arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

David Collier

84 papers · 1974–2024

1974: 11975: 21976: 01977: 21978: 11979: 11980: 11981: 01982: 21983: 01984: 11985: 01986: 01987: 01988: 01989: 11990: 01991: 41992: 21993: 31994: 01995: 01996: 21997: 11998: 21999: 32000: 12001: 22002: 02003: 02004: 12005: 12006: 32007: 22008: 32009: 112010: 42011: 42012: 32013: 42014: 52015: 32016: 12017: 22018: 02019: 02020: 12021: 02022: 02023: 32024: 1
1974peak 11 in 20092024

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 84 RSS

Measurement Validity: A Shared Standard for Qualitative and Quantitative Research

David Collier, Robert Adcock

Political Science and International Relations · eScholarship (California Digital Library) · · cited 1,575× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Scholars routinely make claims that presuppose the validity of the observations and measurements that operationalize their concepts. Yet, despite recent advances in political science methods, surprisingly little attention has been devoted to measurement validity. We address this gap by exploring four themes. First, we seek to establish a shared framework that allows quantitative and qualitative scholars to assess more effectively, and communicate about, issues of valid measurement. Second, we underscore the need to draw a clear distinction between measurement issues and disputes about concepts. Third, we discuss the contextual specificity of measurement claims, exploring a variety of measurement strategies that seek to combine generality and validity by devoting greater attention to context. Fourth, we address the proliferation of terms for alternative measurement validation procedures…

Shaping the Political Arena: Critical Junctures, the Labor Movement and Regime Dynamics in Latin America

Abraham F. Lowenthal, Ruth Berins Collier, David Collier

Political Science and International Relations · Foreign Affairs · · cited 1,113× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Ruth Berins Collier and David Collier are political scientists who use comparative historical research to discover and evaluate patterns and sources of political change. Their work is an overall analysis of Chile, Brazil, Uruguay, Colombia, Argentina, Peru, Venezuela, and Mexico, plus case studies of four distinct pairs in that group: Chile/Brazil, Uruguay/Colombia, Argentina/Peru, and Venezuela/Mexico. In addition, the Colliers meticulously describe and discuss their methods for the study including the limitations of their approach. The authors specifically focus on why and how organized labor movements in the first half of the twentieth century were incorporated into the political process in the eight Latin American countries they study. They analyze the role played by political parties, central government control, worker mobilization, and conflict between radical vs. centrist…

Rethinking Social Inquiry: Diverse Tools, Shared Standards

Henry E. Brady, David Collier

Sociology and Political Science · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 880× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

With innovative new chapters on process tracing, regression analysis, and natural experiments, the second edition of Rethinking Social Inquiry further extends the reach of this path-breaking book. The original debate with King, Keohane, and Verba remains central to the volume, and the new material illuminates evolving discussions of essential methodological tools. Thus, process tracing is often invoked as fundamental to qualitative analysis, but is rarely applied with precision. Pitfalls of regression analysis are sometimes noted, but often are inadequately examined. And the complex assumptions and trade-offs of natural experiments are poorly understood. The second edition extends the methodological horizon through exploring these critical tools. A distinctive feature of this edition is the online placement of four chapters from the prior edition, all focused on the dialogue with King…

Putting Typologies to Work

David Collier, Jody LaPorte, Jason Seawright

Sociology and Political Science · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 423× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Typologies are well-established analytic tools in the social sciences. They can be “put to work” in forming concepts, refining measurement, exploring dimensionality, and organizing explanatory claims. Yet some critics, basing their arguments on what they believe are relevant norms of quantitative measurement, consider typologies old-fashioned and unsophisticated. This critique is methodologically unsound, and research based on typologies can and should proceed according to high standards of rigor and careful measurement. These standards are summarized in guidelines for careful work with typologies, and an illustrative inventory of typologies, as well as a brief glossary, are included online.

Essentially contested concepts: Debates and applications

David Collier, F. Daniel Hidalgo, Andra Olivia Maciuceanu

Law · Journal of Political Ideologies · · cited 387× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Conceptual confusion has long been a source of difficulty in the study of politics. W. B. Gallie's analysis of ‘essentially contested concepts’, published in 1956, stands as a notable effort to address this problem. He explores the normative component of these concepts and offers seven criteria for evaluating their contestedness. In the present article, we examine Gallie's framework and develop two extended applications, focused on ‘democracy’ and ‘rule of law’. We underscore major contributions of Gallie's approach, as well as controversies it has generated. Some important critiques argue that three of his criteria are too narrow. We suggest that these critics fail to recognize that Gallie offers both a restrictive and broader definition of these criteria, and we seek to reconcile their views with his alternative definitions. Further, some accuse Gallie of naively promoting conceptual…

Democracy with Adjectives: Conceptual Innovation in Comparative Research

David Collier, Steven Levitsky

Sociology and Political Science · World Politics · · cited 299× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The recent trend toward democratization in countries across the globe has challenged scholars to pursue two potentially contradictory goals. On the one hand, they seek to increase analytic differentiation in order to capture the diverse forms of democracy that have emerged. On the other hand, they are concerned with conceptual validity. Specifically, they seek to avoid the problem of conceptual stretching that arises when the concept of democracy is applied to cases for which, by relevant scholarly standards, it is not appropriate. This article argues that the pursuit of these two goals has led to a proliferation of conceptual innovations, including numerous subtypes of democracy—that is to say, democracy “with adjectives.” The article explores the strengths and weaknesses of alternative strategies of conceptual innovation that have emerged: descending and climbing Sartori's ladder of…

Aggregate Safety Stock Levels and Component Part Commonality

David Collier

Education · Management Science · · cited 213× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The relationship between aggregate safety stock inventory levels and component part commonality is developed. A simulation experiment strongly supports the functional form of this relationship in an uncertain operating environment. Managers can use these equations to assess the trade-offs between aggregate safety stock levels, service level and the degree of component part standardization. For example, these relationships can be used to predict service, inventory level and cost standards for any change in component part commonality.

Measurement Validity: A Shared Standard for Qualitative and Quantitative Research

Robert Adcock, David Collier

Political Science and International Relations · American Political Science Review · · cited 186× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Scholars routinely make claims that presuppose the validity of the observations and measurements that operationalize their concepts. Yet, despite recent advances in political science methods, surprisingly little attention has been devoted to measurement validity. We address this gap by exploring four themes. First, we seek to establish a shared framework that allows quantitative and qualitative scholars to assess more effectively, and communicate about, issues of valid measurement. Second, we underscore the need to draw a clear distinction between measurement issues and disputes about concepts. Third, we discuss the contextual specificity of measurement claims, exploring a variety of measurement strategies that seek to combine generality and validity by devoting greater attention to context. Fourth, we address the proliferation of terms for alternative measurement validation procedures…

Conceptual “Stretching” Revisited: Adapting Categories in Comparative Analysis

David Collier, James E. Mahon

Sociology and Political Science · American Political Science Review · · cited 171× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

When scholars extend their models and hypotheses to encompass additional cases, they commonly need to adapt their analytic categories to fit the new contexts. Giovanni Sartori's work on conceptual “traveling” and conceptual “stretching” provides helpful guidance in addressing this fundamental task of comparative analysis. Yet Sartori's framework draws upon what may be called classical categorization, which views the relation among categories in terms of a taxonomic hierarchy, with each category having clear boundaries and defining properties shared by all members. We examine the challenge to this framework presented by two types of nonclassical categories: family resemblances and radial categories. With such categories, the overly strict application of a classical framework can lead to abandoning to category prematurely or to modifying it inappropriately. We discuss solutions to these…

The New Authoritarianism in Latin America.

Ian Roxborough, David Collier

Sociology and Political Science · The Economic Journal · · cited 161× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Journal Article The New Authoritarianism in Latin America Get access The New Authoritarianism in Latin America. Edited by DAVID COLLIER. (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1979. Pp. 458. £15.10 hardback, £3.65 paperback.) Ian Roxborough Ian Roxborough London School of Economics Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Google Scholar The Economic Journal, Volume 90, Issue 359, 1 September 1980, Pages 635–637, https://doi.org/10.2307/2231940 Published: 01 September 1980

Typologies: Forming Concepts and Creating Categorical Variables

David Collier, Jody LaPorte, Jason Seawright

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 140× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article describes the categories and typologies as an optic for looking at concept formation and measurement. It also provides an overview of the multiple contributions of typologies and presents numerous examples from diverse subfields of political science. It gives a framework for working with multidimensional typologies, outlining the building blocks of typologies, and illustrating how the cell types constitute categorical variables. In addition, the role of typologies in concept formation, the source of the concepts and terms in the cells of the typology, and the role of ideal types are explained. Finally, it explores the contribution of typologies to mapping empirical and theoretical change and to structuring comparison in empirical analysis. It suggests norms for the careful use of typologies. Among the guidelines for careful work with typologies, a significant…

The Comparative Method

David Collier

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 129× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

I The Comparative Method .I I r J, I David Collier Comparison is a fm•d•ny:ntaJ tool of analysis. It shaipeas out power of description, and plays a c:eatral role in coacept-formatioa by bringing into focus suggestive similarities aud contrasts amoog cases. Comparison is routinely used in testing hypotheses, and it can contribute to the inductive discovery of new hypotheses and to theory-building. The forms of comparison employed in the discipline of political science vary widely and include those contained in statistical analysis, experimmtal research, and historical studies. At the same time, the label comparative method bas a standard meaning within the discipline and in the social mote broadly: it refers to the methodological issues that arise in the systematic analysis of a small number of cases, or a small N. 1 This chapter examines alternative perspectives on the comparative…

DEMOCRACY AND DICHOTOMIES: A Pragmatic Approach to Choices about Concepts

David Collier, Robert Adcock

Sociology and Political Science · Annual Review of Political Science · · cited 117× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

▪ Abstract Prominent scholars engaged in comparative research on democratic regimes are in sharp disagreement over the choice between a dichotomous or graded approach to the distinction between democracy and nondemocracy. This choice is substantively important because it affects the findings of empirical research. It is methodologically important because it raises basic issues, faced by both qualitative and quantitative analysts, concerning appropriate standards for justifying choices about concepts. In our view, generic claims that the concept of democracy should inherently be treated as dichotomous or graded are incomplete. The burden of demonstration should instead rest on more specific arguments linked to the goals of research. We thus take the pragmatic position that how scholars understand and operationalize a concept can and should depend in part on what they are going to do with…

Toward a Pluralistic Vision of Methodology

Henry E. Brady, David Collier, Jason Seawright

Sociology and Political Science · Political Analysis · · cited 106× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The discussion of qualitative and quantitative research methods in political science has followed a “long arc of development,” according to Andrew Bennett (this symposium). He sees our book Rethinking Social Inquiry: Diverse Tools, Standards ( RSI ) as a “key turning point” in this development and as contributing to a more pluralistic vision of methodology. We would certainly be gratified if we have indeed made this contribution. Yet this is an ongoing discussion, and this symposium points to fruitful directions this discussion can take.

Insights and Pitfalls: Selection Bias in Qualitative Research

David Collier, James Mahoney

Sociology and Political Science · World Politics · · cited 95× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Qualitative analysts have received stern warnings that the validity of their studies may be undermined by selection bias. This article provides an overview of this problem for qualitative researchers in the field of international and comparative studies, focusing on selection bias that may result from the deliberate selection of cases by the investigator. Examples are drawn from studies of revolution, international deterrence, the politics of inflation, international terms of trade, economic growth, and industrial competitiveness. The article first explores how insights about selection bias developed in quantitative research can most productively be applied in qualitative studies. The discussion considers why qualitative researchers need to be concerned about selection bias, even if they do not care about the generality of their findings, and it considers distinctive implications of…

Squatters and Oligarchs: Authoritarian Rule and Policy Change in Peru

Henry Dietz, David Collier

Political Science and International Relations · The Western Political Quarterly · · cited 93× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Dale Nelson, and Fernando Calderon provided indispensable help in carrying out the interviews for the survey of settlement formation.This survey would not have been possible had it not been for the willingness of present and past community leader.s in the settlements to devote many hours of their time to responding to numerous detailed questions about how their communities were formed.Officials in government offices concerned with problems of housing, as well as private individuals who had worked in this area, also provided valuable assistance.In particular, the staff of the Oficina de Barrios Marginales of the Junta Nacional de la Vivienda and Marcia Koth de Paredes of PLANDEMET generously shared data on squatter settlements and insights on

Prerequisites Versus Diffusion: Testing Alternative Explanations of Social Security Adoption

David Collier, Richard E. Messick

Political Science and International Relations · American Political Science Review · · cited 83× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Cross-national research has, with a few exceptions, dealt exclusively with hypotheses that focus on causal relations within nations. It is increasingly clear both on substantive and methodological grounds, however, that diffusion effects among nations must also be considered. The present research combines these alternative perspectives in an analysis of the timing of the first adoption of social security in nations. It is found that not only prerequisites explanations—which focus on causes within each nation—but also spatial and hierarchical diffusion effects must be considered in explaining patterns of social security adoption. The most important overall pattern, which appears to result from diffusion, is the tendency for later adopters to adopt at lower levels of modernization. This finding is interpreted as being due in part to a general tendency toward a larger role of the state in…

The Comparative Method: Two Decades of Change

David Collier

Political Science and International Relations · eScholarship (California Digital Library) · · cited 81× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Chapter 2 COMPARATIVE POLITICAL o DYNAMICS : Global qResearch Perspectives. Edited by by Dankwart A. Rustow City University of New York Graduate School and University Center Kenneth Paul Erickson Hunter College and City University of New York Graduate School and University Center Ha_rperCollins Publishers ' 1;991l7 lThe Comparative Method: Two Decades of Change David Collier “And what should they know of England who only England know? q Rudyard Kipling‘ ' qNations can be understood only in comparative perspective. q Seymour Martin Li_pset2- The idea that comparison is a “good thing” is built into our intuitive sense of how we understand the world. Comparison sharpens our powers of description and can be an invaluable stimulus to concept for- mation. It provides criteria for testing hypotheses and contributes to the inductive discovery of new hypotheses and to theory building.‘…

Qualitative and Multimethod Research: Organizations, Publication, and Reflections on Integration

David Collier, Colin Elman

Sociology and Political Science · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 63× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article describes the rapid development of institutions for the study of qualitative methods in the past decade. It first begins by presenting an overview of the approach to methodology that underpins the idea of qualitative and multimethod work. It then discusses these new organizations, in particular the Organized Section on Qualitative and Multi-Method Research of the American Political Science Association, and the annual Institute for Qualitative and Multi-Method Research. It outlines the patterns of publication, and a conclusion considers briefly the merits of an integrative, versus a separate tracks, approach to coordinating alternative methodologies. The formation of the organizations linked with qualitative/multimethod work reflected the need for methodologists with convergent skills and objectives to have a meaningful forum for dialogue.

Putting Typologies to Work: Concept Formation, Measurement, and Analytic Rigor

David Collier, Jody LaPorte, Jason Seawright

Sociology and Political Science · eScholarship (California Digital Library) · · cited 61× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Typologies are a well-established analytic tool in the social sciences. Working with typologies contributes decisively to forming concepts, exploring dimensionality, establishing measurement categories, and grouping cases. Yet some critics – basing their arguments on what they believe to be relevant norms of quantitative measurement – consider typologies to be an old-fashioned and unsophisticated mode of analysis. We show that this critique is methodologically unsound. The use of typologies can and should proceed according to high standards of rigor. We offer a basic template for constructing typologies and show how they can be “put to work” in refining concepts and measurement, examining underlying dimensions, and organizing explanatory claims and causal inference. The conclusion presents guidelines for careful work with typologies.

Toward a Pluralistic Vision of Methodology

David Collier, Jason Seawright, Henry E. Brady

Sociology and Political Science · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 60× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Both data-set observations (DSOs) and causal-process observations (CPOs) are important for causal inference. DSOs – located in the standard “rectangular data set” of statistical analysis – make their contribution through a quantitative logic of comparison, frequently using different forms and extensions of regression analysis. They are deservedly a major research tool in political science. Yet when based on observational data, they must be analyzed with great care. Problems such as cofounders, for example, can be hard to address. DSOs are therefore valuable, but serious limitations must be recognized. CPOs provide a different form of analytic leverage. They are carefully selected “nuggets of data” that are a foundation of qualitative research and can have great probative value in evaluating hypotheses. Achieving rigorous inference with CPOs depends on exact specification both of the…

Rival Strategies of Validation

Jason Seawright, David Collier

Political Science and International Relations · Comparative Political Studies · · cited 49× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The challenge of finding appropriate tools for measurement validation is an abiding concern in political science. This article considers four traditions of validation, using examples from cross-national research on democracy: the levels-of-measurement approach, structural-equation modeling with latent variables, the pragmatic tradition, and the case-based method. Methodologists have sharply disputed the merits of alternative traditions. We encourage scholars—and certainly analysts of democracy—to pay more attention to these disputes and to consider strengths and weaknesses in the validation tools they adopt. An online appendix summarizes the evaluation of six democracy data sets from the perspective of alternative approaches to validation. The overall goal is to open a new discussion of alternative validation strategies.

Symposium on Critical Junctures and Historical Legacies

David Collier, Gerardo L. Munck, Sidney Tarrow +8 more

Sociology and Political Science · eScholarship (California Digital Library) · · cited 46× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This symposium brings together ten essays that explore hypotheses about critical junctures, understood as major episodes of institutional innovation that generate an enduring legacy. Scholars routinely focus on episodes of innovation that occur in contrasting ways across cases, which in turn yields distinct trajectories of change and produces different legacies. These contrasts readily lend themselves to analysis based on the comparative method, generally combined with process tracing. For the analysis of single cases, the comparison is typically focused on explicit or implicit counterfactual alternatives that might have produced different trajectories of change. The critical juncture framework is seen as offering a set of hypotheses that may or may not fit a given historical situation, and whose actual fit must be demonstrated with great care.The symposium builds on Lipset and Rokkan’s…

Outdated Views of Qualitative Methods: Time to Move On

David Collier, Henry E. Brady, Jason Seawright

Sociology and Political Science · Political Analysis · · cited 43× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Both qualitative and quantitative research routinely fall short, producing misleading causal inferences. Because these weaknesses are in part different, we are convinced that multimethod strategies are productive. Each approach can provide additional leverage that helps address shortcomings of the other. This position is quite distinct from that of Beck, who believes that the two types of analysis cannot be adjoined. We review examples of adjoining that Beck dismisses, based on what we see as his outdated view of qualitative methods. By contrast, we show that these examples demonstrate how qualitative and quantitative analysis can work together.

Who Does What To Whom and How: Toward a Comparative Analysis of Latin American Corporatism

David Collier, Ruth Berins Collier

Public Administration · eScholarship (California Digital Library) · · cited 40× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In James M. Malloy, ed., Authoritarianisrn and Corporatism in Latin America. Pitsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1977. DAVID COLIJER and RUTH BERINS COLLIER Who Does What, to Whom, and How: Toward a Comparative Analysis of Latin American Corporatism Recent research on Latin American politics has placed substantial emphasis on the authoritarian relationships between national states and interest groups characteristic of the region. Particular attention ‘has been paid to the limitation of pluralism and to “corporative” patterns of interest representation as distinctive features of the systems_ of state-group relations that have emerged. However, though many theo- retical statements and descriptive case studies have qexamined these themes; little cross-national research has systematically compared state- group relations across a number of cases. Yet systematic comparison can yield…