arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Fergus Kerr

26 papers · 1941–2017

1958: 01959: 01960: 01961: 11962: 01963: 01964: 01965: 01966: 11967: 01968: 01969: 01970: 01971: 01972: 01973: 11974: 01975: 01976: 21977: 11978: 21979: 21980: 21981: 11982: 11983: 01984: 11985: 01986: 11987: 01988: 01989: 01990: 01991: 01992: 21993: 11994: 11995: 01996: 01997: 01998: 01999: 02000: 02001: 02002: 02003: 22004: 12005: 02006: 02007: 02008: 02009: 02010: 12011: 02012: 02013: 02014: 02015: 02016: 02017: 1
1958peak 2 in 19762017

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 26 RSS

The Human Person: Animal and Spirit

Fergus Kerr

Sociology and Political Science · New Blackfriars · · cited 59× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In 1988 David Braine, who has taught philosophy at the University of Aberdeen for many years, published The Reality of Time and the Existence of God, a metaphysical proof of God’s existence. Now, in this second book, The Human Person: Animal and Spirit (Duckworth, London, 1993) which certainly stands on its own although we are frequently referred back to the earlier book and forward to two (if not three) forthcoming volumes, he reconstructs the argument advanced by Thomas Aquinas in favour of our immortality, an even more audacious enterprise in the present intellectual climate. The first move is to cut off every form of dualism which splits the animals that we human beings are into parts that then have to be related to one another. The traditional mind/body dualism to which Platonist Christians have always been attracted is, so David Braine argues, no different from the brain/mind…

Simplicity Itself: Milbank's Thesis

Fergus Kerr

Geography, Planning and Development · New Blackfriars · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

John Milbank's work is familiar to the assiduous reader of New Blackfriars, who will recall his two-part study of William Warburton, as well as his more recent essays ‘On Baseless Suspicion: Christianity and the Crisis of Socialism’ and ‘Religion, Culture and Anarchy: the attack on the Amoldian vision’. Although not incorporated materially into Theology and Social Theory, these essays open up related lines of investigation, and, having read them, one might not find his massive book so intimidating. It may be said, at least, that one might have been prepared for this venture into a post-Nietzschean theology which is also profoundly (Anglican) Catholic—an unlikely conjunction, one might have thought. The book’s dense scholarship and theoretical complexity are formidable, but, fortunately, in the title, the epigraph and the table of contents, we are offered three clues to the brilliantly…

The Open Letter: Evangelical Anglicans and Ecumenism

Fergus Kerr

Law · New Blackfriars · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In July 1977 a group of Evangelical Anglicans addressed an Open Letter to the bishops of the Anglican communion. The Letter has recently been published together with a lengthy commentary, somewhat in the style of the Anglican/Roman Catholic International Commission (ARCIC) Agreements, in the general reception of which this is intended as a significant intervention. This document invites attention from Catholics, not merely on tactical grounds, because of the large number of Anglicans with a Protestant cast of mind who must be respected and accommodated in any reconciliation between Canterbury and Rome, but also because of the intrinsic importance of the theological questions that the authors raise. The tenor of the Open Letter may be judged by the Preface: “Some speak as if with the appearance of the three ARCIC Agreements the main theological discussions are already over, and we can…

HOW MUCH CAN A PHILOSOPHER DO?

OP FERGUS KERR

Sociology and Political Science · Modern Theology · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Some philosophers (Stephen Mulhall, Peter Winch, and D.Z. Phillips) complained that in Sources of the Self Charles Taylor allowed his Christian allegiance to “peep through”, whereas, as a philosopher, he should have done justice to other views than his own, without taking sides. They would no doubt have protested even more about A Secular Age . Reading these two books in the context of his previous work it becomes hard to accuse Taylor of failing to expound fairly views he opposes, especially regarding British empiricism. Moreover, how disinterested can critical genealogy of religion in the West ever be?

Beyond Lonergan's Method: A Response to William Mathews

Fergus Kerr

Political Science and International Relations · New Blackfriars · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

As I wrote in my review of the book (New Blackfriars, July 1975), all but one or two of the thirteen symposiasts in Looking at Lonergan’s Method initiate what seem like quite damaging lines of criticism, and in the space of an article Bill Mathews could no more refute them all (New Blackfriars, January 1976) than I could fairly present them all —and, like me, he has incorporated theological reflections of his own, which makes the debate so multilateral that it threatens to exasperate readers without access to the symposium or perhaps even to Lonergan’s own books. It seems to me, then, that extended argument about the soundness or otherwise of this phalanx of objections to Lonergan, and about the wisdom of my general endorsement of these objections, with all the grit of detailed claim and contradiction and the paraphernalia of criss-crossing page references and citations, would weary all…

Discipleship of Equals or Nuptial Mystery?

Fergus Kerr

Sociology and Political Science · New Blackfriars · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Fifty years ago, as a glance at standard textbooks would confirm, history as taught in school and university was mostly about battles and wars and the doings of kings and queens. Since then, however, there has been a massive shift of interest to the doings and sufferings of ordinary people— much more difficult as it of course is to reconstruct their lives. More recently still, historians have turned their attention to retrieving the experience of women—ordinary women, in different societies, but also (as in such recent books as Woman Defamed and Woman Defended edited by Alcuin Blamires or Medieval English Prose for Women edited by Bella Millett and Jocelyn Wogan-Browne) women who played a distinctive and much more significant part in history than has previously been acknowledged. Here too, it has become possible to read between the lines of familiar material to discover what was (no…

Christian Memory and National Consciousness

Fergus Kerr

Sociology and Political Science · New Blackfriars · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

My original title for this paper asked a question: The Church—Focus for European Integration? Of course there is a great deal that the Church, whether we mean those of us in communion with Rome or include Christians of the Reformed and Orthodox Churches, is able and likely to do to focus integration in Europe. But as I come now to write it I find that the emphasis in what I want to say suggests a fairly modest proposal for some work at national level which would necessarily be ecumenical in character. Christians, in Europe at least, are perhaps more of an obstacle in the way rather than any kind of focus of integration. True, not all the ancient and venomous conflicts that you see almost wherever you look in ‘Europe’ have religious or if you like ecclesiastical origins or dimensions. The problem of Basque separatism in Spain doesn’t have any religious dimension. But whether it is…

Unity and Difference in Christianity

Fergus Kerr

Sociology and Political Science · New Blackfriars · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The difference between Catholics that comes out very plainly in recent writing on the Resurrection (New Blackfriars, October and November 1977, pp 453-461 and 506-515) prompts questions and reflections about the nature and extent of the diversity of belief that exists within the Catholic communion. This is particularly urgent and apposite at the present time, in England, as Catholics seem to be moving, slowly but inexorably, towards some degree of communion with the Anglican Church—long mocked as the home of incompatible beliefs. As Cardinal Hume said, in his address at Church House, Westminster, on 1st February 1978: “We do not yet know what diversity of doctrinal emphasis or differences of practice will not only be permissible but also desirable”. ‘ That avowal of ignorance—which is also clearly a word of hope— must seem to many Catholics even now very like an admission of defeat.…

Priorities in Religious Life

Fergus Kerr

Geography, Planning and Development · New Blackfriars · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Nobody who cares about the future of religious life should fail to study the recent essay on the subject by Jerome Murphy O’Connor, an Irish Dominican who teaches at the Ecole Biblique in Jerusalem— an entire issue of Supplement to Doctrine and Life is given over to it (No. 45, May-June, 1973). What he has to say is so illuminating that it is worth repeating the main idea here, adding some comments and observations to back up his argument. 1—The raison d’etre of religious life The question of priorities is crucial. What service do religious have to offer the Church and society? As they proceed to retrenchment and reform, the dilemma that confronts religious today is as follows: are they to decide what work they should be doing (teaching, nursing, preaching, whatever) and then allow the style of their life to be determined by that, or are they to make the form and quality of their…

A Catholic Response to the Programme of Radical Orthodoxy

O.P. Fergus Kerr

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Given the number of Catholic contributors to the book, Radical Orthodoxy, it is not possible for any Catholic response to come from a wholly external standpoint. It is not difficult to identify other groupings in Britain with quite different sets of interests, who might find Radical Orthodoxy profoundly alien and uncongenial. There are two centrally important discussions of Luther Radical Orthodoxy. The first, by John Montag, explores the highly influential though little studied work of Francisco Suarez. The second is John Milbank's own attempt to renew theological interest in Lutheran thinkers like Hamann and Jacobi. Every theological programme includes a reading of previous theological work, necessarily selective, and may thus be disputable at various points. Many Catholic theologians in the Cajetanian tradition of Thomism especially, found it hard to accept Henri de Lubac's…

Comment: A Ceremonial Animal

Fergus Kerr

Geography, Planning and Development · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A Ceremonial Animal'One could almost say that man is a ceremonial animal, ein zeremonielles Tier', so Ludwig Wittgenstein noted in 1931 as he riffled through the first volume of the Cambridge Union copy of The Golden Bough with his friend M. O'C.Drury (see Philosophical Occasions 1912-1951 edited by James C. Klagge and Alfred

The First Issue

Fergus Kerr

Geography, Planning and Development · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Revamped with effect from October 1964 as New Blackfriars, this journal first appeared in April 1920. We claimed then not to be ‘new’ but only The Catholic Review, ‘ revived and renamed’: a quarterly that ran for several years but had to give up during the War. In 1919 Fr Bede Jarrett (1881-1934), then Prior Provincial, bought it for £40, on behalf of the English Dominican Province. Bernard Delany (1890-1959) was appointed Editor of the projected journal. He had just come from two years as an army chaplain (1917-19). As he recalled, Fr Bede wanted a review which ‘was not to be learned or theological, nor of a specifically ecclesiastical character’ (see Bernard Delany, ‘The Beginnings of “Blackfriars”’, Blackfriars 34 (1953): 308-319). The first issues were planned over lunches at Jack Straw’s Castle on Hampstead Heath. Besides Delany and Jarrett himself the editorial board consisted of…

TRUTH IN RELIGION

Fergus Kerr

Education · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Anyone ever involved in religious education, as parent, teacher, catechist or minister, realizes that those whom they seek to educate want to know how much of it is true. Some feel in their bones that God exists, but others see nothing to show that such a being exists. The Christian religion is based on the claim that Jesus of Nazareth was raised from the dead, that he appeared to certain men and women, ate and drank with them, etc., before withdrawing from earthly sight. Like anything else that happened long ago, this could be a fact only if we trust the testimony of those who claim to have been there at the time. We surely need extraordinarily strong evidence before we could accept it as something that ‘really’ happened.

Reading the <i>Medea</i>

Fergus Kerr

Anthropology · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Medea —in a Japanese version—performed outdoors—after dusk—in the neo-Classical courtyard of the Old College Edinburgh—late in what had been a cold and wet August: was it worth buying a ticket for that —even if Yukio Ninagawa’s production of Macbeth had been the sensation of the 1985 Festival? After all, that had been indoors, and the Shakespeare play had been part of my mind for over forty years. You had to choose between Greek and German, in my day, at a Scottish grammar school, and I had opted for German (entirely because I feared the principal Classics master). But then—I understand Japanese as little as I can follow spoken Greek, and would not that be the case for nearly everyone in the audience? We should all be relying on the eloquence of gesture, lighting, tone, and perhaps music. It seemed advisable, for all that, to study the text in advance of the performance. What…

Küng's Case for God

Fergus Kerr

Sociology and Political Science · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

People would like to have reasons for believing that God exists. With its appearance in attractive paperback format Hans Küng’s Does God Exist ? certainly looks like the most thorough and scholarly treatment of the subject. For one thing, at seventeen ounces, clearly printed on decent paper, and sturdily enough bound to survive several readings, it is a fine example of modern book-production. The translation by Edward Quinn, is, needless to say, almost faultless. Some of the reviews which the hardback version received were very destructive—Alasdair MacIntyre’s page-long diatribe in The London Review of Books (5—18 February, 1981) comes to mind: “Whenever in future I try to imagine what Purgatory will be like, the thought of having to read Dr. Küng’s book will recur”. Judgements in some of the theological periodicals were rather more respectful. To give only two examples: in Theology…

The ARCIC Report

Fergus Kerr

Law · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Thomas More, lately Lord Chancellor of England, was beheaded on Tower Hill on 6 July 1535. Thomas Cranmer, lately Archbishop of Canterbury (who had tried to save More), was burnt to death in Oxford on 21 March 1556. William Allen left England for good in 1565. The ‘Roman Catholic Relief Act’ was passed in 1829. Anglican orders were declared invalid, in 1896, through defect of both form and intention. Michael Ramsey, Archbishop of Canterbury, visited Pope Paul VI in 1966 and they decided to set up a joint theological commission which reported to them two years later (the Malta Report). The first meeting of the Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commission (ARCIC) took place at St George’s House, Windsor Castle, in 1970. The concluding meeting was at the same venue in 1981. The Final Report appeared, after mysterious delays, on 31 March 1982. Pope John Paul II is due to arrive in…

The Theology of Ernst Käsemann ‐ I

Fergus Kerr

Political Science and International Relations · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Ernst Käsemann was born in Westphalia in 1906. His graduate studies, in the leisurely and protracted German manner, were coming to a close in 1933, the year in which Hitler was voted into power and his dissertation on the concepts of the body and the body of Christ in St Paul was published. From the outset, as a young pfarrer in Westphalia, he belonged to the Confessing Church: the organized opposition to the influence of National Socialism among German Protestants. At the age of forty, in 1946, he returned to academic life as professor of New Testament studies, first at Mainz, then at Gottingen, and since 1959 until his retirement at Tubingen. On the third day of his first semester as a student at Bonn in 1925 he started going to the class on the Epistle to the Romans which was being given by Erik Peterson: “the course of my study and in some sense, as befits a theologian, my life was…

Rahner's <i>Grundkurs</i> revisited once again

Fergus Kerr

Geometry and Topology · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Karl Rahner writes as follows (Foundations of Christian Faith, page 431): “In view of the mode in which eschatological statements are made in the Old and New Testaments, a Christian is always tempted to read and to interpret the eschatological statements of Christianity as anticipatory eyewitness accounts of a future which is still outstanding”. The meaning of this sentence, according to Hugo Meynell (New Blackfriars, July/August 1980, page 348), is that Rahner is warning us against the temptation of thinking that eschatological statements tell us anything, or have any bearing upon, what is to happen to us when we die: “Perhaps it is stupid of me not to be able to see what is being denied here, unless it is that Christians have some kind of expectation for the future after the end of the present life”. Dr Meynell thus reads the sentence as if it were stressed as follows: “In view of the…

Liverpool 1980 The National Pastoral Congress

Fergus Kerr

Sociology and Political Science · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The young couple, both teachers, one at a Catholic school in the city, did not know that the National Pastoral Congress would be taking place that week-end in Liverpool until they agreed three or four days before to put me up. On the Saturday afternoon thousands of people were left outside when the gates were locked at Anfield long before the kick-off: that Liverpool FC retained the First Division championship obviously stirred far more hearts far more deeply, Catholic ones no doubt included, than the NPC’s deliberations ever had any chance of doing. With all such qualifications duly noted, however, the Congress was nonetheless the most important event in the history of the Catholic Church in England and Wales since the restoration of diocesan bishops in 1850. On the Sunday afternoon the Liverpool Orange Lodge held a march, with several bands and plenty of Union Jacks, so they at least…

4: The Conflict between the English Bishops Vatican I and the Papacy

Fergus Kerr

Political Science and International Relations · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The decade that preceded Vatican I saw what was by far the most intensive and exciting theological debate there has ever been in modern English Catholic history. Compared with the pious torpor of the decade that preceded Vatican II, certainly, the zest and odium of theological exchange prepared the clergy and educated laity in England more thoroughly for the proclamation of the doctrine of papal infallibility than was the case anywhere else in the Catholic world. It is true, of course, that nobody elsewhere expected papal infallibility to be so high on the agenda at the Council. The English debate, through Manning’s extraordinary influence at the Council, may even be described (with little exaggeration) as the key factor in ensuring that papal infallibility was moved to the head of the agenda. The Dublin Review , from 1863 onwards, was the principal organ of the “New Ultramontanism”. In…

Obstacles to Christian Unity

Fergus Kerr

Political Science and International Relations · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

“A penny for the guy, please mister”. I never give small boys anything when they come out on the streets at the beginning of November every year, with the effigies of Guy Fawkes which they should be burning this evening. “Sorry”, I say, “but I am a Roman Catholic”. I like waiting for the look of pure astonishment that comes over their faces, as if that were a reason for not giving them a penny for the guy. When the Chaplain invited me to address you this evening he suggested that I might take the opportunity to reflect on the obstacles that Roman Catholics in England see as still blocking the way to union with the Church of England. So much rapprochement has taken place, particularly since the Anglican/Roman Catholic International Commission which has since produced three remarkable “Agreed Statements” testifying to convergence, if not perhaps consensus, on traditionally controversial…

Recent Catholic Writing on the Resurrection (1) The Empty Tomb Story

Fergus Kerr

Political Science and International Relations · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The foundation of Christianity, as fact and doctrine, is the resurrection from the dead of Jesus who was crucified, “a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles, but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God” (I Cor 1: 23-24). Great efforts have been made over the centuries to spell out the presuppositions and implications, historical, metaphysical and theological, of this event, and it is unlikely that anything wholly new will be discovered now. In the last ten or fifteen years, on the other hand, study of the resurrection narratives in the New Testament has quickened dramatically, among Catholics, and it is important for us all to recognize that some divergence of interpretation is now established. Without attempting even to summarise the ever increasing Catholic literature on the subject, or to examine the various problems which…

A Marxist's Jesus

Fergus Kerr

Sociology and Political Science · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Prague was once, and in time no doubt will be again, a crossroads of ideas, a carrefour of cross-fertilisation between Christians and Marxists. The effect upon such theologians as J.B. Metz and Jurgen Moltmann would not be difficult to demonstrate. In many respects now, so pervasive have a certain basic Marxist agenda and vocabulary become, Christians can no longer formulate their ideas or decide their course of action without more or less explicit reference to Marxism. This is particularly true in Latin America. It is noticeable also in Vatican documents on social policy—for example in the paragraphs on liberation in Pope Paul’s lengthy statement “Evangelii nuntiandi”, published some three weeks before the Declaration on Sexual Ethics, but, in contrast with the latter, destined to drop immediately into that oblivion of indifference reserved by conservatives and radicals in the Catholic…

Delusive Radicalism in Modern Theology

Fergus Kerr

Sociology and Political Science · New Blackfriars · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

We are familiar enough now with the distinction between doctrine and theology, between the doctrinal content of the Christian faith as a form of life (an ‘experience’) and the variety of theological formulations in which this form of life is recognized and registered in the continuing self-awareness of the Christian community. The distinction is not absolute: there are cases in which, for instance, it is extremely difficult to imagine how a particular doctrine could be presented in any but the terms of some particular theology; but in principle at least it is always possible to express the truth of the faith in theological systems which, while of course never actually conflicting, nevertheless diverge considerably from one another in standpoint and procedure. This pluralism of approach has not developed so richly as it might have done because Christian thinking has always been conducted…

Odious Corollaries in D. H. Lawrence

Fergus Kerr

Geography, Planning and Development · Blackfriars : · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The most serious and perceptive assault on Lady Chatterley's Lover, in the recent flurry of controversy, issued from Dr Leavis in his review of the Pelican Special which told the story of the trial. Apart from his judgment that it is a bad novel, and the persuasive rationale that he offers there to support this decision, which, though much sharpened and more circumstantial, is essentially the one he reached in his book on Lawrence in 1955, Dr Leavis makes an interesting sociological comment on the significance of the Defence’s success. The Prosecution, he observes, was defeated, ‘not by the presentment of any sound or compelling case, but by its realization that it was confronted by a new and confident orthodoxy of enlightenment’. The verdict, in fact, registered a change in the values of educated people—a change which owes a good deal, in ways that it would be instructive to examine…