arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Jeremy Rayner

43 papers · 1985–2025

1985: 11986: 11987: 01988: 01989: 01990: 01991: 11992: 01993: 01994: 01995: 01996: 21997: 01998: 01999: 02000: 02001: 02002: 02003: 02004: 12005: 12006: 22007: 12008: 12009: 62010: 02011: 02012: 12013: 32014: 32015: 42016: 12017: 22018: 22019: 02020: 32021: 22022: 22023: 02024: 22025: 1
1985peak 6 in 20092025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 43 RSS

Patching vs Packaging in Policy Formulation: Assessing Policy Portfolio Design

Michael Howlett, Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · Politics and Governance · · cited 331× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Thinking about policy mixes is at the forefront of current research work in the policy sciences and raises many significant questions with respect to policy tools and instruments, processes of policy formulation, and the evolution of tool choices over time. Not least among these is how to assess the potential for multiple policy tools to achieve policy goals in an efficient and effective way. Previous conceptual work on policy mixes has highlighted evaluative criteria such as "consistency" (the ability of multiple policy tools to reinforce rather than undermine each other in the pursuit of individual policy goals), "coherence" (or the ability of multiple policy goals to co-exist with each other in a logical fashion), and "congruence" (or the ability of multiple goals and instruments to work together in a uni-directional or mutually supportive fashion) as important design principles and…

Introduction: Understanding integrated policy strategies and their evolution

Jeremy Rayner, Michael Howlett

Political Science and International Relations · Policy and Society · · cited 206× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Much attention in recent years has been focused on the idea of replacing patchworks of public policies in specific issue areas with more coordinated or ‘integrated’ policy strategies (IS). Such strategies are expected to display a match of coherent policy goals and consistent policy means which can produce policy outcomes optimally matched to specific large-scale problem contexts. Work on such strategies in areas such as Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM), National Forest Policies (NFPs), European transportation and energy planning, Mediterranean desertification and others, however, has shown a remarkable resilience of pre-existing policy elements, leading to policy failures and other sub-optimal outcomes. On the basis of a review of this literature, this article argues that the development of IS typically follows one or more of the processes Thelen et al. have…

The Constitution of Law: Legality in a Time of Emergency

Jeremy Rayner

Law · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 113× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Constitution of Law: Legality in a Time of Emergency , David Dyzenhaus, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006, pp. xv, 250. This book, which began life as the 2004 J.C. Smuts lectures at the University of Cambridge, is contribution to the burgeoning debate about emergency powers in post-9/11 liberal democracies. States that pride themselves on their commitment to constitutionalism and the rule of law find themselves engaged in the difficult task of suspending or restricting the operation of civil liberties while simultaneously trumpeting their own commitment to the liberal values that they purport to be defending against threat. As Dyzenhaus usefully reminds us, the predicament is not a new one. Smuts himself not only survived being on the wrong side of a colonial insurrection but, before becoming prime-minister of South Africa and a leading architect of apartheid (a paradigm…

Convergence and Divergence in ‘New Governance’ Arrangements: Evidence from European Integrated Natural Resource Strategies

Michael Howlett, Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Public Policy · · cited 76× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

To analyse convergence and divergence in Natural Resource New Governance Arrangements (NRNGAs) two regimes in the environmentally-related areas of forest and fisheries management are examined. The findings reveal limited convergence across sectors and countries in the general aims and ideas behind NGAs and evidence of significant policy divergence in the tools and mechanisms created for their implementation. The reasons for the differences lie primarily in the policy formulation process. While the impetus for the adoption of both NRNGAs is in the international and regional realms, without the force of either international law or competitive advantage, pressure for convergence is weak. Aspects of the policy formulation process, especially the manner in which the changing capacities of domestic public and private actors active in the affected resource policy arena interact to influence…

Third Generation Policy Diffusion Studies and the Analysis of Policy Mixes: Two Steps Forward and One Step Back?

Michael Howlett, Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis Research and Practice · · cited 73× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Three features of Gilardi and Meseguer's recent announcement of the start of a “third generation” of diffusion research in Europe require evaluation. First, conceptualization of policy diffusion is considered a task completed by the first two “generations”. Second, the work of the second generation is located against the background of globalization, democratization and the trend towards the adoption of market instruments. And, third, methodological sophistication is equated with the development of large-n empirical methodologies. Each of these features is discussed in turn. We argue that diffusion studies remain seriously hindered by a lack of clarity about the dependent variable under examination; second, that the peculiar interest of the second generation in measuring the impact of large scale diffusion mechanisms such as democratization, globalization and market orientation…

Learning and Change in the British Columbia Forest Policy Sector: A Consideration of Sabatier's Advocacy Coalition Framework

Ken Lertzman, Jeremy Rayner, Jeremy Wilson

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 66× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article uses British Columbia forest policy to test our ability to distinguish between policy change and policy learning using the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) developed by Paul Sabatier. The authors find the ACF a useful way of approaching policy change in this sector, but argue that finer discriminations are needed to detect policy learning. They argue that Sabatier underestimates the extent to which the legitimation function of key ideas forces dominant advocacy coalitions to respond to criticisms in ways that promote learning. They conclude that, in this case, adaptive strategies undertaken by a dominant advocacy coalition in response to criticism has resulted in policy-oriented learning that may cause a major policy shift without an externally induced crisis in the forest policy sector.

Policy Mixes and their Alignment over Time: Patching and stretching in the oil sands reclamation regime in Alberta, Canada

Jeremy Rayner, Michael Howlett, Adam Wellstead

Political Science and International Relations · Environmental Policy and Governance · · cited 53× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract When, why and how do policy mixes change and evolve? Much of the contemporary interest in such mixes is focused on distinguishing simple policies from more complex policy mixes, evaluating the relationships between single and multiple policy tools within a mix, and developing criteria to assess the likely performance of particular mixes. These are important and necessary analytical tasks. However, another required step in understanding policy mixes is to understand how and why mixes evolve and change over time and to determine whether any changes are an improvement. In this paper, we analyse the development of a complex policy mix in the case of reclamation and remediation of the Alberta oil sands from an earlier ‘simple goal, single instrument’ policy regime to a more complex one. This case study reveals the presence of at least two dynamic processes at work in policy mix…

Understanding Policy Change as a Historical Problem

Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis Research and Practice · · cited 45× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The search for alternatives to understanding time as “general linear reality” in models of policy change has usually resulted in theorists championing a single alternative; narratives, path dependency, or punctuated equilibrium. Following a suggestion by Haydu, the alternative to general linear reality is conceptualized as process sequencing. Narratives, path dependency and punctuated equilibrium are identified as different process sequencing methods for understanding change in particular contexts. Periodization, in the sense of identifying discrete sequences, is proposed as the special problem of process sequencing models and the de Vries model of “policy generation” is used to establish the importance of methodological pluralism and local explanation in explaining policy change. A preliminary classification of policy contexts is proposed as a means for determining the…

GOVERNANCE FROM THE BOTTOM UP: COMPLEXITY AND DIVERGENCE IN COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE

Giliberto Capano, Jeremy Rayner, Anthony R. Zito

Public Administration · Public Administration · · cited 42× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This symposium article examines how the threefold governance framework of the symposium actually works across multiple policy sectors and multiple politically systems. It undertakes a comparative survey of governance‐related developments across three policy sectors: environment, education/higher education and forests. To control for differentiation in political structures, the article studies the policy sectors with respect to three political systems Canada, England and Germany, taking into account the role of the European Union, the federal systems and international actors. This broad macro comparative focus enables the authors to make one of the first empirical efforts to assess the presence and sweep of governance arrangements across both policy sectors and states; and to assess the degree of convergence around particular governance practices.

Alberta's oil sands reclamation policy trajectory: the role of tense layering, policy stretching, and policy patching in long-term policy dynamics

Adam Wellstead, Jeremy Rayner, Michael Howlett

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Environmental Planning and Management · · cited 32× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

As the Canadian oil sands development matures, an increasingly important policy activity is reclamation. Reclamation has received limited attention compared with the broader discussion of oil sands expansion, however, and its past direction and future trajectory are unclear. Recent moves to reform the policy in Alberta have been interpreted simultaneously as a major change and a marginal adaptation to the existing framework. This article employs a historical-institutional perspective to help reconcile this debate and further understanding of changes to Alberta's oil sands reclamation policies over the past half century. It traces the factors and outlines the processes which have driven its evolution since 1963 with special attention paid to the 2011 Oil Sands Progressive Reclamation Strategy, the most recent attempt to reform oil sands reclamation policy. The article reveals a complex…

Coherence, Congruence and Consistency in Policy Mixes

Michael Howlett, Jeremy Rayner

Public Administration · · cited 25× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Thinking about policy mixes is at the forefront of current research work in the policy sciences and raises many significant questions with respect to policy tools and instruments, processes of policy formulation and the evolution of tool choices over time. Not least among these is the potential for multiple policy tools to achieve policy goals in an efficient and effective way. Previous work on policy mixes has highlighted evaluative criteria such as ‘consistency’ (the ability of multiple policy tools to reinforce rather than undermine each other in the pursuit of individual policy goals), ‘coherence’ (or the ability of multiple policy goals to co-exist with each other in a logical fashion) and ‘congruence’ (or the ability of multiple goals and instruments to work together in a unidirectional or mutually supportive fashion) as important design principles and measures of optimality in…

Diverse community energy futures in Saskatchewan, Canada

Margot Hurlbert, Mac Osazuwa-Peters, Jeremy Rayner +2 more

Sociology and Political Science · Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy · · cited 24× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This research explores peoples’ place attachment and context surrounding power production and energy futures. Facilitated, deliberative focus groups were conducted as comparative case studies in three fossil fuel-dependent cities in Saskatchewan Canada: Estevan (situated next to the provincial centers of coal, oil and gas production), Saskatoon (situated more northerly and furthest from coal, oil and gas production) and the capital city of Regina. (situated between the other two communities). This study supports the conclusions: (1) participants believed the focus groups improved their knowledge surrounding power production; (2) although there is strong support for wind and solar power production, there is a gap in implementation; and (3) place-based location impacts perceptions of power production sources. Participants were surveyed before and after focus group meetings to…

Understanding Policy Designs Over Time

Michael Howlett, Ishani Mukherjee, Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Thinking about policy mixes is at the forefront of current research work in the policy sciences and raises many significant questions with respect to policy tools and instruments, processes of policy formulation and the evolution of tool choices over time. Previous empirical work on the evolution of existing policy mixes has highlighted how mixes that have evolved over time encounter specific kinds of problems retaining their coherence and consistency. This chapter discusses how evolutionary processes affect policy designs and designing, why many existing policy mixes are sub-optimal and how this can be improved.

Patching vs Packaging in Policy Formulation: Complementary Effects, Goodness of Fit, Degrees of Freedom, and Feasibility in Policy Portfolio Design

Michael Howlett, Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 23× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Thinking about policy mixes is at the forefront of current research work in the policy sciences and raises many significant questions with respect to policy tools and instruments, processes of policy formulation, and the evolution of tool choices over time. Not least among these is how to assess the potential for multiple policy tools to achieve policy goals in an efficient and effective way. Previous conceptual work on policy mixes has highlighted evaluative criteria such as consistency (the ability of multiple policy tools to reinforce rather than undermine each other in the  pursuit of individual policy goals), coherence (or the ability of multiple policy goals to co-exist with each other in a logical fashion), and 'congruence (or the ability of multiple goals and instruments to work together in a uni-directional or mutually supportive fashion) as important design principles and…

Is Learning without teaching possible? The productive tension between network governance and reflexivity

Kathleen McNutt, Jeremy Rayner

Public Administration · Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning · · cited 21× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Theories of reflexive governance are closely linked with the claim that more traditional modes of coordination have been replaced by networked structures, allowing reflexivity to emerge and reflexive learning to function as a steering mechanism in rapidly changing policy contexts. This paper explores this connection between reflexivity, governance, learning and networks in societal transitions, focusing particularly on the claim that networks will deliver reflexive learning. Using network theories from both policy networks and network governance and a case study of the Canadian agricultural biotechnology (agbiotech) policy network, it suggests that the kind of learning produced in networks will be a function of network structure. In particular, higher order reflexive learning will be compromised by the inevitability of the political struggle for nodality or central place in networks and…

Philosophy into Dogma: The Revival of Cultural Conservatism

Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · British Journal of Political Science · · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The conservative revival that has taken place on both sides of the Atlantic in recent years has been an intellectual as well as a practical accomplishment. That this remarkable fact has received scant attention from political theorists can be attributed to two main causes. First, and less important, there has been an understandable tendency to focus on personalities and party politics where expediency blurs the sharp outlines of doctrine. As President Reagan confronts the problems of a second-term presidency, as Mrs Thatcher's iron grip on her party seems to weaken and as Chancellor Kohl or Mr Mulroney make their inevitable compromises and evasions, the conservative politician in office is revealed to be not dissimilar to his liberal or socialist predecessor. Now – as Elie Kedourie noted when asking the question ‘Is neo-conservatism viable?’ back in 1982 – this is only to be expected.…

The Integrity Gap: Canada's Environmental Policy and Institutions

Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Integrity Gap: Canada's Environmental Policy and Institutions, Eugene Lee and Anthony Perl, eds., Vancouver: UBC Press, 2003, pp. xi, 288. This collection, which grew out of papers presented at a conference at the Sookyung Centre for Canadian Studies in Seoul in 1999, is one of a number of recent publications to call attention to a peculiar feature of Canadian environmental policy. In spite of our much publicized commitment to greenery at home and our hectoring criticism of other countries' environmental policies abroad, our own record, when closely examined, proves to be lamentable and is actually getting worse in comparison with our counterparts in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). This yawning gulf between promise and performance is the “integrity gap” of Lee and Perl's title.

Implementing Integrated Land Management in Western Canada: Policy Reform and the Resilience of Clientelism

Jeremy Rayner, Michael Howlett

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Natural Resources Policy Research · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Much attention in recent years has been focused on the idea of replacing patchworks of public policies in specific issue areas with more coordinated or ‘integrated’ policy strategies (IS). Empirical work on such strategies, however, shows the remarkable resilience of pre-existing policy elements, often leading to policy failures and other sub-optimal outcomes in policy reform efforts. Case studies of Integrated Land Management (ILM) reform efforts in Western Canada reveal the continuing problems pre-existing clientelistic political arrangements cause for governments attempting to replace sector-specific plans with more integrated frameworks.

Power to the People? The Impacts and Outcomes of Energy Consultations in Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia

Linsay Martens, Kathleen McNutt, Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Like other policy subsectors, power generation has been affected by the governance changes of the last two decades, including a shift to more collaborative state-society relations. Collaborative governance implies new kinds of public engagement designed to provide both input legitimacy, through the involvement of a broader range of actors in policy design, and output legitimacy, through enhanced feedback and policy learning. This paper compares the impact of “governance-driven engagement” in the power generation subsectors in Nova Scotia and Saskatchewan, arguing that engagement increased the complexity of the policy mix in the subsector without succeeding in providing better feedback and learning. The paper notes a recent trend towards more expert-driven and less collaborative processes, as both provinces struggled to rationalize and simplify power generation policy goals and…

Policy Divergence as a Response to Weak International Regimes: The Formulation and Implementation of Natural Resource New Governance Arrangements in Europe and Canada

Michael Howlett, Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · Policy and Society · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article addresses the issue of convergence and divergence in Europe, and elsewhere, of a specific type of governance arrangement: “Natural Resource New Governance Arrangements” (NRNGAs). Two cases of the development of these regimes in the environmentally-related areas of forest and fisheries management are examined in Europe and North America, focusing on the Canadian experience in the latter case. The findings reveal significant similarities across sectors and countries but little evidence of any larger pattern of policy convergence. While the impetus for the adoption of both these NRNGAs lies in the international and regional realms, without the force of either international law or competitive advantage, consequential pressure for convergence is weak. It is proposed that the reasons for the differences in NGA adoptions thus lie primarily in the interaction of the…

Is There a Fourth Institutionalism? Ideas, Institutions and the Explanation of Policy Change

Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

While the concepts of policy paradigms and paradigmatic change now range freely through the policy literature, one of the most influential contributions to the currency of the paradigm and related concepts is that of Hall (1993). This is not to say that Hall invented the idea of transferring Kuhn's (1970) original ideas from the sociology of science to politics and policy. Scattered references are found much earlier, for example in Manning (1976, pp. 26–7), where the succession of dominant ideologies is treated as an example of paradigm shifts. Nonetheless, for modern policy studies, Hall (1993) is the canonical reference. This chapter explores the connection between the contemporary debates about policy paradigms and the tradition in which Hall (1993) was written, namely neo-institutionalism. It is argued that much of the value of the concept, together with some of the unresolved…

Patching versus packaging in policy formulation: assessing policy portfolio design

Michael Howlett, Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Thinking about policy mixes is at the forefront of current research work in the policy sciences and raises many significant questions with respect to policy tools and instruments, processes of policy formulation and the evolution of tool choices over time. Not least among these is how to assess the potential for multiple policy tools to achieve policy goals in an efficient and effective way. Previous conceptual work on policy mixes has highlighted evaluative criteria such as ‘consistency’ (the ability of multiple policy tools to reinforce rather than undermine each other in the pursuit of individual policy goals), ‘coherence’ (or the ability of multiple policy goals to co-exist with each other in a logical fashion) and ‘congruence’ (or the ability of multiple goals and instruments to work together in a uni-directional or mutually supportive fashion) as important design principles and…

On the Place of Ideas: A Reply to George Hoberg

Ken Lertzman, Jeremy Rayner, Jeremy Wilson

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In “Putting Ideas in Their Place,” George Hoberg raises some important and persistent questions about the explanation of policy change. In particular, he suggests that our attempt to demonstrate the role played by ideas in changing forest policy in British Columbia using Paul Sabatier's Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) gives excessive weight to ideas at the expense of more traditional concerns with power and interest. Although it is unclear whether he places the blame on the ACF itself or merely on the way we have employed it, the burden of his critique is that we fail to live up to our commitment to show how ideas and interests can be combined in a more comprehensive form of explanation than one which appeals to interests alone. Worse still, by our reckless overstatement of the case for ideas, we risk creating a “straw monster,” thereby warping the judgment of an entire generation of…

Autonomy, Centrality, and Persistence in Place: The Indigenous Movement and the Right to the City in Quito

Jeremy Rayner

Political Science and International Relations · City & Society · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article draws on ethnography with active supporters of the comunas (communes) in Quito to critically engage with the theory and politics of the right to the city. Communal activists—mostly affiliated with the Indigenous movement—forcefully claim rights to the democratic production and appropriation of space advocated by right to the city theorists, as they promote communal self‐management and the authority of communal assemblies over urbanization processes. At the same time, they have had little use for their constitutionally guaranteed right to the city. In carefully laying out the points of convergence between Lefebvrian right to the city theory and communal struggles, I also identify its limits and contradictions, especially: (1) the tension between “the collective power to reshape the process of urbanization” and the fixed forms and meanings of “the city,” and (2) the…

Hope and Fear Revisited: Did the Provincial Election of 2007 Mark the Transition to a Stable Two-Party System in Saskatchewan?

Jeremy Rayner, Tina L. Beaudry-Mellor

Sociology and Political Science · Canadian Political Science Review · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Saskatchewan provincial election of November 2007 brought the new Saskatchewan Party to power, ending 16 years of NDP rule. Observers have been divided over the significance of the rise of the Saskatchewan Party between those who see provincial politics as continuing on its course of ideological polarization between parties of the left and the right and those who detect a convergence on the political centre. Arguing that polarized politics is best understood by a historical approach to party systems, and convergence politics by an institutional approach, this paper examines the evidence for polarization and convergence in Saskatchewan politics. It concludes that there is evidence for a new party system based on convergence, a system that first appears in 2003 after a transitional period in the 1990s.