arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Daniel Ghezelbash

19 papers · 2010–2025

2010: 22011: 12012: 02013: 02014: 12015: 12016: 22017: 02018: 22019: 22020: 22021: 12022: 22023: 12024: 02025: 2
2010peak 2 in 20102025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–19 of 19 RSS

SECURITIZATION OF SEARCH AND RESCUE AT SEA: THE RESPONSE TO BOAT MIGRATION IN THE MEDITERRANEAN AND OFFSHORE AUSTRALIA

Daniel Ghezelbash, Violeta Moreno‐Lax, Natalie Klein +1 more

Sociology and Political Science · International and Comparative Law Quarterly · · cited 154× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article compares the law and practice of the European Union and Australia in respect to the search and rescue (SAR) of boat migrants, concluding that the response to individuals in peril at sea in both jurisdictions is becoming increasingly securitized. This has led to the humanitarian purpose of SAR being compromised in the name of border security. Part I contrasts the unique challenge posed by SAR operations involving migrants and asylum seekers, as opposed to other people in distress at sea. Part II analyses the relevant international legal regime governing SAR activities and its operation among European States and in offshore Australia. Part III introduces the securitization framework as the explanatory paradigm for shifting State practice and its impact in Europe and Australia. It then examines the consequences of increasing securitization of SAR in both jurisdictions…

Between life, security and rights: Framing the interdiction of ‘boat migrants’ in the Central Mediterranean and Australia

Violeta Moreno‐Lax, Daniel Ghezelbash, Natalie Klein

Sociology and Political Science · Leiden Journal of International Law · · cited 82× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article sets out two case studies to examine the evolving reality of ‘boat migration’ and the intersecting legal frameworks at play. Our analysis takes a systemic integration approach to reflect on the complex dynamics underpinning responses to the phenomenon in Australia and the Central Mediterranean. The regime that governments purport to act under in any given instance reflects the way they choose to frame incidents and possibly exploit legal gaps in, or contested interpretations of, the relevant rules. The ‘closed ports’ strategy adopted by Italy and Malta against the MV Lifeline and the detention-at-sea policy pursued by Australia are investigated from the competing perspectives of what we call the ‘security lens’ and the ‘humanitarian lens’ to demonstrate how a good faith interpretation of the applicable (if apparently conflicting and overlapping) norms can (and…

The End of the Right to Seek Asylum? COVID-19 and the Future of Refugee Protection

Daniel Ghezelbash, Nikolas Feith Tan

Sociology and Political Science · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 49× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The global pandemic has stopped asylum seekers in their tracks, as States across the world have sealed their borders, suspended asylum procedures, and – in some cases – summarily deported asylum seekers. Some of these measures have been explicitly justified using public health emergency laws. Others have been implemented quietly and informally behind the scenes. As a result, it has been almost impossible for most asylum seekers to travel to access protection. While these drastic measures have come as immediate responses to the spread of COVID-19 across borders, they are best understood as an exacerbation of underlying tendencies towards the extinguishment of the right to seek asylum in the global North. Access to asylum in the developed world has been under pressure since the end of the Cold War, with the emergence of a vast array of non-entrée measures to prevent asylum seekers…

Hyper-Legalism and Obfuscation: How States Evade Their International Obligations Towards Refugees

Daniel Ghezelbash

Sociology and Political Science · The American Journal of Comparative Law · · cited 30× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This Article examines how wealthy democratic states evade and avoid their international obligations towards refugees. The focus is on two strategies. The first is hyper-legalism—an overly formalistic bad-faith approach to interpreting international law. The second is obfuscation, which involves secrecy about what actions the government is taking and deliberate silence as to the purported legal justifications. The discussion is illustrated with examples from the United States, Australia, and Europe. The Article concludes with a discussion of possible tactics for resisting these strategies and holding governments accountable for their actions.

LEGAL TRANSFERS OF RESTRICTIVE IMMIGRATION LAWS: A HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE

Daniel Ghezelbash

Sociology and Political Science · International and Comparative Law Quarterly · · cited 26× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article examines the legal transfer of restrictive race-based immigration laws across self-governing settler societies in the United States, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and South Africa in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. These societies shared the common policy objective of limiting Chinese and other ‘non-white’ immigration. They each also faced informal and formal restrictions on implementing overtly racist immigration policies. This created fertile ground for legal transfers. When an innovation was found that could achieve the policy goal of race-based immigration restriction, without direct reference to race, it quickly spread across all jurisdictions operating in that paradigm. The legal transfer of three mechanisms is examined: (1) landing taxes; (2) passenger-per-ship restrictions; and (3) literacy tests. The article concludes by drawing parallels…

Forces of diffusion: what drives the transfer of immigration policy and law across jurisdictions?

Daniel Ghezelbash

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Migration and Border Studies · · cited 26× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this paper, I examine the forces which drive the transfer of immigration policies across jurisdictions. In Part I, I survey the legal scholarship on legal transplants, public policy scholarship on policy transfer and international relations scholarship on diffusion to identify three common motivations for transfers that can operate in any area of law or policy: efficiency, prestige and coercion. In Part II, I explore two additional forces that operate in policy fields such as immigration, where there is interdependence between the policy decisions of governments: cooperation and competition. Drawing parallels with regulatory theory, I argue that transfers of immigration policy can be driven by cooperative and competitive interdependence. I conclude by arguing that identifying the forces driving a particular instance of transfer can provide a framework for critically evaluating both…

Asylum at Sea: The Legality of Shipboard Refugee Status Determination Procedures

Azadeh Dastyari, Daniel Ghezelbash

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Refugee Law · · cited 17× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Austria and Italy have recently proposed that processing the protection claims of asylum seekers attempting to cross the Mediterranean should take place aboard government vessels at sea. Shipboard processing of asylum claims is not a novel idea. The policy has been used for many years by the governments of the United States and Australia. This article examines the relevant international law, as well as State practice and domestic jurisprudence in the United States and Australia, to explore whether shipboard processing complies with international refugee and human rights law. It concludes that, while it may be theoretically possible for shipboard processing to comply with international law, there are significant practical impediments to carrying out shipboard processing in a manner that is compliant with the international obligations of States. Current practices in the United…

Do Loose Lips Bring Ships? The Role of Policy, Politics and Human Rights in Managing Unauthorised Boat Arrivals

Mary Crock, Daniel Ghezelbash

Sociology and Political Science · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 13× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This article explores the phenomenon of asylum seekers and irregular migrants presenting as ʻboat peopleʼ. We evaluate key aspects of policies introduced to deter and contain these people – namely mandatory detention, temporary protection visas and offshore processing. Given the high rate of deaths and injuries associated with unauthorised boat arrivals, we argue that governments should do their best to discourage or prevent people from attempting to enter Australia in this way. However, the available evidence suggests that the rationale underlying deterrent policies is inherently flawed. Most have been totally ineffective in stopping unauthorised boat arrivals. History suggests that the best strategies prevent rather than deter, stopping the flow of asylum seekers at source and/or diverting desperate people away from dangerous and irregular modes of transport. We argue that no…

Australian Refugee Policy and its Impacts on Pacific Island Countries

Brian Opeskin, Daniel Ghezelbash

Sociology and Political Science · The Journal of Pacific Studies · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Refugees present an immense challenge globally but until recently Pacific Island Countries (PICs) have been relatively sheltered from this phenomenon. However, changes to Australia’s border security and refugee policies in recent years have significant implications for the Pacific because of Australia’s determination to prevent asylum seekers from arriving by boat in Australian territory. This article examines Australia’s so-called ‘Pacific Solution’, which entails the transfer of asylum seekers to camps in Nauru and Papua New Guinea, where they are detained pending determination of their refugee status and ultimate resettlement. The social impacts of Australia’s policies include the heightened tensions that arise from establishing large detention facilities in small island communities, and the social costs of resettling persons who are found to be refugees among poor local populations.…

Due Process and Rule of Law as Human Rights: The High Court and the 'Offshore' Processing of Asylum Seekers

Mary Crock, Daniel Ghezelbash

Political Science and International Relations · The Sydney eScholarship Repository (The University of Sydney) · · cited 7× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

A central message delivered by the High Court in Plaintiff M61/2010E v Commonwealth; Plaintiff M69 of 2010 v Commonwealth is that Australia’s Constitution and common law tradition do provide some guarantees against administrative unfairness and the arbitrary use of power, even in the absence of a bill of rights. The case is another example of the Australian courts facing down attempts to restrict judicial oversight of immigration decision-making. This time, the focus was on the system for processing asylum claims outside of Australia’s "migration zone". In a unanimous judgment, the High Court ruled that two Tamil asylum seekers denied refugee protection on Christmas Island did have a right to have their determinations made in accordance with the rules of procedural fairness and general principles of law. The authors examine the implications of the ruling for both the current regime and…

Fast-track, accelerated, and expedited asylum procedures as a tool of exclusion

Daniel Ghezelbash

Sociology and Political Science · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter examines the proliferation and expansion of fast track policies that accelerate and simplify asylum procedures for certain categories of arrivals. Drawing on examples from Europe, Australia and North America, I chart the evolution and spread of fast track policies. Building on my earlier work on hyper-legalism and obfuscation, I show how these tactics have been used to expand fast track policies and erode procedural safeguards, while allowing governments to claim the rhetorical and political benefits of ostensible compliance with international law. The chapter concludes with some proposed strategies for counter-acting the use of fast track policies and advocating for more robust procedural safeguards.

Technology and countersurveillance: holding governments accountable for refugee externalization policies

Daniel Ghezelbash

Sociology and Political Science · Globalizations · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper explores how technology and counter-surveillance can be used to hold governments accountable for the treatment of refugees, asylum seekers and other migrants beyond their borders. Externalization policies rely on secrecy and obfuscation. Carried out far from the public gaze, governments implement a range of measures aimed at ensuring that the precise details of their operations are not made public. Without knowing exactly what governments are doing, it is difficult to demonstrate that states are breaching their international obligations. Drawing on examples from Australia, Europe and the United States, this article examines how refugees, migrants, activists and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) have used technology to pierce this veil of secrecy, and how the images and data collected have been used in legal challenges and to influence public opinion. The aim is to learn…

Shifting sands and refugee boats: The transfer of immigration control measures between the United States and Australia

Daniel Ghezelbash

Political Science and International Relations · The Sydney eScholarship Repository (The University of Sydney) · · cited 5× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Policy makers are increasingly drawing on practices in other jurisdictions when developing immigration law and policy. This is due in part to the fact that the objectives of governments are converging as they seek to attract what they perceive as ‘good’ migrants, such as skilled workers and investors, and to deter ‘bad’ migrants, such as asylum seekers and irregular arrivals. In this thesis, I examine transfers of law and policy that have the objective of deterrence. I focus on the transfer of three measures between the United States and Australia. These are long-term mandatory detention, maritime interdiction, and extraterritorial processing of asylum claims. I compare and analyse the history and implementation of these measures. Referring to interviews carried out with key policy makers, I argue that the similarities in the way these policies have been implemented in the United States…

Understanding the politics of refugee law and policy making: Interdisciplinary and empirical approaches

Daniel Ghezelbash, Keyvan Dorostkar

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Refugee Studies · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract In this article, we argue that building a stronger empirical understanding of the politics of domestic refugee law and policy making is essential for refugee law scholars to better advocate for protection-orientated reforms. While much of the legal scholarship is aimed at promoting policy change, the best way to achieve this goal has rarely been examined. We identify three key areas of interdisciplinary empirical research that can create a stronger evidence-base for improving domestic policy reform efforts. This includes understanding the institutions and actors involved in policy formulation, measuring the impact of refugee laws and policies in practice, and identifying how to influence public opinion and build support for progressive law and policy change. We showcase existing interdisciplinary research in each of these areas, and highlight topics ripe for further empirical…

Australia's boat push-back policy

Daniel Ghezelbash

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter critically examines Australia’s policy of pushing-back asylum seekers who attempt to reach Australia by boat. It begins by briefly describing Australia’s approach and the concerns it raises under international law. Attention then turns to the tactics Australia has used to evade accountability for breaches of international law which occur as part of its push-back operations. Two tactics are examined. The first is hyper-legalism, a formalistic bad faith interpretation and application of international obligations. The second is obfuscation, which involves secrecy around operations and their purported legal justification. The chapter concludes with some targeted strategies for counter-acting each of these strategies and fostering greater accountability.

The rise and rise of mandatory immigration detention

Daniel Ghezelbash

Political Science and International Relations · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter explores the phenomenon of legal transfers in the area of immigration detention and their impact on child migrants. It uses as a case study the apparent borrowing of these regressive immigration control measures between the United States and Australia. It also examines the subsequent spread of progressive case management alternatives to detention (ATD) models.

Fairness and Efficiency in the Review of Asylum Decisions: Data-Driven Insights and Lessons From Australia’s Failed Fast Track Process

Mia Bridle, Daniel Ghezelbash

Sociology and Political Science · Refugee Survey Quarterly · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Attempts to enhance efficiency in asylum processing by limiting procedural rights have often backfired, leading to poor decision-making, increased appeals, and longer delays. Australia’s recently abolished Fast Track review process at the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) provides an illustrative example of how this plays out in practice. This article draws on a novel data set collated by the Kaldor Centre Data Lab of decision-making outcomes at the IAA. The statistical analysis demonstrates that the IAA was neither fair nor efficient, and resulted in a system that was both slow and unjust. This analysis provides valuable lessons for the design and operation of Australia’s new Administrative Review Tribunal and other international reforms aimed at improving the efficiency of asylum review mechanisms. The article calls for a re-evaluation of the relationship between…

Sensible Tactics or Missed Opportunity? Evaluating the Exceptional Treatment of Migration and Refugee Decisions in the Administrative Review Tribunal Act

Daniel Ghezelbash, Mary Crock, Mia Bridle +1 more

Political Science and International Relations · Federal Law Review · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The creation of the Administrative Review Tribunal represents a critical redesign of Australia’s federal administrative review system. In this article, we draw on a novel dataset from the Kaldor Centre Data Lab to question the government’s justifications for retaining separate codified procedures and other restrictive rules for the new tribunal’s migration and protection jurisdictions. Our data analysis reveals that historically, there is no evidence that the codification of procedures increases the efficiency or certainty of decision-making. This approach may in fact have the opposite effect, contributing to both inefficiencies and unfairness for applicants. The government’s decision to retain separate procedures for migration and protection applicants represents a missed opportunity and may undermine the new tribunal’s objectives.

Do Loose Lips Bring Ships?

Mary Crock, Daniel Ghezelbash

Sociology and Political Science · Griffith Law Review · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article explores the phenomenon of asylum seekers and irregular migrants presenting as ‘boat people’. We evaluate key aspects of policies introduced to deter and contain these people – namely mandatory detention, temporary protection visas and offshore processing. Given the high rate of deaths and injuries associated with unauthorised boat arrivals, we argue that governments should do their best to discourage or prevent people from attempting to enter Australia in this way. However, the available evidence suggests that the rationale underlying deterrent policies is inherently flawed. Most have been totally ineffective in stopping unauthorised boat arrivals. History suggests that the best strategies prevent rather than deter, stopping the flow of asylum seekers at source and/or diverting desperate people away from dangerous and irregular modes of transport. We argue that no…