive,” conception of harm, according to which mere displeasure or distress counts as nonconsensual harm. Moreover, Mill is not a radical antipaternalist. He says that society may legitimately consider the individual’s own good as a reason for interference with other-regarding actions that inflict nonconsensual harm on others. But there are no reasons, paternalistic or otherwise, for interference with self-regarding actions that may be displeasing to others without causing them any nonconsensual harm.

Racism, blasphemy, and free speech

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

J. S. Mill evidently accepts that society and government may legitimately use coercive measures to prevent individuals from behaving in ways that pose a risk of direct and immediate harm to other people without their genuine consent and participation. The most important thing a society can do to promote the general welfare, he makes clear in the fifth chapter of Utilitarianism, is to establish laws and customs that distribute weighty equal rights not to suffer unprovoked violence, undue discrimination, and other grievous harms. These rules of justice might sanction unusually harsh punishment for wrongdoers – whether members of the popular majority or a minority – who make a show of harming others merely because the others are perceived as belonging to alien races, religions, or ethnic backgrounds.

&lt;title&gt;Comparison of the effectiveness of alternative feature sets in shape retrieval of multicomponent images&lt;/title&gt;

John P. Eakins, Jonathan D. Edwards, K. Jonathan Riley +1 more

Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition · Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Many different kinds of features have been used as the basis for shape retrieval from image databases. This paper investigates the relative effectiveness of several types of global shape feature, both singly and in combination. The features compared include well-established descriptors such as Fourier coefficients and moment invariants, as well as recently-proposed measures of triangularity and ellipticity. Experiments were conducted within the framework of the ARTISAN shape retrieval system, and retrieval effectiveness assessed on a database of over 10,000 images, using 24 queries and associated ground truth supplied by the UK Patent Office . Our experiments revealed only minor differences in retrieval effectiveness between different measures, suggesting that a wide variety of shape feature combinations can provide adequate discriminating power for effective shape retrieval in…

On the Possibility of Liberal Democracy

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · American Political Science Review · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A complex liberal version of utilitarianism is introduced which bears similarities to John Stuart Mill's moral and political philosophy and offers a promising approach to liberal democratic theory. Formally, liberal utilitarianism is represented as a type of generalized social welfare functional which maps any given set of individual vector-valued utility functions into a social ordering. The generalized social welfare functional in question relies on the experienced members of society to classify ond compare the different kinds of utilities found in individual vectors; to grant and protect libertarian rights with respect to a well-defined private kind of individual utilities; and to make the interpersonal comparisons required to aggregate over each of the public kinds of individual utilities. At the same time, it is dynamic in that it implicitly comprehends many different levels of a…

Justice Under Capitalism

Jonathan Riley

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Capitalism is outrageously unjust: it requires a continuing mal-distribution of wealth in order to exist. But more than that, it is also self-destructive. Property is a term that refers to rights of ownership granted by society with respect to both production and consumption goods. The meaning of the term varies across societies because different societies assign different bundles of proprietary rights. Justice also requires clarification. Unfortunately, justice involves potentially contradictory ideas whatever theory is adopted of its ultimate foundations or first principles. Justice under capitalism properly does not involve individual rights to liberty with respect to the allocation of scarce resources. What is uniquely characteristic of justice under capitalism is the assignment of individual property rights in production goods. Capitalist justice grounded on desert can be…

John Stuart Mill: <i>On Liberty</i>

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A remarkable aspect of John Stuart Mill's argument in On Liberty (1859) is his claim to be defending “one very simple principle”: that “the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own good, either physical or moral, is not a sufficient warrant” (OL i.9; Mill 1977: 223, emphasis added). Prevention of harm to others is a necessary condition for the legitimate exercise of any form of coercion against “human beings in the maturity of their faculties”. The implication usually seized upon by commentators, which, however, is not the only possible one, is that any adult ought to be free to do anything that does not harm other people. In other words, a civil society has no legitimate authority to regulate any conduct that does not pose a definite risk of harm to others, and should not…

Utilitarian Liberalism: Between Gray and Mill

Jonathan Riley

Political Science and International Relations · Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract John Gray’s hostile reading of J.S. Mill’s utilitarian doctrine of individual liberty and social authority is rejected in favour of a more sympathetic reading. According to the latter, Mill’s doctrine says that every civilized society ought to distribute equal rights to complete liberty of self‐regarding conduct. Although clarification of the relevant terms is required, utilitarian calculations are not needed to understand or apply this principle of self‐regarding liberty because it is already a utilitarian principle. Mill’s doctrine also says that every civilized society has legitimate authority to consider establishing rules of social (or other‐regarding) conduct, although society may rightfully decide to adopt broad laissez‐faire policies for some types of social conduct, including trade and expression. In particular, to promote the general welfare, any civil society should…