arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Hugo Storey

37 papers · 1998–2023

1998: 11999: 02000: 02001: 02002: 02003: 12004: 02005: 02006: 02007: 12008: 22009: 02010: 02011: 12012: 12013: 22014: 32015: 22016: 22017: 12018: 22019: 12020: 22021: 32022: 02023: 12
1998peak 12 in 20232023

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 37 RSS

EU Refugee Qualification Directive: a Brave New World?

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 69× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article aims to map some of the major implications for asylum–related law in Europe of the Refugee Qualification Directive, which twenty-four EU Member States were required to implement by 10 October 2006. It seeks to build on important studies of the Directive completed by, among others, Hemme Battjes, in his book European Asylum Law and International Law, Nijhoff 2006, and Jane McAdam, in her book Complementary Protection in International Refugee Law, OUP 2007, albeit it takes a different view of some key questions. Part 2 deals with the impact of the Directive on the application and interpretation of the 1951 Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol. It is argued that, even read simply as a set of provisions giving interpretive guidelines on the application of the Refugee Convention, it affects many things concerned with refugee eligibility, since these provisions cover key…

The 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and its 1967 Protocol: A Commentary

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 61× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This book will bestride the world of refugee law like a colossus for some years to come. The Walther-Schücking Institute for International Law, the Deutsche Forchungsgemeinschaft (German Research Foundation) and OUP, which in various ways have underwritten it, can take pride. Its title is far too modest. It is not just a commentary; it is also a digest, exposition, treatise, discourse, exegesis and more. Commentary on each and every provision of the CSR51 and its CSRP67 is accompanied by up-to-date guidance on their interpretation and application. Major developments in the jurisprudence and in academic studies are distilled. Its commitment to a truly international understanding of the CSR51, which it rightly refers to as the ‘Magna Carta’ of international refugee law, is reflected in the diversity of its scholarship: it weaves together forty-eight contributions from sixteen different…

Armed Conflict in Asylum Law: The "War-Flaw"

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · Refugee Survey Quarterly · · cited 40× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article charts the difficulties refugee law -and more widely the legal regime governing international protection -has encountered from the outset in dealing with asylum-related claims by persons fleeing armed conflict. It analyses the origins of the prevailing " exceptionality approach" , which regards such claims as unable to succeed unless they can make out a special case. It explains why its opposite, the " normalcy approach" , equally does not resolve underlying problems.

The Ashgate Research Companion to Migration Law, Theory and Policy

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 35× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This Companion is the latest in the ground-breaking Ashgate series, Law & Migration. Operating a ‘vastly expanded research agenda’ covering the current state of literature on migration law, theory and policy and its likely future developments, this book ranges far and wide. Despite the best efforts of its editor, Satvinder Juss, to give coherent structure to its contents, the diversity of its chapters - penned by some thirty-six contributors - leaves the impression of a vast, sprawling compendium. It is difficult to follow the ordering of its seven parts, which start with a critical analysis of the regional European context then move to a global-level discussion of several themes, with the more theoretical contributions left till last. The titles of some of the sections, eg, ‘Part IV: Emerging Paradigms of Legal Protection’, only weakly match their actual contents. Juss candidly…

What Constitutes Persecution? Towards a Working Definition

Hugo Storey

Sociology and Political Science · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 25× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Journal Article What Constitutes Persecution? Towards a Working Definition Get access Hugo Storey Hugo Storey Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Google Scholar International Journal of Refugee Law, Volume 26, Issue 2, June 2014, Pages 272–285, https://doi.org/10.1093/ijrl/eeu017 Published: 23 June 2014

Foundations of International Migration Law

Hugo Storey

Health · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Minimalistically defined by Louis Varlez in 1927 as the body of international norms applicable to migration, international migration law continues to struggle to achieve recognition as a discrete body of international law ranking alongside international criminal law, the law of the sea, international economic law, etc. In a weighty study, featuring sixteen different contributions by leading scholars, the editors seek to furnish an overview of the subject in an accessible foundational text that includes maps, case studies, break-out boxes and a helpful glossary. International migration law is seen to have three pillars: human rights, state sovereignty and international cooperation. The editors do not flinch from accepting that in key respects international migration law remains a fragmented ‘unassembled jigsaw’ or a building with various sites still ‘under construction’. In their…

Credibility Assessment in Claims based on Persecution for Reasons of Religious Conversion and Homosexuality: A Practitioners Approach

Uwe Berlit, Harald Doerig, Hugo Storey

Artificial Intelligence · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 17× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In June 2015 the European Chapter of the International Association of Refugee Law Judges (IARLJ) convened a workshop on credibility assessment in claims based on persecution for reasons of religious conversion and homosexuality. Prompting this choice of subject were recent judgments of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) which define requirements for the recognition as a refugee of asylum seekers who base their claims on persecution of that type.1 Forty Judges from thirteen EU member states had collected and made available to the workshop their most important national judgments and - if available - the national questionnaires used as the basis of the applicant’s interview by the government authorities. The judges’ development of criteria for the assessment of the credibility of asylum seekers will be summarized in the following. The article starts with an overview of the…

The Law of Refugee Status, 2nd edition: Paradigm Lost?

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Publication of this book is a major event in refugee law. It is over twenty-three years since The Law of Refugee Status (LRS1)1 came out. True, Hathaway has kept all of us apprised of developments in his thinking since. In addition to his other major work, The Rights of Refugees under International Law (RRIL),2 he has been a much-consulted expert, a prolific writer of articles, and a generous giver of lectures and seminars around the world, but that is quite another thing to knowing how he sees his subsequent thinking fitting in with the analytical framework famously set out in LRS1. Now we know. But the second edition (LRS2) is not just an update. Superficially, the fact that its seven chapter topics for the most part track those of the original edition might suggest otherwise, but as explained in the Introduction, ‘it is in truth largely an original analysis that retains little beyond…

The Internal Protection Alternative in Refugee Law: Treaty Basis and Scope of Application under the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees and Its 1967 Protocol

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

At last, a book on the Internal Protection Alternative (IPA)! Given how much the issue has vexed refugee law, a monograph devoted to this subject is long overdue. Few issues have exercised decision makers and scholars as much, with even the name of the test being often contentious. Schultz’s choice of title will perhaps prove the last word – consigning the ‘Internal Flight Alternative’ (IFA), the ‘Internal Relocation Alternative’ (IRA), and other formulations to mere historical record. It is worthwhile setting out her reasons for rejecting other formulations. She writes: Compared to the IFA, which suggests a backward-looking (only) inquiry, the IPA more clearly captures the fact that state or state-like protection must be presently, and durably, available. Further, ‘IPA’ seems more accurate than ‘internal relocation’ for a few reasons. First, the latter phrase has been historically used…

In Flight from Conflict and Violence: UNHCR’s Consultations on Refugee Status and Other Forms of International Protection

Hugo Storey

Sociology and Political Science · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This is primarily a source book of the consultation process, encompassing three expert roundtables, towards the elaboration of guidelines on international protection. The first of these roundtables, held in Arusha in 2011, resulted in the publication of the Summary Conclusions of the Expert Meeting on Complementarities between International Refugee Law, International Criminal Law and International Human Rights Law. The second was held in Cape Town in 2012 and the third in Montevideo in 2013. The book contains two appendices, one setting out the Cape Town roundtable’s Summary Conclusions on International Protection of Persons Fleeing Armed Conflict and Other Situations of Violence. Five of the studies commissioned for this roundtable are reincarnated as chapters in the book, albeit refined and updated – to the end of 2015 seemingly. The other appendix gives the text of the Montevideo…

States, the Law and Access to Refugee Protection: Fortresses and Fairness

Hugo Storey

Sociology and Political Science · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 11× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

What has been happening on the ground to people seeking asylum around the world? What are the obstacles they confront? This collection goes a long way to answering these questions, by means of a number of contributions providing comparative as well as academic and practitioner perspectives focusing on the situation in a diverse range of countries or regions: Australia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, the European Union (EU), Lebanon, South Africa, Turkey, and the United States (US). The book’s contributions focus on two different types of obstacles faced by asylum seekers in gaining access to international refugee protection: physical obstacles, in terms of access to territory; and legal barriers to accessing a fair and effective asylum procedure (‘access to asylum justice’). The book is in three parts. Part I commences with an analysis by the editors of key concepts and related…

The Meaning of “Protection” within the Refugee Definition

Hugo Storey

Sociology and Political Science · Refugee Survey Quarterly · · cited 11× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

While the notion of “protection” forms part of the refugee definition, any clear definition of this term has yet to emerge. With a view to remedying that, this article re-examines certain basic assumptions often made about protection within the refugee definition so as to clarify its meaning. It first delves into the very notion of protection as possessing both a negative content (absence of persecution) and a positive content (consisting of a securement of basic human rights). In order to give effect to this positive content, the article identifies five qualities that protection must have, while discussing as well the requirements relating to internal relocation/protection. The article then tackles the glaring failure of refugee law to move beyond vague utterances about States having a basic duty to protect their citizens and seeks to clarify the appropriate concept of the State to be…

Consistency in Refugee Decision-Making: A Judicial Perspective

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · Refugee Survey Quarterly · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article examines the extent to which progress has been made towards achieving greater consistency in refugee law decision-making. It is pointed out that consistency is not necessarily an end in itself and is only a virtue in the service of fair and just decision-making. The backdrop to the article is the fact that many recent studies have highlighted that decision-making is still too much of a lottery. In order to aid analysis use is made of the distinction between two dimensions of a claim for asylum: the individual dimension and the country dimension. Applying this distinction it is suggested that the world of refugee decision-making can be divided into three segments: decision-making by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees; non-European decision-making; and European decision-making.

Complementary Protection in International Refugee Law

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

For over fifty years all matters relating to interpretation or application of the CSR51 have been left to national courts. Article 38 of the Convention, which provides for any dispute about such matters to be referred to the International Court of Justice (ICJ), has never been invoked. This has become known as the ‘Article 38 deficit'. As a result of this deficit, despite UNHCR's considerable efforts to supervise application of the Convention and encourage consistency of approach world-wide, refugee law jurisprudence still differs considerably from country to country. Given that the CSR51 deliberately left key terms – persecution, protection etc. – undefined, it was perhaps inevitable that, in the absence of any ICJ guidance, divergent approaches should emerge and that, under pressure of numbers, concerns should be increasingly expressed about attendant problems and pitfalls: asylum…

International Refugee Law and the Protection of Stateless Persons

Hugo Storey

Sociology and Political Science · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Even read purely as an addition to the burgeoning literature on statelessness, this book holds its own. But, as its title well captures, it is first and foremost a book about refugee law. As such, it does more than hold its own; it provides the first comprehensive treatment of the interaction between statelessness and refugee law. Reading it, one soon becomes aware how relatively ignored this topic has been. The UNHCR Handbook on Procedures and Criteria for Determining Refugee Status (1979, reissued 2019) deals in only cursory fashion with the application of the refugee definition to stateless persons. To date, none of the UNHCR Guidelines on International Protection tackle it. With notable exceptions, such as Eric Fripp’s (less comprehensive) monograph, Nationality and Statelessness in the International Law of Refugee Status (2016), the vast majority of studies of the refugee…

Climate Change, Disasters, and the Refugee Convention

Hugo Storey

Sociology and Political Science · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

On refugees and climate change, that most existential of refugee law topics, the literature proceeds apace, as needs must. One of its latest additions, Matthew Scott’s book stands out for its ambition and originality. It not only sets out a new approach to climate change and disaster-related refugee claims, but seeks to propose a significant ‘recalibration’ of the refugee definition for application to all types of claim. Raising serious, well-articulated challenges on virtually every page to prevailing thinking on the definition of refugee in article 1A(2) of the 1951 Refugee Convention, it represents a signal contribution to the field. Lack of protection for victims of climate change and disasters within the existing corpus of international treaty law is well documented, both for those within States and those who involuntarily migrate. The responses of those seeking to fill this gap…

The Advanced Refugee Law Workshop Experience: An IARLJ Perspective

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Advanced Refugee Law Workshop Experience: An IARLJ Perspective Get access Hugo Storey, Dr Hugo Storey, Dr Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Google Scholar International Journal of Refugee Law, Volume 15, Issue 3, July 2003, Pages 422–429, https://doi.org/10.1093/ijrl/15.3.422 Published: 01 July 2003

The Internal Flight Alternative Test: The Furisprudence Re-examined

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Among essential elements of the refugee definition, the internal flight alternative has been a source of difficulties of interpretation and application. In the context of a legal framework of international protection its logic is irrefutable. But the text of the Convention does not spell it out; the treatment in UNHCR's Handbook is cursory and controversial; and it has gone by different names. Underlying these difficulties is a shared concern about the potential rigours of the test, its uncertain implications for asylum seekers; and the temptations it offers decision-makers intent upon quick-fix dispute resolution. This article examines developments in the IFA test in recent international jurisprudence. After a brief textual analysis, a number of key features of the test are examined: its name; the relevance of paragraph 91 of the Handbook; the burden and standard of proof; its temporal…

The Human Rights Approach to the Refugee Definition: Rising Sun or Falling Star?

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Until recently, the human rights approach to the refugee definition appeared destined to become a permanent feature of international refugee law. Now, however, doubts have set in. The object of this article is to address the main criticisms that have been levelled and to seek to put them in a wider perspective, reflecting briefly on where the law on refugee status is heading now that the 1951 Refugee Convention has entered its eighth decade. To this end, this article commences with a description of the human rights approach and a brief summary of how and why it came to become the ‘dominant’ approach and its underlying justifications. It then turns to consider the major criticisms raised, breaking these down into three clusters. The first cluster seeks to argue that such an approach is not warranted by proper application of the rules of treaty interpretation enjoined by the 1969…

Refuge Lost: Asylum Law in an Interdependent World

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The vocabulary of deterrence has come to dominate the world of refugee law and policy: ‘pushbacks’, ‘pullbacks’, maritime interdiction, extraterritorial processing, and mandatory detention are now the ‘go-to’ mechanisms of first world States to deter migrants and asylum seekers – before they can arrive, when they arrive, and/or after they arrive at their borders. In large sum, Ghezelbash’s book stands as a highly insightful survey and analysis of such mechanisms. With primary focus on the United States (US) and Australia, he examines long-term mandatory detention in chapter 3; maritime interdiction and pushback operations in chapter 4; and extraterritorial processing in chapter 5. In the chapter on mandatory detention, he charts the ways in which, from the 1980s onwards, the US and Australian governments shifted their policies in reaction to unauthorized boat arrivals (mainly Haitians…

Nationality and Statelessness

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter looks at the ‘nationality’ element of the refugee definition (which encompasses both those with and without nationality). It explains why this element of the refugee definition, which concerns its personal scope, is dealt with first. Having examined the international law rules that govern acquisition and loss of nationality, this chapter then considers the meaning to be given to the terms used in Article 1A(2) of the Convention, namely ‘country of nationality’, ‘more than one country of nationality’, and ‘not having a nationality’ respectively. It is explained why the term must be construed to denote the legal bond between the individual and the state and why, in temporal terms, ‘nationality’ must refer to current or actual nationality. The main issues tackled in the remainder of this chapter concern whether stateless persons are ipso facto refugees (it is argued…

III. Asylum Qualification Directive 2011/95/EU

Harald Dörig, Ingo Kraft, Hugo Storey +1 more

Law · Nomos eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Da wesentliche Teile des Ausländer- und Asylrechts in die Kompetenz der EU übergegangen sind, werden die auf der Grundlage des EG-Vertrags erlassenen Verordnungen und Richtlinien von immer größerer Bedeutung für die Praxis der Ausländerbehörden und Verwaltungsgerichte. Allein in Deutschland sind mehr als fünf Vorlagen zur Auslegung von Richtlinien, insbesondere im Bereich der sog. Qualifikationsrichtlinie (Kriterien der Anerkennung als Flüchtling) von deutschen Gerichten beim Europäischen Gerichtshof anhängig gemacht worden.

Approaches, Ordering, Interrelationships, Modalities

Hugo Storey

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Before being able to address the individual elements of the refugee definition, it is important to cover several ‘framework’ issues that overset their interpretation. This chapter first examines the main approaches that have been taken: the ‘literal approach’; the ‘circumstantial approach’; the ‘US subjective approach’; the ‘case-by-case’ approach; and the human rights approach. It is argued that the human rights approach is the only one that adheres closely to VCLT rules. Having looked at the history of this approach and its main versions, this chapter seeks to evaluate its merits and demerits. The author concludes that it has justifiably come to be regarded as the approach most conducive to achieving a truly universal definition of key elements of the refugee definition, although more clarification is needed. Hence international human rights law (IHRL) norms are to be applied…

‘Well-Founded Fear’

Hugo Storey

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The ‘well-founded fear’ element of the refugee definition furnishes the critical link between its personal and material scope. Application of VCLT rules is seen as capable of supporting either of its two main interpretations, namely the ‘bipartite approach’ or the ‘objective approach’. The former treats both subjective fear and objective fear as necessary conditions; the latter maintains that well-founded fear contains just the one component, namely objective fear. It is considered that proponents of the former, which treats subjective fear as a necessary condition, have so far proved unable to respond effectively to the main criticisms levelled against it. This chapter’s analysis reveals, however, that despite the divide between these two approaches, both concur in considering that the well-founded fear inquiry requires a foundation in fact; an individual assessment; a…

The Availment Clause: ‘To Avail Himself of the Protection’

Hugo Storey

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter tackles the paradox that even though the meaning of the definition’s availment (or protection) clause has been the subject of highly divergent interpretations, these have had virtually no discernible effect on the outcome of decisions. Applying VCLT rules, it is argued that the clause must be understood to connote both external (diplomatic) and internal protection, not one or the other. Contrary to the view sometimes voiced, that the clause is an ‘historical relic’, this chapter argues that it must still be understood as one of the substantive requirements of the refugee definition. Being the only element of the refugee definition that employs the term ‘protection’, it should be treated as the source of its meaning for the use made of it elsewhere in the definition, in particular within the ‘being persecuted’ element. Treating the availment clause as the primary…