arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Ellen Brantlinger

30 papers · 1985–2017

1985: 21986: 01987: 11988: 11989: 01990: 11991: 21992: 11993: 01994: 11995: 01996: 21997: 11998: 11999: 22000: 02001: 02002: 02003: 02004: 02005: 12006: 12007: 02008: 02009: 12010: 62011: 02012: 02013: 42014: 12015: 02016: 02017: 1
1985peak 6 in 20102017

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 30 RSS

Using Ideology: Cases of Nonrecognition of the Politics of Research and Practice in Special Education

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · Review of Educational Research · · cited 321× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This critical review focuses on 13 articles and 5 book chapters by prominent special education scholars. These authors write in support of a continuum of special education services and recommend that only the results of empirical research should inform special education practice. They also express wariness about the concept of inclusion and the direction of the inclusion movement. In touting the superiority of their own scholarship, they accuse inclusion supporters of being political, subjective, and ideological. This article challenges the supposed neutrality of the special education status quo and the moral grounding of the reviewed authors’ position. Drawing from the insights of theorists who study ideology, the analysis sheds light on the ideological nature of the reviewed authors’ own writing. The major recommendation put forth in this article is that scholars and other…

Self-interest and Liberal Educational Discourse: How Ideology Works for Middle-Class Mothers

Ellen Brantlinger, Massoumeh Majd-Jabbari, Samuel L. Guskin

Education · American Educational Research Journal · · cited 90× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Middle-class mothers typically are viewed as ideal models in terms of their values and goals related to education, participation in their children’s education, and professional involvement in schooling. Yet, the results of this study indicate that educated, middle-class mothers, perceived as liberals who believe in integrated and inclusive education, still support segregated and stratified school structures that mainly benefit students of the middle class. Thompson’s (1990) modes of operation of ideology and strategies of symbolic construction shed light on the ways ideology works to establish and sustain high-income parents’ self-interested educational choices while, at the same time, allowing them to maintain a liberal image. The study illustrates how ideology allows parents to bridge disparate streams of thought and salve the dissonance that results from the contradiction between…

Social Class Distinctions in Adolescents' Reports of Problems and Punishment in School

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · Behavioral Disorders · · cited 85× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Adolescents from high- and low-income backgrounds were interviewed about their perceptions of their own and others' disciplinary infractions and consequences in school. High-income adolescents reported fewer misbehaviors and behaviors which were playful, whereas those of low-income youth stemmed mainly from anger. Low-income adolescents reported a greater number and variety of penalties that seemed both disproportionate to offenses and humiliating in nature. It is suggested that inequitable school conditions for low-income students influence their behaviors and disciplinary practices contribute to their anger and alienation. Moreover, low-income adolescents' acting-out or withdrawal behaviors are likely to be perceived by others as signs of emotional disturbance and not as legitimate responses to social class inequities in school and society.

Influence of Preservice Teachers' Beliefs About Pupil Achievement on Attitudes Toward Inclusion

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · Teacher Education and Special Education The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional Children · · cited 51× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This study identified beliefs about pupils, learning, and schooling held by special education preservice teachers that are likely to influence their support for the inclusion of students with disabilities in general education settings as well as their instructional effectiveness in inclusive settings. By examining written assignments and course and advising discussions, the researcher screened the written and oral narratives of 182 junior and senior majors and minors at various stages of their undergraduate special education teacher preparation. Analysis of narratives revealed that special education preservice teachers held a variety of anti-inclusion beliefs. It is suggested that if inclusion is to be successful, teacher education programs should seek antidotes to these anti-inclusion beliefs.

Poverty, Class, and Disability: A Historical, Social, and Political Perspective

Ellen Brantlinger

Sociology and Political Science · Focus on Exceptional Children · · cited 40× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Although this is a special education publication, in this article I engage the broader topic of creation of social hierarchy.Disability-which is subsumed under the generic construct "losing in stratified relations"-may be somewhat hidden from view.Moreover, for the purpose of clarity of argument, I intentionally oversimplify political positioning by referring to two inclusive sides, "leftists" and "rightists," a framing that challenges the neutrality of most people.Although this may seem to have little relevance to special educators, insights gained from a "big picture" view can shed light on current practice.I use graduation exit ("gateway") exams to show how social class relations are manifest _ in school practice.After deconstructing the negative, I put forward ideas for reform and ask readers to join in a movement to transform hierarchical and excluding relations in school and…

The conflicted pedagogical and curricular perspectives of middle-class mothers

Ellen Brantlinger, Massoumeh Majd-Jabbari

Education · Journal of Curriculum Studies · · cited 26× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Advocates of progressive education have been frustrated by the lack of success in implementing and sustaining progressive school reform. The ideals of progressive education are associated with educated professionals and middle-class parentsespecially mothers- are influential in determining the nature of education for their children and, inadvertently, for all children. This study examines the attitudes towards schooling of middle-class, college-educated mothers in order to discern their curricular and pedagogical preferences. The findings indicate that an impediment to progressive reform is the lack of support for progressive forms of schooling among its supposed proponents, the college-educated members of the middle class. On one level middle-class parents espouse the liberal notions of open, integrated, multicultural, student-centred education that are typically associated with…

Making Decisions About Special Education Placement: Do Low-Income Parents Have the Information They Need?

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · Journal of Learning Disabilities · · cited 24× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Using the hypotheses-generating techniques of Glaser and Strauss (1967), interviews were conducted with 35 low-income parents in an attempt to ascertain their knowledge of and their feelings about the adequacy of schooling in general and special education services in particular. Thirty-six percent of the respondents had school-aged children who were receiving special education services. The majority of parents had positive feelings about special education, although parents of learning disabled students perceived their children and their children's educational needs differently from parents of mildly mentally retarded students. Parents had given permission for special education placement, but it was found that they lacked the information essential for making informed decisions.

Inward Gaze and Activism as Moral Next Steps in Inquiry

Ellen Brantlinger

Sociology and Political Science · Anthropology & Education Quarterly · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

When researchers get to know situations through studies, they are likely to form opinions about the legitimacy of certain practices. Yet, in local studies, if they divulge their findings and express opinions openly, the comfortable distance between professional career and private life disappears. In this article I explore the nature of praxis and its impact on scholars' status in community and university. In spite of recognizing the stress of engaging in praxis, I still recommend that researchers endorse standards consistent with Enlightenment, modernist goals and engage in democratically transformative activism in conjunction with their scholarly careers.

Low-Income Adolescents' Perceptions of School, Intelligence, and Themselves as Students

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · Curriculum Inquiry · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACTUsing naturalistic methodologies, 40 low-income teenagers were interviewed regarding their own, their peers', and their parents' attitudes toward school; their feelings about the purposes and personal influences of school; and their ideas about the nature and importance of intelligence. Results indicate considerable correspondence between low-income adolescents' and the general public's views of school, intelligence, and the causes of poor school performance. Adolescents tended to internalize the negative messages they received in the school setting and blame themselves for school failure. Problematic is the fact that low- income adolescents were not very critical of a system that does not work well for them.

Teachers’ Perceptions of the Sexuality of their Secondary Students with Mild Mental Retardation

Ellen Brantlinger

Safety Research · Education and training in mental retardation · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Using a naturalistic research design, 22 teachers of secondary students classified as EMR were interviewed about their perceptions of their students’ feelings, attitudes, knowledge and behaviors related to sexuality. Results indicate that these students have limited and / or distorted information about sexual topics and hold attitudes that, teachers believe, result in problematic situations for them and others.

Professionals' Attitudes toward the Sterilization of People with Disabilities

Ellen Brantlinger

Safety Research · Research and Practice for Persons with Severe Disabilities · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Semistructured interviews were used to explore the attitudes of legal, medical, social welfare, developmental disabilities agency, and educational professionals toward the sterilization of people with disabilities. It was found that opinions about sterilization were integrally related to attitudes toward individuals with disabilities, as well as toward their parenting skills and general sexuality. Most professionals had been involved in some capacity with sterilization cases of people with disabilities and were concerned about present practices, although there was little consensus about how sterilization should be handled.

Teachers' Moral Authority in Classrooms: (Re)Structuring Social Interactions and Gendered Power

Ellen Brantlinger, Mary Lou Morton, Sandra Washburn

Education · The Elementary School Journal · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Studies focused on the school lives of students have identified interactional problems that occur in unstructured social situations. Although in early ethnographies boys' behaviors were of concern, several recent studies have documented problematic actions on the part of girls. Although this article addresses peer relations and learning conditions across gender, we do make girls' education central as we observe 2 teachers who we believe move in the direction of creating a moral framework for structuring humane treatment, respectful social relations, and "authentic learning" for all students. We conclude with recommendations for how teachers can assume the "moral authority" to create inclusive, caring, and participatory classrooms that are conducive to the development of democratic citizens.

Low-Income Parents' Opinions about the Social Class Composition of Schools

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · American Journal of Education · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Social class school segregation has not been the focus of much attention either on the level of school policy-making or in research journals. It has been observed that middle-class parents strive to enable their children to attend predominantly middle-class schools, which they define as "good schools," but there is little information on the school preferences of low-income parents, particularly relating to the social class composition of schools. Naturalistic methodology, involving home interviews with 35 low-income parents, was utilized to assess parents' perceptions of their low-income schools and to learn their opinions about social class school desegregation. Low-income parents were found to be aware of the class character of local schools and to believe that high-income schools were of superior quality. Although parents suggested that problems would result from mixing poor and rich…

Conclusion: Whose Labels? Whose Norms? Whose Needs? Whose Benefits?

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In studying a comprehensive girls school in England, Benjamin (2002) found that the students identified as disabled had few positive identity resources available to them. Given the oppressive nature of American schools for poor children and children of color, it is difficult for them to acquire an acceptable identity that recognizes their strengths, is located in reality, joins them with others, reflects their inner being, and leads to the realization of their potential. Clearly, for children in subordinate positions, these unresolved identity issues cause conflict, stress, and crisis (Erikson, 1968; Maslow, 1970). The problem with identity construction is that, regardless of individuals’ identity aspirations, identity is never entirely under their personal control. Identity is “socially bestowed, socially sustained, and socially transformed” (Berger, 1963, p. 98). Studying how labeling…

High-Income and Low-Income Adolescents' Views of Special Education

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · Journal of Adolescent Research · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

As a component of a comprehensive qualitative study of social class influences on schooling, 34 high-income and 40 low-income adolescents were interviewed about various aspects of special education. Qf the low-income respondents, 55% had been classified as learning disabled, mildly mentally handicapped, or emotionally disturbed and had received special education services at some time during theirschooling; whereas only two (6%) high-income adolescents had been classified as learning disabled. Nonclassified low-income students also had considerable contact with friends, neighbors, and relatives who had received special education services. The majority of low-income adolescents had ambivalent or negative feelings about special education. High-income adolescents had little contact with students classified as handicapped and, with few exceptions, they saw special education as a helpful…

IMPLICATIONS OF SOCIAL AND CULTURAL DIFFERENCES FOR SPECIAL EDUCATION WITH SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS

Ellen Brantlinger, Samuel L. Guskin

Education · Focus on Exceptional Children · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Programs for multicultural, nonsexist, and handicap awareness share a number of common characteristics and goals. All three focus on diminishing the stereotypes of their respective groups and on increasing their power. Their goals are to enhance academic performance and general student competence and to improve interaction among diverse groups of students, enabling these students to work together for a future they all share.

An Application of Gramsci´s “Who Benefits?” to High-Stakes Testing

Ellen Brantlinger

Political Science and International Relations · Open Collections · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

To discern reasons behind the spate of official state and federal mandates for high-stakes tests as well as other stringent standards and accountability measures, in this article, I turn to what Italian Marxist, Antonio Gramsci claimed should be the perennially essential question to ask related to social actions; that is, "Who benefits?" I make the case that various forms of dominance are established or strengthened through recent state and federal legislation.

In Ellisonian Eyes, What is Curriculum Theory?

Ellen Brantlinger

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Howard and Tappan have written a thoughtful and engaging essay in which they assert that rather than seeing identity solely as economic status it is beneficial to use the concept of identity to create an explanatory framework for understanding social class. To provide the rationale for class analysis, they preface their chapter with a compelling review of the growing inequities in schools and society. They make a broad theoretical sweep to explain the relevance of correspondence theory, habitus, performance theory, and ideology to understanding class relations. I was delighted that the authors’ mentioned “moral ideologies” because I am convinced that the moral prerogatives that undergird scholarly work must be articulated. I personally am explicit in insisting on the necessity of basing one’s scholarly contributions on a social reciprocity morality that acknowledges human commonalities…

The Influence of Teacher Gender on Students' Access to Knowledge about Their Sexual and Intimate Social Selves.

Ellen Brantlinger

Gender Studies · Feminist Teacher · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The understanding that adults have of themselves as sexual, intimate social, and familial entities is likely to have an impact on their success and feelings of fulfillment in a variety of relationship and domestic contexts. Additionally, the problems experienced in these domains because of the lack of information may be severe, even life-threatening. Expressions of concern about the nature and quality of sexual and family relationships are prominent in the media from scholarly journals to the tabloids. Yet, individuals' access to meaningful knowledge about sexuality and intimate social relations is very limited; schools rarely provide comprehensive sexuality education programming, in spite of the fact that there are few other sources of accurate information. Some might argue that such knowledge is not well enough defined to become part of the standard curriculum in either public schools…

Critical Theory Perspective on Social Class, Race, Gender, and Classroom Management

Ellen Brantlinger, Scot Danforth

Education · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter takes a critical theory perspective to address how students and teachers’ social class, race, and gender influence the dynamics of classroom life. Lincoln and Guba (2000) call critical theory a research paradigm, hence the critical orientation is fitting for this alternative paradigms section. Critical theory, historically and currently, has the radical democratic aim of understanding and eliminating the power imbalances that exist between people in various social settings. As critical educational scholar Leistyna (1999) writes:MAJOR THEMES AND THEORIES IN CRITICAL SCHOLARSHIPCritical scholars rarely prescribe classroom strategies; however, ideas for schools are implied in the issues they research. Because they focus on problems, critical theorists often are accused of being negative. Yet, their efforts to reduce oppressive hierarchies indicate they are more accurately…

Examining Social Class Reproduction at Micro and Emic Levels

Ellen Brantlinger

Demography · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this study of the school system of an Indiana town, Ellen Brantlinger studies educational expectations within segments of the middle class that have fairly high levels of attainment. Building on her findings, she examines the relationship between class structure and educational success. This book asserts the need to look beyond poor peoples' values and aspirations--and rather to consider the values of dominant groups--to explain class stratification and educational outcomes.

Class Position, Social Life, and School Outcomes

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

S chool personnel with considerable experience in the Hillsdale district were purposefully selected for this study because (1) they would be likely to be informed about schools and (2) they might have the security and confidence to be candid in expressing their views. A list of personnel in the district was obtained from the central administration and a cross-section was chosen to represent (1) schools located in higherand lower-income neighborhoods; (2) a grade-level distribution from elementary through high school; and (3) teaching and administrative ranks. The school-based experience of participants ranged from 3 years to 41 years. Two had taught fewer than 5 years: an itinerant teacher had taught art at various highand low-income schools and a secondary social studies teacher had attended Hillsdale schools. Twenty-two teachers and eight administrators were interviewed (see Table 2.2…

Positions and Outlooks of Teachers at Different Schools

Ellen Brantlinger

Education · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

It is widely acknowledged that social class-related hierarchies prevail in American education. Although few professionals deny that school circumstances and outcomes correspond to social class status, it seems they presume this results from adults of their class striving hard to succeed in occupations and settle in good neighborhoods, parents of their class caring about schooling and providing intellectually stimulating home environments, and children of their class being smart and having high aspirations and good work ethics. Thus, they are inclined to attribute stratified school structures and outcomes to the essentially superior traits of higher social classes and the natural result of fair competition in meritocratic schools and job markets. Furthermore, they insist that for life to become more equitable, the poor must become more like themselves.

Examining Social Class Reproduction at Micro and Emic Levels: A Critical, Interpretive Study

Ellen Brantlinger

Health · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A lready there school personnel knew that affluent Hillsdale school patrons negotiated school advantage and segregation, but most saw this as legitimate parental behavior. In contrast, in-the-middle teachers and administrators disapproved of their actions and were upset about disparities, favoritism, and elitism. The essence of any social class system is that resources flow to powerful constituencies, and an unequal distribution of material and status resources exist. Yet it is also the nature of the system for those on the losing end of the distribution to protest and resist the implicit hierarchies. After many close readings of interview transcripts and much pondering over teachers' narratives, I came to the conclusion that damaging repercussions for school equity arise not only from status and power differentials between affluent families and poor families but also from differentials…

Affluent Mothers Narrate Their Own and Other People’s Children

Ellen Brantlinger

Gender Studies · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this study of the school system of an Indiana town, Ellen Brantlinger studies educational expectations within segments of the middle class that have fairly high levels of attainment. Building on her findings, she examines the relationship between class structure and educational success. This book asserts the need to look beyond poor peoples' values and aspirations--and rather to consider the values of dominant groups--to explain class stratification and educational outcomes.