arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Janet Draper

28 papers · 1996–2013

1996: 31997: 31998: 31999: 22000: 32001: 02002: 32003: 32004: 12005: 12006: 12007: 02008: 02009: 22010: 12011: 02012: 12013: 1
1996peak 3 in 19962013

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 28 RSS

The Quality of Teachers' Professional Lives: Teachers and Job Satisfaction

Helen Fraser, Janet Draper, Warwick Taylor

Education · Evaluation & Research in Education · · cited 60× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Using data drawn from teachers with 5, 10 and 15 years of experience, this article examines specific aspects of job satisfaction and compares data from the different cohorts of teachers at different stages in their careers. It shows that teachers are very much in agreement about how they rate different facets of teaching in terms of satisfaction and there are particularly high correlations about the most and least satisfying aspects. It also shows that teachers with longer service are overall less satisfied with teaching, and on some specific aspects of satisfaction, differences are statistically significant.Only on two aspects,'recognition of efforts'and 'influence over school policies' are there notable gender differences, women being more satisfied with the former and men with the latter. Interestingly, however, secondary teachers are notably less satisfied than primary teachers with…

The Rocky Road to Headship

Janet Draper, Paquita McMichael

Education · Australian Journal of Education · · cited 38× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article considers career decision making in relation to headship/principalship. It explores the career options open to experienced and promoted teachers. Changes in the role of the headteacher and perceptions of the role of the head held by potential and recently appointed headteachers are reviewed. Findings on acting headship are used to illuminate headship itself and recruitment issues. Headship is analysed in terms of factors at four levels: the system, headship itself, the school and the individual. The outcome of a recent major inquiry into teachers' pay and conditions in Scotland and changes subsequently agreed is analysed for its likely impact on the nature of and recruitment to headship. The article concludes with some thoughts on the need for sufficient but not excessive numbers of good applicants for headship, for effective human resource management of teachers and…

Contextualising New Headship

Janet Draper, Paquita McMichael

Education · School Leadership and Management · · cited 37× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In order to examine approaches to headship amongst those appointed in the past three years 10 secondary school headteachers were interviewed. To contextualise the heads' experiences we examined the way in which they had prepared themselves for appointment, their aims in becoming heads (of particular schools in particular contexts), and the surprises they had faced. Since headship in its first years is often a time of anxiety we explored the supports obtained both within and outside schools and various means for strengthening those supports.

First Impressions: the new teacher induction arrangements in Scotland

Janet Draper, Jim O’Brien, Fiona Christie

Education · Journal of In-service Education · · cited 28× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

New arrangements for the induction of teachers in Scottish schools were introduced for school session 2002/03. Those completing initial teacher education (ITE) are now entitled to a one-year training post with a 70% workload, 30% of working time for professional development and 10% of an experienced teacher's time for support. Such inductees must meet the Standard for Full Registration (SFR) by the end of the year. Evidence on the implementation of the Teacher Induction Scheme was gathered at school, education authority and national level. This article reports the initial findings of the research project and suggests messages for the development of the scheme.

Finding our voices

Elisabeth Buggins, Mary Newburn, Gillian Fletcher +3 more

Education · British Journal of Midwifery · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This is the first of three articles looking at women's involvement in the planning and monitoring of the maternity services. This article focuses on the role of user representatives on maternity services liaison committees and the Voices training project.

Teachers' careers: accident or design?

Janet Draper, Helen Fraser, Warwick Taylor

Education · Teacher Development · · cited 17× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Careers in teaching may take many forms. Early work suggested many teachers seek horizontal opportunities rather than seeking promotion. This article reports the findings of a study of 192 teachers' past decision-making and their future career intentions. The teachers involved were from primary and secondary schools and had 5, 10 and 15 years of teaching experience. The data are used to construct a typology of career strategies which has implications for the range and type of professional development opportunities which might be made available to teachers. The findings show that the majority of teachers chose career paths which took them increasingly out of the classroom, and that many of those who stayed in the classroom did not do so by choice.

Teachers at work: early experiences of professional development

Janet Draper, Helen Fraser, Warwick Taylor

Education · Journal of In-service Education · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Professional development is expected to be a career long feature of teaching. The establishment of positive attitudes to professional development might be expected to be central to the early experiences of new teachers. The Scottish Study of Probationers (1988 - 1991) found that, during their probation, teachers reported spending more time proving they could do their jobs than they spent developing their practice. That increasing numbers of teachers begin and, in some cases, complete their probation on temporary contracts is likely to threaten the developmental potential of these early years in post. One-hundred-and-ninety-three teachers who completed probation during the period April 1995 to March 1996 rated their levels of satisfaction with their professional development experiences during probation, their clarity about assessment procedures and how far they had developed as…

Secondary School Identities and Career Decision Making

Janet Draper, Paquita McMichael

Education · Scottish Educational Review · · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Within this article we shall examine the assumption of the inevitability of applying for promotion. For this purpose we consider those who are interested in applying for promotion beyond Principal Teacher (head of subject department) level. We seek to identify the factors relating to self concept which might distinguish these teachers from those who plan to go no further up the ladder. The findings we report derive from a study of the identities of Scottish secondary school Principal Teachers and Assistant Headteachers, drawing on five elements of identity. While some elements of identity are found to vary with role, this only occurs when career intention is taken into account. A considerable proportion of both groups of staff do intend to seek further promotion, and links are drawn between these intentions and gender, age and length of time in post.

Leaving the register: Scottish teachers lost to the profession, 1997-98

Stephen Sharp, Janet Draper

Education · Journal of In-service Education · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract With recruitment into teaching becoming more difficult, the spectre of teacher shortage raises questions about teacher retention, especially given recent negative comment about teaching. This article offers an analysis of some of the characteristics of the 4000 Scottish teachers who left the profession in the year 1997-98. The study looked at the age, gender, sector, length of experience and registration status of those who left. It found that, while some left teaching early in their working lives and, as would be expected, a goodly number remain to nearly retirement age, there is a pattern of departures at all stages which constitutes a considerable loss of expertise to the profession. The findings generate questions about the average length of a modern teaching career and the costs of losing experienced staff well before retirement age.

Keeping the Show on the Road?

Janet Draper, Paquita McMichael

Education · Educational Management & Administration · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In a context where school leadership is identified as crucial to school performance and preparation for headship is expected, the role of the short-term acting head is increasingly anomalous and school leadership may be jeopardized. This article reports on a study of acting heads’ situations, experience and support in post. A range of reasons led to acting positions that were then held for widely varying periods and supported to very different degrees. Uncertainty on length of appointment, role boundaries and freedom to innovate led to some dissatisfaction and unwillingness to apply for permanent posts. The findings also raise issues for the maintenance of school performance in times of change and uncertainty.

Developing Effective School Leaders? Initial Views of the Scottish Qualification for Headship (SQH)

Jim O’Brien, Janet Draper

Education · Journal of In-service Education · · cited 11× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article outlines the rationale for and the development of the Scottish Qualification for Headship (SQH). It describes the context of standards and competences within which the SQH has been developed, and the nature of the consultation process undertaken. The qualification itself has a four-unit structure, with two units of school-based learning. It may be taken in two modes, a full four-unit form and an accelerated route for those with attestable experience. Evaluation data are reported from the first group of candidates to complete the qualification, who had followed the accelerated route. The findings are very positive, which might be expected from an enthusiastic first group of volunteers, but they also raise a series of questions for further study, particularly in relation to assumptions about a single model for headship of schools of all sizes and sectors, and for candidates…

I Am the Eye of the Needle and Everything Passes through Me: primary headteachers explain their retirement

Janet Draper, Paquita McMichael

Education · School Organisation · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT Fourteen early retiring primary headteachers in individual and group interviews discussed their decision to apply for early retirement. Retirement decisions were affected by ‘pushes’ from the system and ‘pulls’ towards retirement. Perceived pushes were external pressures, job expansion/overload, bureaucracy, local authority support, loss of job satisfaction and school relationships. Pulls comprised ‘facilitators’ (personal and financial) and ‘gains’ (control, opportunities, health and family). Pushes against retirement comprised losses of positive school relationships, role and status, job challenge and time structure. Early retirement amongst these headteachers appeared to derive from current retirement trends, job stress and lack of management support.

Local management of the scottish qualification for headship

Daniel Murphy, Janet Draper, Jim O’Brien +1 more

Education · Journal of In-service Education · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The Scottish Qualification for Headship (SQH) has been designed for delivery through a partnership of higher education institutions (HEIs) and local authorities (LAs). The study reported in this article aimed to give an account of the processes of management of SQH at LA level. This article highlights the liaison and support role played by those who coordinated SQH within local authorities. Conclusions are drawn about the complexities of the coordination role and the centrality of adequate resourcing for the success of the programme that has a substantial workbased learning element. Implications are identified for future continuing professional development (CPD) strategies

The Induction of Beginning Teachers in Scotland and Hong Kong: Getting it Right?

Janet Draper, Victor Forrester

Education · Research in Comparative and International Education · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Where the continuing professional development (CPD) process is being increasingly articulated and circumscribed by policy and central specification, the initial year of teaching may significantly shape career-long expectations of CPD. This article contrasts the early experiences of beginning secondary teachers in Scotland and Hong Kong and the emergent model that highlights a tension between the systems' support structures and individual autonomy. To resolve this impasse, the authors conclude by arguing for a different model that places as synonymous new teachers' induction, CPD and approaches to becoming autonomous.

All together better

Elisabeth Buggins, Meg Gready, Gillian Fletcher +1 more

Education · British Journal of Midwifery · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This is the second in a series of articles looking at women's involvement in the planning and monitoring of maternity services. This article focuses on the value of effective maternity service liaison committees to purchasers, providers and users of the service.

Fatherhood As Transition: The Contemporary Relevance of Transition Theory

Janet Draper

Gender Studies · Open Research Online (The Open University) · · cited 6× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter explores the contemporary utility of ritual transition theory (Van
\nGennep [1909], 1960). Drawing on qualitative data generated during a
\nlongitudinal ethnographic study of men’s transition to fatherhood, the paper
\ndescribes how the three phases associated with the theory - separation,
\ntransition and re-incorporation - provide insight into men’s transition to
\ncontemporary fatherhood. It is argued therefore, that despite its earlier
\nstructural-functionalist roots the theory remains a valuable and relevant
\nframework illuminating contemporary transitions across the life course.

‘It's almost like a secondment’: parenting as professional development for teachers

Brian Cosford, Janet Draper

Education · Teacher Development · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract There are many sources of professional development. This article considers the experience of parenting as a source of personal and professional development in Scotland. Nias (1989), in her work on teacher identity, stresses the importance of the personal dimension in effective teaching. Becoming a parent has been identified as a significant transition in adult life. Such a major influence on personal development seems likely to impinge on how teachers play their professional roles. Some of this influence would be expected to relate to the effect of having increased family and domestic commitments, which compete with limited time. Sikes (1997) explores the impact of parenthood on teachers' definitions of their job. In contrast to the emphasis on problems associated with being a parent teacher, Sikes identified a productive link between parenting and teaching, with parent…

Choosing teaching in Hong Kong: a strategy to survive the financial crisis?

Janet Draper

Education · Educational Research · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Background: Hong Kong is currently a Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China. It has autonomy over many policy areas, including finance and education. It is a community of seven million people, which has changed its focus and identity significantly over the last 25 years, from predominantly manufacturing to a service and knowledge economy with particular strengths in financial services. Purpose: This paper will consider the market for teacher education places and the market for teachers, and explore the career intention and commitment implications of high numbers of well qualified applicants applying for teaching in the context of reduced work opportunities elsewhere, an increasing higher education focus on intake scores and the challenge, for the teaching profession and the education system, of teaching becoming less secure work. Sources of evidence…

Crossing the threshold: students' experiences of the transition from student to staff nurse

Janet Draper, Shelagh Sparrow, Donna Gallagher

Education · Open Research Online (The Open University) · · cited 3× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Current policy in the health services emphasises nursing students’ fitness to practice at the point of registration. There has also been some suggestion that pre-registration education has not equipped them with the necessary knowledge and skills. Other research findings have indicated that students can find this transition stressful. Due to the massive investment in nurse education and the need to retain nurses in the workforce, we wanted to understand the factors that might better support this transition. Using telephone interviews with former students of The Open University part-time, distance learning, pre-registration nursing programme, we explored nurses’ experiences of their first 3-6 months of qualified practice. A number of recurring themes emerged which were then exposed to theoretical analysis using Van Gennep’s theory of transition and Bridges’ work on organisational change.…

The Professional Formation and Learning of New Secondary Teachers in Hong Kong: a dim–sum model?

Victor Forrester, Janet Draper

Education · Teacher Development · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Changing educational priorities are reflected both in the literature and the models that seek to describe initial teachers' professional formation and learning. However, do new teachers' experiences conform to these models? A sampling of Hong Kong secondary school teachers over their first year as full-time teachers provides data from questionnaires and longitudinal interviews supporting a variety of processes and related models which highlight that becoming a teacher reflects individual differences. To account for this array of individual differences an interaction model is proposed that reflects the Chinese cultural context of this study - the 'dim-sum' model - a model that sites initial teachers' professional formation and learning within a multi-perspective and interactive learning context. </br>[Copyright of Teacher Development is the property of Routledge. Full article may…

Continuity or Change? The Initial Impact of the Post-McCrone Agreement

Janet Draper, Stephen J. Sharp

Education · Scottish Educational Review · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Changes in teachers’ work, designed to modernise the teaching profession, and derived from the Agreement reached following the ‘McCrone Report, A Teaching Profession for the 21st Century’ in 2000, began to be introduced in Scotland in 2001. The spirit of the original report emphasised change of several types and recommended moves to enhance professional autonomy. This paper offers an initial analysis of the impact of these changes on teachers’ work, continuing professional development (CPD), careers and autonomy. The findings reported are drawn from 128 teachers in their fifteenth year of teaching, who have taken part since 1988 in a longitudinal study which has explored teachers’ work, careers and development. Data were collected by questionnaire from the full sample and by interview from a sub-set. The analysis is shaped by Kelly’s GLAD model for reviewing change and concludes that…

Keeping the Show on the Road?: The Role of the Acting Headteacher

Janet Draper, Paquita McMichael

Education · Educational Management & Administration · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In a context where school leadership is identified as crucial to school performance and preparation for headship is expected, the role of the short-term acting head is increasingly anomalous and school leadership may be jeopardized. This article reports on a study of acting heads’ situations, experience and support in post. A range of reasons led to acting positions that were then held for widely varying periods and supported to very different degrees. Uncertainty on length of appointment, role boundaries and freedom to innovate led to some dissatisfaction and unwillingness to apply for permanent posts. The findings also raise issues for the maintenance of school performance in times of change and uncertainty.

Converting from Secondary to Primary: Strategic or magnetic decisions?

Janet Draper

Education · School Leadership and Management · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT Some teachers in Scotland choose to change sector from secondary to primary or vice versa, which requires them to take a shortened course of training, a 'conversion course', and to be on probation in the new sector for a year. This paper analyses teachers' motives for changing sector and distinguishes between strategic reasons for converting (e.g. more jobs in the new sector), and magnetic reasons, either intrinsic attractions of working in the new sector (e.g. a preferred age group) or disincentives in the current sector. Magnetic reasons were more frequently reported. Some teachers found their expectations of the new sector were unrealistic in practice.

Widening participation in pre-registration education in the United Kingdom - alumni and employer accounts of a unique part-time supported open learning route

Janet Draper

Education · Open Research Online (The Open University) · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Introduction This study explored the impact of The Open University’s (OU) unique pre-registration nursing programme (PRNP) with particular reference to students’ employability, career progression and its contribution to developing the nursing workforce across the UK. The PRNP is the only part-time supported open learning programme in the UK leading to registration as a nurse. Purposefully designed for healthcare support workers (HCSWs) who are sponsored by their employers, the programme promotes widening participation to higher education (HE) and enables employers to invest in and develop their support workforce. Partnership working is crucial to its success. The project is timely in relation to UK policy across both the HE and health sectors. In HE, there is current emphasis on widening participation (HEFCE, 2010), employability and adopting more flexible approaches to learning…