arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Eric Mack

32 papers · 1981–2024

1981: 11982: 01983: 11984: 01985: 01986: 01987: 01988: 01989: 01990: 11991: 01992: 11993: 31994: 01995: 11996: 01997: 01998: 11999: 02000: 02001: 02002: 22003: 02004: 02005: 12006: 22007: 12008: 12009: 02010: 12011: 32012: 12013: 02014: 02015: 22016: 02017: 12018: 22019: 12020: 12021: 02022: 22023: 02024: 2
1981peak 3 in 19932024

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 32 RSS

The Self-Ownership Proviso: A New and Improved Lockean Proviso

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 91× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this essay I propose to explicate and defend a new and improved version of a Lockean proviso—the self-ownership proviso (SOP). I shall presume here that individuals possess robust rights of self-ownership. I shall take it that each individual has strong moral claims over the elements which constitute her person, e.g., her body parts, her talents, and her energies. However, in the course of the essay, I shall be challenging what I take to be the standard conception of self-ownership and proposing an enrichment of that conception. The SOP is presented and in part justified as an implication of the right of self-ownership as it is more richly conceived—hence its designation as the self-ownership proviso. As an implication of the right of self-ownership which is also compatible, in theory and practice, with extensive and robust private property rights, the SOP is offered as an integral…

THE NATURAL RIGHT OF PROPERTY

Eric Mack

Law · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 57× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The two main theses of “The Natural Right of Property” are: (i) that persons possess an original, non-acquired right not to be precluded from making extra-personal material their own (or from exercising discretionary control over what they have made their own); and (ii) that this right can and does take the form of a right that others abide by the rules of a (justifiable) practice of property which facilitates persons making extra-personal material their own (and exercising discretionary control over what they have made their own). I articulate some of the good reasons we have to affirm persons' possession of an original, non-acquired right of self-ownership and argue that the same good reasons support the ascription to persons of a natural right of property. I contrast an “inherent feature” conception of the actions through which (initial) rights over extra-personal objects…

Nozickian arguments for the more-than-minimal state

Eric Mack

Sociology and Political Science · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 49× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The first and longest part of Robert Nozick's Anarchy, State, and Utopia (ASU) is substantially devoted to a defense of the minimal (nightwatchman) state against the challenge of the individualist anarchist. In this chapter I explore the contest between Nozick and the individualist anarchist by examining responses that Nozick offered, could have offered, or should have offered to the anarchist challenge. I conclude that the best Nozickian response to the anarchist challenge vindicates a state which is more than minimal because, although it provides only the service of rights protection, it funds the production of its services by requiring at least some of the recipients of those services to purchase those services. In this introductory section I will provide a sketch of the structure of this exploration.

Distributive Justice and the Tensions of Lockeanism

Eric Mack

Law · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 49× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

An ongoing tension exists within the Lockean tradition in political philosophy between the claim that each individual is the “Proprietor of his own Person” and the claim that nature is “that which God gave to Mankind in common.” The former claim points to a realm of discrete individual entitlements only formally equal in the sense of each individual having jurisdiction over his own person and not over any other person, while the latter points either to a collective entitlement to nature or to individual entitlements to substantively equal shares of nature. Were the two realms, that of persons and that of extra-personal nature, separate and independent, no tension would arise from the union of these two claims. But the realms are manifestly interconnected. Individuals acquire, use, labor upon, invest their time and energy on, and transform, more or less in accordance with their purposes…

Self-ownership, Marxism, and Egalitarianism

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Politics Philosophy & Economics · · cited 48× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This two-part article offers a defense of a libertarian doctrine that centers on two propositions. The first is the self-ownership thesis according to which each individual possesses original moral rights over her own body, faculties, talents, and energies. The second is the anti-egalitarian conclusion that, through the exercise of these rights of self-ownership, individuals may readily become entitled to substantially unequal extra-personal holdings. The self-ownership thesis remains in the background during Part I of this essay, while the anti-egalitarian conclusion is supported in two ways. First, I offer a reconstruction of Robert Nozick's well-known `How Liberty Upsets Patterns' argument against all end-state and pattern theories of distributive justice; and I defend this reconstructed stance against what might (otherwise) seem to be telling criticisms. Second, I defend the two key…

Self-Ownership and the Right of Property

Eric Mack

Sociology and Political Science · The Monist · · cited 45× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Journal Article Self-Ownership and the Right of Property Get access Eric Mack Eric Mack Tulane University Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic PubMed Google Scholar The Monist, Volume 73, Issue 4, 1 October 1990, Pages 519–543, https://doi.org/10.5840/monist19907343 Published: 09 December 2014

NON-ABSOLUTE RIGHTS AND LIBERTARIAN TAXATION

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 38× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Rights-oriented libertarian theory asserts the existence of robust individual rights - including robust rights of property. If these property rights are absolute, then it seems that all taxation is theft. However, it also seems that, if an individual is (faultlessly) in dire straits, it is permissible for him to seize or trespass in order to escape from those straits. It does seem that in this sense property rights are non-absolute. This essay examines what contribution this non-absoluteness of rights makes to the justification of taxation for the sake of rescuing individuals from their dire straits. The essay investigates how dire an individual's circumstances have to be for him to have a dispensation from the normal obligation to respect property. It distinguishes among different dispensations that individuals in dire enough circumstances may have. And it emphasizes how precarious is…

Defining textual entailment

Daniel Z. Korman, Eric A Mack, Jacob Jett +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology · · cited 33× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Textual entailment is a relationship that obtains between fragments of text when one fragment in some sense implies the other fragment. The automation of textual entailment recognition supports a wide variety of text‐based tasks, including information retrieval, information extraction, question answering, text summarization, and machine translation. Much ingenuity has been devoted to developing algorithms for identifying textual entailments, but relatively little to saying what textual entailment actually is . This article is a review of the logical and philosophical issues involved in providing an adequate definition of textual entailment. We show that many natural definitions of textual entailment are refuted by counterexamples, including the most widely cited definition of Dagan et al. We then articulate and defend the following revised definition: T textually entails H = df…

Gauthier on Rights and Economic Rent

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 33× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

David Gauthier's Morals by Agreement is an impressive — indeed, daunting — exercise in contractarian moral and political philosophy. The primary purpose of his treatise is to explicate practical rationality as constrained maximization and morality as compliance with these constraints. Gauthier offers an account of which constraints on straightforward utility maximization each rational individual will be prepared to accept and comply with on the condition that other individuals also will accept and comply with them as well as an explanation of why compliance with those constraints counts as morality. However, although Morals by Agreement is in the great tradition of Hobbesian moral and political theorizing, Gauthier's morality by agreement does not begin with the Hobbesian state of nature. Gauthier does not start by envisioning a Hobbesian war of all against all which has been generated…

Elbow Room for Rights

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 28× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract If individuals possess robust rights over their own persons and legitimately acquired possessions does any action on the part of another person that has any physical effect on the right-holder or her property to which the right-holder has not consented violate those rights? If so, it seems that almost every ordinary exercise of one’s rights—e.g., starting one’s car up in one’s own driveway, emitting some smoke while grilling in one’s own backyard—violate the rights of one’s neighbors. To avoid this conclusion must the libertarian theorist shift to a less robust understanding of rights? This chapter argues against the need for such a general attenuation of rights. Any sensible delineation of rights must leave moral elbow room for the exercise of those rights. So, a sensible delineation of rights will not construe the minor physical intrusions under consideration as moral…

Deontic Restrictions Are Not Agent-Relative Restrictions

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 25× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The primary purpose of this essay is to offer a critique of a particular program within moral and political philosophy. This program can be stated quite succinctly. It is to account for agents' being subject to deontic restrictions on the basis of their possession of agent-relative reasons for acting in accordance with those restrictions. Needless to say, the statement of this program requires some further explication. Specifically, two claims require explanation: (1) the reasons individuals have for or against engaging in particular actions are, at least to a very significant extent, agent-relative rather than agent-neutral; and (2) agents' conduct toward others is subject to deontic restrictions . Finally, (3) I need to explain why an agent's possession of agent-relative reasons for performing or refraining from certain actions may be thought to explain that agent's being subject to…

Personal Integrity, Practical Recognition, and Rights

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · The Monist · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Journal Article Personal Integrity, Practical Recognition, and Rights Get access Eric Mack Eric Mack Tulane University Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic PubMed Google Scholar The Monist, Volume 76, Issue 1, 1 January 1993, Pages 101–118, https://doi.org/10.5840/monist199376112 Published: 09 December 2014

The World Health Organization's New International Health Regulations: Incursion on State Sovereignty and Ill-Fated Response to Global Health Issues

Eric Mack

Sociology and Political Science · Chicago journal of international law · · cited 13× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Part II of this Development discusses the legal initiative undertaken by the WHO when it first drafted the International Health Regulations in 1969 ("IHRs 1969"). This section also outlines the purpose of the IHRs 1969 and highlights some of their major shortcomings. Section II then discusses the 2005 revisions to the IHRs 1969 and analyzes them with particular attention paid to the increased legislative and constitutional power granted to the WHO. Section III considers the potential conflict between the IHRs 2005 revisions and the principle of state sovereignty as well as the revisions' conflict with federal structures of government inherent in a number of large Western states. Lastly, Section III addresses the extent to which the WHO is seeking to become a supranational organization capable of side-stepping states' rights irrespective of geopolitical boundaries. Given the increased…

PREROGATIVES, RESTRICTIONS, AND RIGHTS

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

I offer a defense of the moral side-constraints to which Robert Nozick appeals in Anarchy, State and Utopia but for which he fails to provide a sustained justification. I identify a line of anti-consequentialist argumentation which is present in Nozick and which, in the terminology of Samuel Scheffler, moves first to affirm a personal prerogative which allows the individual not to sacrifice herself for the sake of the best overall outcome and second moves on to affirm restrictions (i.e., moral side-constraints) which prohibit the individual from suppressing others' exercise of their personal prerogatives even if that suppression would serve the overall good. I argue that one ought to follow this line of anti-consequentialist argumentation all the way to the affirmation of restrictions by showing that the rationale for the adoption of the personal prerogative is not satisfied unless the…

In Defense of ‘Unbridled’ Freedom of Contract

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · American Journal of Economics and Sociology · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A bstract . The doctrine of freedom of contract, viz. , that each person should have the liberty to enter into and the right to insist on the fulfillment of any rights‐respecting contract , is defined and defended as an implication of a Lockean emphasis on natural rights. This natural rights perspective requires the rejection of all collective social goal theories, e.g., utilitarianism , and the rejection of objections to freedom of contract which proceed from such theories. Four specific objections to freedom of contract, each of which appears to flow from an individualistic emphasis on freedom and rights , are considered. But each of these is dismissed either for misconceiving the nature of freedom or for involving an underlying appeal to some implausible social goal theory.

Paradigms for Parallel Computation

Gil Speyer, Natalie Freed, R. Akis +2 more

Hardware and Architecture · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Message passing, as implemented in message passing interface (MPI), has become the industry standard for programming on distributed memory parallel architectures, while the threading on shared memory machines is typically implemented in OpenMP. Outstanding performance has been achieved with these methods, but only on a relatively small number of codes, requiring expert tuning, particularly as system size increases. With the advent of multicore/manycore microprocessors, and continuing scaling in the size of systems, an inflection point may be nearing that will require a substantial shift in the way large scale systems are programmed to maintain productivity. The parallel paradigms project was undertaken to evaluate the nearterm readiness of a number of emerging ideas in parallel programming, with specific emphasis on their applicability to applications in the user productivity…

LYSANDER SPOONER: NINETEENTH-CENTURY AMERICA'S LAST NATURAL RIGHTS THEORIST

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The main purpose of this essay is to articulate the ideas of the last powerful advocate of natural rights in nineteenth-century America. That last powerful advocate was the Massachusetts-born radical libertarian Lysander Spooner (1808-1887). Besides his powerful antebellum attacks on slavery, Spooner developed forceful arguments on behalf of a strongly individualistic conception of natural law and private property rights and against coercive moralism, coercive paternalism, and state authority and legislation. This essay focuses on the theoretical core of Spooner’s position which is his doctrine of natural rights—a doctrine that is primarily developed in Spooner’s The Law of Intellectual Property (1855), Natural Law (1882), and A Letter to Grover Cleveland (1886). I situate Spooner within the libertarian tradition in political thought by beginning this essay with an examination…

Scanlon as natural rights theorist

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Politics Philosophy & Economics · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article examines the character of Scanlon’s contractualism as presented in What We Owe to Each Other. I offer a range of reasons for thinking of Scanlon’s contractualism as a species of natural rights theorizing. I argue that to affirm the principle that actions are wrongful if and only if they are disallowed by principles that people could not reasonably reject is equivalent to affirming a natural right (of an admittedly non-standard sort) against being subject to such reasonably disallowed actions. I argue that Scanlon’s invocation of the value of human life can be seen as an attempted grounding for this principle that is akin to standard natural rights attempts to ground fundamental rights. Lastly, I argue that the invocation of the value of human life does not in fact well support the sort of requirement of justifiability to others that characterizes this contractualist variant…

EQUALITY, BENEVOLENCE, AND RESPONSIVENESS TO AGENT-RELATIVE VALUE

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Do differences in income or wealth matter, morally speaking? This essay addresses a broader issue than this question seems to pose. But this broader issue is, I believe, the salient philosophical issue which this question actually poses. Let me explain. Narrowly read, the question at hand is concerned only with inequality of income or wealth. It asks us to consider whether inequality of income or wealth as such is morally problematic. On this construal, the question invites us to consider whether the bare fact that Joshua has a greater income or net worth than Rebekah is a morally defective social state of affairs. Is there at least a significant moral presumption on behalf of equality of income or wealth such that, if an inequality of income or wealth obtains vis-à-vis Joshua and Rebekah, that inequality ought to be nullified unless some impressive positive justification for the…

Tethering the Law of Armed Conflict to Operational Practice: �Organized Armed Group� Membership in the Age of ISIS

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · UC Berkeley · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The article begins with a background section discussing organized armed groups (OAG), such as ISIS, and the consequences of membership in such a group. A survey of the various methods of determining OAG membership, and the practical applicability of each approach to ISIS, follows. Based upon this comparison, the article concludes that more restrictive membership criteria create an unworkable paradigm that does not match the realities of the modern battlefield. Instead, an expansive understanding of who qualifies as a member of an OAG is not only practical, but necessary for providing underlying support for the principle of distinction in non-international armed conflicts.

Of Transplants and Trolleys

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Philosophy and Phenomenological Research · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

According to Judith Thomson we know there are claim-rights because we know that persons are often under behavioral constraints that cannot be accounted for by-indeed are incompatible with-purely consequentialist ways of thinking. We know that these constraints exist because of our confidence in many cases about asserting the impermissibility of value-maximizing behavior. The exemplar of these cases is

Locke

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

“Locke” ranges over the essentials of Locke’s political philosophy, especially as found in the Second Treatise and A Letter Concerning Toleration. The chapter begins with a focus on Locke’s conception of freedom and his arguments for a natural right to freedom, as well as Locke’s grounding of property rights in the self-proprietorship that is implied by the natural right to freedom. It proceeds to Locke’s tracing the inconveniences of the state of nature to people’s private judgments and concluding that the remedy is a state that gives determinate public form to the law of nature and publicly enforces those more finely specified rights. The chapter then indicates the conditions under which individuals and their political society may forcibly resist and replace overreaching political rulers. A discussion of Locke’s case for religious toleration points to a different type of solution to…

John Locke on Just Price:

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Locke Studies · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Locke’s short essay, “Venditio,” offers a series of thought-provoking examples of prices that might or might not be viewed as just. Locke writes as though these examples and his comments about them point to a coherent doctrine about which agreed-to prices are morally acceptable and which are morally unacceptable. However, despite the acuity of some of Locke’s observations, no such coherent doctrine emerges from Locke’s discussions of these examples. Indeed, many of the conclusions Locke reaches as he moves from example to example are implausible in themselves or inconsistent with one another. Nevertheless, not all is lost. Locke’s observations can be viewed as thought experiments on his part which, in conjunction with insights from Locke’s other economic writings, indicate what features a doctrine of acceptable and unacceptable prices needs to possess. I show how a line of argument…

Natural Rights

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This essay is about the character and structure of the natural rights theorizing which grounds – or at least seeks to ground – natural rights that strongly support libertarian conclusions. It focuses entirely on this first phase of natural rights argumentation. It is not concerned with the ways in which libertarian-minded natural rights thinkers employ or refine their affirmations of natural rights to support downstream conclusions about, e.g., what property rights and contractual rights individuals have and how those rights are acquired, or why there must be radical limits on the use of coercive power by the state (or state-like entities), or under what special circumstances, if any, an individual or a state may act toward other individuals in ways that would normally be forbidden by the rights of those individuals. The key contention of this essay is that the grounding argument for…

TWO DEMANDS UPON LUCK EGALITARIANS

Eric Mack

Political Science and International Relations · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract I offer two objections to luck egalitarianism. The no-adequate-account objection takes note of the egalitarian insistence that the disvalue of inequality is only one of a plurality of values or disvalues that needs to be considered in arriving at a judgment about the ranking of alternative distributions of welfare. This turn to pluralism places a reasonable demand upon luck egalitarianism to provide an account of how the different sorts of values or disvalues that are supposed to attach to available distributions of welfare are to be aggregated or weighed against one another in that ranking procedure. I contend that the prospects for developing such an account are dim and that some salient responses to this objection misfire. The churlishness-envy objection against luck egalitarianism is that this doctrine countenances envy directed toward the faultless good fortune of others.…