Education · The Future of Children · · cited 210× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Beginning as early as preschool, race and gender are intertwined with the way US schools mete out discipline. In particular, black students and male students are much more likely than others to be suspended or expelled—punishments that we know can hold them back academically. These disparities, and the damage they can cause, have driven recent reforms, including some that incorporate social and emotional learning (SEL) practices.
Education · Teachers College Record The Voice of Scholarship in Education · · cited 176× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Background/Context The last two reauthorizations of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act established a policy mandate for districts to take action to reduce high rates of minority overrepresentation in special education. Purpose/Objective/Research Question/Focus of Study The overrepresentation of Black and Latino students in special education suggests a convergence of two distinct processes: (1) assumptions of cultural deficit that result in unclear or misguided conceptualizations of disability and (2) the subsequent labeling of students in special education through a pseudoscientific placement process. This article explores how the social construct of the “normal child” became racialized through the special education referral and classification process, and subsequently produces disproportionality. Setting This research was conducted in two multiracial suburban school…
Education · Review of Research in Education · · cited 90× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
In the review, we examine what is known about disproportionality with the intention of informing the direction of policy and practice remedies. We outline the definition, contours, and characteristics of disproportionality and examine some of the prevailing explanations as to why the issue persists. We then pivot the review to consider how policy, through the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), has sought to address disproportionality in special education and disciplining of students with disabilities. We question why a legally sound civil rights law like IDEA has been unable to abate disproportionality for nearly 40 years. We then turn our attention to review interventions embedded in IDEA that have been recommended to address disproportionality and question why they have not improved outcomes for “nondominant” students in special education. We conclude with some…
Sociology and Political Science · Teachers College Record The Voice of Scholarship in Education · · cited 53× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Background/Context For the last 40 years, researchers have posited competing theories regarding the relative influence of social class background and racial-group membership on the school experiences, academic performance, behavior, and motivation of ethnic minority students. The general purpose of these competing theories has been to explain why ethnic minority students fail or succeed in schools. Many of these theories consider factors inside the school and the child's family, culture, racial/ethnic group affiliation, and responses to school. These theories are commonly situated into three categories of thought: cultural deprivation, cultural difference/discontinuity, and cultural ecology. Each theory juxtaposes dimensions of race as a significant variable, but each has omitted the meaning of race/ethnicity as internally and externally constructed, particularly among Latino groups.…
Education · School Psychology Review · · cited 35× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Few studies explicitly examine how opportunity structures impact school safety, school climate, or bullying. This article applies school-centered ecological theory as a heuristic conceptual framework that links opportunity structures and school safety. Historically, opportunity structures identified how institutional characteristics such as labor conditions, combined with factors such as geographic location, gender, race, religion, nationality, ethnicity, and family background, influence the opportunities open to individuals and shape patterns of entering the labor market. In education, the concept has been used when describing systemic racism in educational inequality. Examples are drawn from several bodies of research that have strong implications for future study of these issues. These areas include research on communities and families, creating positive school cultures and climates…
Sociology and Political Science · Theory Into Practice · · cited 28× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
In 1954, the Supreme Court ruled schools in the United States needed to desegregate and begin integration. The decision was a radical departure from the facilities argument initially presented; it added the issue that the segregation of Black students was having a deleterious effect on their self-concept. Many scholars argue the integration has not been sustained (Orfield and Frankenberg, 2014); in fact, a recent report highlights Black, Latino and Native American students are less integrated with White and Asian students than in 1954 (Orfield and Frankenberg, 2014). However the Brown decision set forth another integration project – the integration of White practitioners (i.e., teachers and principals) with Black, Latino and Native American student populations! This article brings together an array of social interaction research that articulates the complexity of this integration…
Education · Reading & Writing Quarterly · · cited 22× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Abstract Changes in the demography of the nation's public schools are occurring at a dramatic pace. In states such as California, Texas, and Florida, new immigrants comprise more than a third of the student population. In major cities such as New York, Miami, and Los Angeles, they comprise more than 40% of the student population. Similar changes are occurring in small towns and rural areas throughout the country. This article examines (a) how Washington Elementary, a suburban school, has responded to these dramatic demographic changes; and (b) why this particular school has produced dramatic academic success among immigrant students when so many other suburban schools have not. This article focuses on understanding the school's practices and their implications for literacy achievement. It focuses on whether the interaction between organizational and programmatic practices and the…
Sociology and Political Science · Urban Education · · cited 17× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Discussions on Latino/a students’ interpretation of the opportunity structure and schooling treat racial/ethnic identification among Latino/as as static, despite skin color variation. This article provides findings from interviews with six Mexican students who discussed teachers identifying them as “White-looking” or “Hispanic/Mexican-looking.” Both groups shared belief in the achievement ideology and understood the opportunity structure as fraught with barriers. However, the “White-looking” students perceived themselves as being able to permeate such barriers meanwhile the “Hispanic/Mexican-looking” students believed such barriers affect their ability to “make it” regardless of their aspirations. This study raises questions regarding theories on academic variability of Latino/a students.
Sociology and Political Science · Theory Into Practice · · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
The process of Latino self-identification, both racially and ethnically, is of limited conversation among educators. The research on Latinos focuses on either their ethnic construction or absence of including a racial identification. This article focuses on the span of research about ethnicity and race for Latino groups.
Since the last version of this chapter in 2014, national events, including and most especially the murder of George Floyd, have created a virtual sea change in our national understanding of race and racism. Scholarly research is not, and cannot be, unaffected by this shift. In this chapter, we review recent research on racialized disciplinary disparities in light of America’s “racial reckoning,” specifically using the lens of structural racism. We explore previous descriptions of the term to develop a working definition, and examine the extent to which exclusionary discipline serves as a key mechanism in a network of structural racism, supporting a racialized hierarchy that reproduces inequity and disadvantage. Arguing that a color-blind ideology is the central belief system undergirding structural racism in the twenty-first century, we discuss its components in relationship to recent…
Sociology and Political Science · Phi Delta Kappan · · cited 11× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Colorblindness is socially acceptable bias that lives in our personal and institutional beliefs. Its existence inhibits our ability to recognize and respond to the realities of the lives of students of color. The author outlines several activities that educators can use to surface beliefs about race during staff meetings and the like.
The education, employment/labor, and incarceration status of Latino males in the United States is a complex one. Although the conditions of this population mirror those of other vulnerable populations, their status is far less explored and understood. There are many possible reasons for this lack of focus on Latino males. First, Latinos are by definition an extraordinarily diverse group, comprised of individuals from a variety of countries and racial and ethnic backgrounds, and these regional variations result in significantly different Latino experiences. Second, because of the diversity within the Latino population, many of the challenges that are specific to Latino males often go unrecognized and, therefore, do not receive the attention they deserve. When Latinos are disaggregated by national origin, social class, or region, it becomes clear that certain groups are particularly…
Many school practitioners think of poverty as a kind of “culture,” characterized by dysfunctional behaviors that can only be corrected by imposing harsh discipline on students. Further, beliefs about poverty are often used to justify racial disparities in disciplinary referrals, achievement, and enrollment in gifted, AP, and honors courses, as well as to justify harsh punishments for “disobedience” or “disorderly conduct” or “disrespect.” Edward Fergus suggests that educators learn to understand their blind spots related to race and culture and to seek out feedback on the degree to which members of the school community experience bias.
Education · Preventing School Failure Alternative Education for Children and Youth · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
The prevalence of racial disparities in discipline outcomes continues despite a prominence of new strategies and research. When implemented with fidelity, PBIS (Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports) is shown to contribute to reductions in school suspension, expulsion, and other positive educational outcomes. Despite its promise for making school discipline more efficient and less exclusionary, PBIS in some schools struggles to address disproportionate patterns of exclusion and office referrals. This commentary offers the use of critical race theory framing as a way to understand how teachers’ beliefs about race and culture operate within their personalized lives and transfer themselves within the schooling environment.
Education · School Psychology Review · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
The current policy terrain is primed for schools to absorb new discipline strategies and address bias-based beliefs. Over the past 10 years, numerous policy changes regarding discipline have emerged at the federal and state levels. I argue these policy shifts, primarily at the state level, are using two of four value levers (quality, efficiency, choice, and equity) identified in research as the impetus for policy development. I focus on the quality and efficiency levers, as I believe these have been central to the recent changes in discipline policy. Quality is defined in terms of optimal educational experiences, such as instructional time, rehabilitative discipline, and appropriate behavioral interventions based on age. This quality frame suggests that behavioral interventions should not jeopardize instructional time or be inappropriate toward children. Another basis for policy shifts…
The conversation on the school-to-prison pipeline among boys of color is complex and involves understanding how the 4 C’s— classroom, cops, courts, and community— interface to create a pipeline. However, what has been underconceptualized is whether and how notions of masculinity and boyhood that emerge within these institutions may operate as an invisible connective tissue across these institutions. In other words, the manner in which the bodies of Black and Latino males are viewed, interacted with, and treated within these institutions provides a rationalizing frame for how the actions within institutions occur. In this special issue, we theorize that, to understand the ways in which the school-to-prison pipeline operates for boys of color, there needs to be theoretical exploration through empirical work of what notions of masculinity are promoted and detracted within these…
The focus of this study is on the ways in which skin color moderates the perceptions of opportunity and academic orientation of 17 Mexican and Puerto Rican high school students. More specifically, the study's analysis centered on cataloguing the racial/ethnic identification process of these students which includes how their identification shifts (or not) in relation to how they perceive others situate them based on skin color. The students' experienced others (primarily African American students and teachers) situating them into three discrete racial and ethnic categories: (1) White-looking; (2) Hispanic/Mexican-looking; and (3) Black/Biracial-looking. Each skin color grouping not only reported different experiences of treatment, discrimination and privilege but also their experiences of being racialized based on skin color were implicated in their perceptions of opportunity and…
Sociology and Political Science · eScholarship (California Digital Library) · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·
The brief describes original research and and new theoretical paradigms to examine the severe social, educational, and economic disadvantages, hardships, and vulnerabilities experienced by Latino men and boys, ones that include high dropout rates, disproportionate levels of incarceration, and their concentration in low wage jobs. Through the application of the theoretical framework of intersectionality, the brief identifies ways in which policy and programs can address restructuring social institutions and re-designing public policy.
As much as Latino groups are an ever-present component of the educational discourse on academic variability, there is a predominant situating of the Latino population as a monolithic group. Yet recent data have documented the vast diversity within this population. According to Census 2000, over 35 million Latinos were living in the United States at that time. By mid-decade, this number rose to 42 million. The rapid and dramatic growth of the Latino population represented 51 percent of the change in racial/ethnic groups between 2000 and 2005 (Pew Hispanic Center, 2006). Given our shared border, the majority of the 42 million were Mexican (64 percent), followed by Puerto Ricans (9.1 percent), Cubans (3.5 percent), Salvadorans (3.0 percent), and Dominicans (1.7 percent). In Census 2000, over 900,000 Latinos (2.7 percent) self-identified as Black Hispanic and 17.6 million (47.9 percent) as…
According to the 2000 Census, over 35 million Latinos/as were living in the United States (U.S.). By mid-decade, the figure had increased to 42 million, and data for the 2010 Census signaled that the number had exceeded 50 million. The rapid and dramatic growth of Latino/a residency accounted for 55% of the population change between 2000 and 2010 (Humes, Jones, & Ramirez, 2011). Given the shared border, the majority of Latinos/as in the U.S. are of Mexican descent (64%), followed by Puerto Ricans (9.1%), Cubans (3.5%), Salvadorans (3.0%), and Dominicans (1.7%).
The chapters in this book provide a launching pad from which a set of policy interventions and policy principles can be proposed. Our hope in offering these is that community activists, politicians, practitioners, and policy makers can utilize them to counter the marginalization of Latino men and boys in various arenas. In addition, the incisive scholarship presented in this volume points to the areas where further research is needed to sharpen an understanding of the issues confronting Latino men and boys.
The chapters in this book provide a launching pad from which a set of policy interventions and policy principles can be proposed. Our hope in offering these is that community activists, politicians, practitioners, and policy makers can utilize them to counter the marginalization of Latino men and boys in various arenas. In addition, the incisive scholarship presented in this volume points to the areas where further research is needed to sharpen an understanding of the issues confronting Latino men and boys.
Demography · English Journal of the English Association · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
The Principal objective of the Approaches to Teaching series is ‘to collect within each volume different points of view on teaching’ (Joseph Gibaldi, Preface to the Series). By surveying sixty-one university teachers and one independent scholar and taking note of the methods they use, the ideas they have and the problems they encounter while teaching Bleak House, the editors of this volume have collected an impressively diverse range of pedagogical tools. Part I, ‘Materials’, reproduces a few relevant images (Phiz's illustrations, Punch cartoons) then gallops us through bibliographies, reference works, and other materials: sources for more illustrations, advertisements in the original monthly numbers, DVDs, and web resources. Finally, we are given a selection of suggested reading for students and teachers – Dickens biographies, critical and theoretical essays, and contextual reading…
The focus of this study is on the ways in which skin color moderates the perceptions of opportunity and academic orientation of 17 Mexican and Puerto Rican high school students. More specifically, the study's analysis centered on cataloguing the racial/ethnic identification shifts (or not) in relation to how they perceive others situate them based on skin color.
The focus of this study is on the ways in which skin color moderates the perceptions of opportunity and academic orientation of 17 Mexican and Puerto Rican high school students. More specifically, the study's analysis centered on cataloguing the racial/ethnic identification shifts (or not) in relation to how they perceive others situate them based on skin color.