Objective and Subjective Identification of Outstanding Elementary Teachers
Edward E. Hawkins, Emery Stoops
This study identified the outstanding teachers in 10 randomly chosen elementary schools. Very high concordance was found among the ten methods of identification, some of which were objective while others depended upon subjective opinions of respondents.Three methods chosen to represent salary determinants (training and experience), formal evaluation (principal judgments), and informal nonadministrative evaluation (selections by peer teachers, non-teaching staff members and school-associated parents), proved to have moderate statistical correlation.Apparent general inadequacies in the formal evaluation process should be critically analyzed, especially if merit pay programs based on the evaluation process are being considered.