arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Isabelle Freiling

19 papers · 2017–2026

2017: 12018: 02019: 12020: 12021: 22022: 22023: 42024: 12025: 32026: 4
2017peak 4 in 20232026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–19 of 19 RSS

Fact-checking as risk communication: the multi-layered risk of misinformation in times of COVID-19

Nicole M. Krause, Isabelle Freiling, Becca Beets +1 more

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Risk Research · · cited 430× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The emergence of the 2019 novel coronavirus has led to more than a pandemic—indeed, COVID-19 is spawning myriad other concerns as it rapidly marches around the globe. One of these concerns is a surge of misinformation, which we argue should be viewed as a risk in its own right, and to which insights from decades of risk communication research must be applied. Further, when the subject of misinformation is itself a risk, as in the case of COVID-19, we argue for the utility of viewing the problem as a multi-layered risk communication problem. In such circumstances, misinformation functions as a meta-risk that interacts with and complicates publics’ perceptions of the original risk. Therefore, as the COVID-19 “misinfodemic” intensifies, risk communication research should inform the efforts of key risk communicators. To this end, we discuss the implications of risk research for efforts to…

Believing and sharing misinformation, fact-checks, and accurate information on social media: The role of anxiety during COVID-19

Isabelle Freiling, Nicole M. Krause, Dietram A. Scheufele +1 more

Sociology and Political Science · New Media & Society · · cited 225× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The COVID-19 pandemic went hand in hand with what some have called a "(mis)infodemic" about the virus on social media. Drawing on partisan motivated reasoning and partisan selective sharing, this study examines the influence of political viewpoints, anxiety, and the interactions of the two on believing and willingness to share false, corrective, and accurate claims about COVID-19 on social media. A large-scale 2 (emotion: anxiety vs relaxation) × 2 (slant of news outlet: MSNBC vs Fox News) experimental design with 719 US participants shows that anxiety is a driving factor in belief in and willingness to share claims of any type. Especially for Republicans, a state of heightened anxiety leads them to believe and share more claims. Our findings expand research on partisan motivated reasoning and selective sharing in online settings, and enhance the understanding of how anxiety shapes…

The ‘infodemic’ infodemic: Toward a more nuanced understanding of truth-claims and the need for (not) combatting misinformation

Nicole M. Krause, Isabelle Freiling, Dietram A. Scheufele

Sociology and Political Science · SocArXiv (OSF Preprints) · · cited 60× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

(Mis)information scholarship struggles to assist policy actors in assessing the relative accuracy of science-related truth claims as well as their potential threat. This limited ability to produce translational research stems in part from conceptualizations of dis- and misinformation that pay insufficient attention to an information ecosystem in which defining “accuracy” is complicated by intersecting uncertainties associated with the nature of science, sociopolitical climates, and media systems. These uncertainties introduce compounding error in accuracy assessments, and they demand more nuanced understandings of mis- and disinformation than those which currently underlie discussions of the “infodemic.” Here, we propose a framework for evaluating claims in terms of a collection of intersecting attributes beset by uncertainty. We apply our framework to real-world examples and conclude…

Science and Ethics of “Curing” Misinformation

Isabelle Freiling, Nicole M. Krause, Dietram A. Scheufele

Sociology and Political Science · The AMA Journal of Ethic · · cited 37× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A growing chorus of academicians, public health officials, and other science communicators have warned of what they see as an ill-informed public making poor personal or electoral decisions. Misinformation is often seen as an urgent new problem, so some members of these communities have pushed for quick but untested solutions without carefully diagnosing ethical pitfalls of rushed interventions. This article argues that attempts to "cure" public opinion that are inconsistent with best available social science evidence not only leave the scientific community vulnerable to long-term reputational damage but also raise significant ethical questions. It also suggests strategies for communicating science and health information equitably, effectively, and ethically to audiences affected by it without undermining affected audiences' agency over what to do with it.

Public engagement: Faculty lived experiences and perspectives underscore barriers and a changing culture in academia

Mikhaila N. Calice, Becca Beets, Luye Bao +7 more

Education · PLoS ONE · · cited 36× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The idea of faculty engaging in meaningful dialogue with different publics instead of simply communicating their research to interested audiences has gradually morphed from a novel concept to a mainstay within most parts of the academy. Given the wide variety of public engagement modalities, it may be unsurprising that we still lack a comprehensive and granular understanding of factors that influence faculty willingness to engage with public audiences. Those nuances are not always captured by quantitative surveys that rely on pre-determined categories to assess scholars' willingness to engage. While closed-ended categories are useful to examine which factors influence the willingness to engage more than others, it is unlikely that pre-determined categories comprehensively represent the range of factors that undermine or encourage engagement, including perceptual influences…

Polarized platforms? How partisanship shapes perceptions of “algorithmic news bias”

Mikhaila N. Calice, Luye Bao, Isabelle Freiling +6 more

Communication · New Media & Society · · cited 32× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The use of artificial intelligence-based algorithms for the curation of news content by social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter has upended the gatekeeping role long held by traditional news outlets. This has caused some US policymakers to argue that platforms are skewing news diets against them, and such claims are beginning to take hold among some voters. In a nationally representative survey experiment, we explore whether traditional models of media bias perceptions extend to beliefs about algorithmic news bias. We find that partisan cues effectively shape individuals’ attitudes about algorithmic news bias but have asymmetrical effects. Specifically, whereas in-group directional partisan cues stimulate bias perceptions for members of both parties, Democrats, but not Republicans, also respond to out-group cues. We conclude with a discussion about the implications for the…

Our changing information ecosystem for science and why it matters for effective science communication

Nicole M. Krause, Isabelle Freiling, Dietram A. Scheufele

Sociology and Political Science · SocArXiv (OSF Preprints) · · cited 18× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Current information ecologies present unique opportunities to communicate science and engage diverse publics in science. Unfortunately, they also present unique challenges. Here, we outline how the public sphere for science is transforming as media evolve, and we connect these changes to the high-stakes issue context of COVID-19. We argue that scientific organizations’ struggles to adapt to evolving media are linked, in part, to asymmetries in which social media platforms prevent researchers from producing reliable data that could inform institutional change and improve science communication. This has been apparent in studies of echo chambers and filter bubbles. Producing a more usable evidence base, we conclude, will require that scholars (a) obtain access to proprietary data, (b) reconceptualize information ecologies as social systems, (c) avoid ceding core research tasks to…

Detecting misinformation in online social networks: A think-aloud study on user strategies

Isabelle Freiling

Sociology and Political Science · Studies in Communication and Media · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Although online social networks (OSN) facilitate the distribution of misinformation, one way of reducing the spread of false information in OSN is for users to detect it. Building on the framework of how audiences act to authenticate information, this study provides a user perspective on which strategies people use in evaluating information in OSN. In 15 qualitative interviews, participants were asked to think aloud while evaluating whether the content of posts from their own newsfeeds and of interviewer-supplied posts was true or false. Their answers were analyzed to determine which evaluation strategies they used. Analyzing participants’ thoughts as they evaluate information is more reliable than directly asking participants which strategies they think they use. Results show that users’ strategies in information evaluation are searching for more information, knowledge of account or…

Correcting climate change misinformation on social media: Reciprocal relationships between correcting others, anger, and environmental activism

Isabelle Freiling, Jörg Matthes

Sociology and Political Science · Computers in Human Behavior · · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Although correcting others on social media is a frequently used strategy to combat the spreading of misinformation, we lack knowledge on the drivers of such corrective efforts. We theorize that climate change-related anger and political environmental activism can explain why people chose to correct others on social media. We further assume reciprocal relationships in which the act of correcting others predicts anger and political environmental activism. By doing so, we extend the concept of expression effects of correcting others from a cognitive level that predicts activism to an affective level (i.e., predicting anger). Structural equation modeling using data from a two-wave panel survey (N = 549) showed reciprocal relations between political environmental activism and correcting perceived climate change misinformation. Correction was further positively related to climate…

Support for misinformation regulation on social media: It is the perceived harm of misinformation that matters, not the perceived amount

Isabelle Freiling, Marlis Stubenvoll, Jörg Matthes

Sociology and Political Science · Policy & Internet · · cited 11× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Responding to harmful content on social media, calls for regulations are coming up to break down the black boxes of social media platforms in handling misinformation. Examples are requiring cooperations with fact‐checkers or the government stepping in. So far, there is a lack of knowledge about predictors of policy attitudes in the context of misinformation besides attitudes toward and perceptions of censorship. Using a two‐wave panel study in Germany at the beginning of the COVID‐19 pandemic and 8 months in, we examine the role of perceived misinformation exposure, perceived harm of misinformation, and trust in institutions involved in regulating misinformation on public support for misinformation regulation. Results show that trust in media and democracy increases policy support over time. Furthermore, perceived exposure to misinformation does not influence policy attitudes…

Religious values and confidence in science: Perceived tensions and common ground

Isabelle Freiling, Michael A. Cacciatore, Meaghan McKasy

Health · PLoS ONE · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

While confidence in science is high compared to other institutions, many Americans question whether scientists share their values, including religious ones. Narratives surrounding science and religion often focus on a conflict between the two, but religious people, especially, tend to see their religious views as in line with science. Using survey data of two probability samples representative of U.S. adults, we examine how religious views, including perceptions of conflict and harmony between science and religion, predict confidence in science. We found that while general perceptions of religion and science as conflicting negatively predicted confidence in science, when individuals think religion endorses protecting the planet, their confidence in science was higher. The results suggest that attitudes toward religion and science are more nuanced than is often acknowledged and that…

Addressing social media platforms’ influence on academic research

Raffael Heiss, Isabelle Freiling

Sociology and Political Science · Humanities and Social Sciences Communications · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Social media platforms play a central role in shaping today's information ecosystem, yet access to both their internal data and even publicly visible content remains tightly restricted for academic researchers. This stands in sharp contrast to other industries, such as food and pharmaceuticals, where researchers can independently study product ingredients and effects. As a result, academic research on social media faces an unprecedented dependency on industry-controlled data, increasing the risk of bias and potentially distorting the evidence needed for effective regulation and policymaking. Drawing on research from other disciplines, we examine how industry influence operates and how researchers' reliance on platforms for data may amplify industry influence. We identify four challenges in collaborations between researchers and social media platforms: restricted data access, selective…

Understanding Knowledge Among White, Black, and Hispanic Audiences: Media Attention and Inequities in Factual and Perceived Knowledge

Sara K. Yeo, Michael A. Cacciatore, Isabelle Freiling +4 more

Sociology and Political Science · Mass Communication & Society · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

There is a normative assumption that a knowledgeable populace can make informed civic decisions that are central to the well-being of society. Yet, access to knowledge is not equitable. Using the context of science information, the present work is a step toward understanding inequities in knowledge and addressing this challenge among underserved groups. A paucity of data presents a critical challenge in studying and understanding underserved communities’ access to knowledge. Here, we rely on a probability sample of American adults that includes oversampling of two hardly reached populations, Black and Hispanic Americans, to examine socioeconomic inequalities in science knowledge and the contributions of media attention on these gaps in knowledge. We found that SES positively predicted factual knowledge among all the groups in our sample but was only positively associated with perceived…

Scan method tracks reader attention, engagement

Isabelle Freiling, Lisa Weidmüller

Sociology and Political Science · Newspaper Research Journal · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A methodological comparison was conducted between copy testing, eye-tracking and a relatively new scan method, where panelists record where they stop reading a news item. Results show: news item characteristics that proved most influential in previous research also significantly affect reading behavior measured with the scan method. By being precise and more practicable than copy testing and eye-tracking, the scan method can help the struggling newspaper industry to better understand their readers.

Do algorithmic information environments mark the end of media effects research?

Isabelle Freiling, Jakob Ohme, Isabel I. Villanueva +1 more

Human-Computer Interaction · Annals of the International Communication Association · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Algorithmically curated information environments are beginning to challenge both long-standing notions of what media effects look like and our ability to study them directly. Algorithmic curation and microtargeting of content based on users’ behavioral and digital trace data pose conceptual as well as methodological challenges to our understanding of communication effects. These challenges increasingly introduce significant distortions to our field’s current ability to transparently and systematically iterate between theory and empirical testing. In this article, we provide a blueprint for how a systematic, empirical rethinking, and testing of communication effects theory can look like in an era of what we call preference-based information ecologies (PBIEs). Specifically, we discuss 9 current challenges to theorizing that are conceptual and methodological in nature and discuss…

Cognitive and affective predictors of sharing intentions on social media: the role of anxiety, social benefits, and risks

Isabelle Freiling, Anja Stević

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Risk Research · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Sharing information and participating in discussions on social media involves social risks and benefits. It is unclear whether those risk and benefit perceptions predict sharing intentions. Previous research on sharing news has shown emotions like anxiety to predict sharing intentions, but it remains unclear whether this also applies beyond sharing news. This study builds on the Appraisal Tendency Framework and the social calculus perspective. Using an online experiment (N = 523), with a 2 (emotional state: anxiety vs. relaxation) by 3 (consequences: social benefits vs. social risks vs. none) design, this study examines cognitive (risks, benefits) and affective (anxiety) predictors of sharing intentions on gun laws. Results show that benefit perceptions and anxiety positively predicted sharing intentions, while risk perceptions and interactions with cognitive and affective factors did…

When AI and Humans Produce Partial Truths: Examining Acceptability of Perceived Error and Perceived Associated Harms

Isabelle Freiling, Sara K. Yeo, Haoning Xue

Sociology and Political Science · Health Communication · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Existing research on misinformation often focuses on messages that are completely false. For greater external validity, our experiment examines reactions to messages that contain both false and accurate information. Using a framework of uncertainty attributes of truth claims, we examine perceptions of how acceptable error is when the source is (perceived to be) human-only, generative artificial intelligence-only, or a combination of the two. We examine the acceptability of perceived error and harms associated with the message and its topic, and how they interact as predictors of intentions to engage with the message or intervene.

Resistant and Misinformed: Understanding the Role of Elite Perceptions and Resistance Strategies Against COVID-19 Reporting in Legacy Media in Adopting COVID-19 Misperceptions

Marlis Stubenvoll, Isabelle Freiling, Jörg Matthes

Sociology and Political Science · Digital Journalism · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

At the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, individuals strongly relied on legacy media for current information. At the same time, parts of the population grew increasingly critical of the evidence presented in legacy media, leading them to resist reported facts. This study examines how and under which circumstances audiences resist journalistic evidence and adopt misperceptions about COVID-19. We theorize that citizens’ perceptions of elite manipulative intent drive resistance against legacy media reporting on COVID-19 and COVID-19 misperceptions. We tested this relationship across two panel studies in Austria. In Study 1 (NTime1 = 731, NTime2 = 416), we found that perceptions of elite manipulative intent only explained citizens’ misperceptions when their level of anxiety was low. In Study 2 (NTime1 = 912, NTime2 = 511), we reexamined this relationship and additionally included four…

The Role of Media in Political Polarization| The Way We Use Social Media Matters: A Panel Study on Passive Versus Active Political Social Media Use and Affective Polarization

Jörg Matthes, Andreas Nanz, Ruta Kaskeleviciute +8 more

Communication · DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

When looking at the origins of affective polarization, political communication scholars have frequently pointed to social media. In this article, we theorize that the relationship between social media use and affective polarization depends on the ways in which social media are used. Based on two-wave panel data collected during a national election campaign, our findings suggest that only active political uses of social media (i.e., sharing, posting, or commenting) foster affective polarization; in contrast, passive uses (i.e., informing oneself) do not. Looking at reciprocal relationships, we found that affective polarization did not significantly predict active or passive political social media use over time. Overall, our findings support the argument that social media are neither unconditionally detrimental nor beneficial for society and democracy.