arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Carl Knight

41 papers · 1969–2025

1969: 11970: 01971: 11972: 01973: 01974: 01975: 01976: 01977: 01978: 01979: 01980: 01981: 01982: 01983: 01984: 01985: 01986: 01987: 01988: 01989: 01990: 01991: 01992: 01993: 01994: 01995: 01996: 01997: 01998: 01999: 02000: 02001: 02002: 02003: 02004: 12005: 12006: 12007: 02008: 12009: 82010: 02011: 32012: 42013: 42014: 32015: 12016: 02017: 12018: 02019: 02020: 02021: 12022: 02023: 02024: 02025: 10
1969peak 10 in 20252025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 41 RSS

A framework for luck egalitarianism in health and healthcare

Andreas Albertsen, Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Medical Ethics · · cited 76× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Several attempts have been made to apply the choice-sensitive theory of distributive justice, luck egalitarianism, in the context of health and healthcare. This article presents a framework for this discussion by highlighting different normative decisions to be made in such an application, some of the objections to which luck egalitarians must provide answers and some of the practical implications associated with applying such an approach in the real world. It is argued that luck egalitarians should address distributions of health rather than healthcare, endorse an integrationist theory that combines health concerns with general distributive concerns and be pluralist in their approach. It further suggests that choice-sensitive policies need not be the result of applying luck egalitarianism in this context.

Luck Egalitarianism

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Philosophy Compass · · cited 58× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Luck egalitarianism is a family of egalitarian theories of distributive justice that aim to counteract the distributive effects of luck. This article explains luck egalitarianism's main ideas, and the debates that have accompanied its rise to prominence. There are two main parts to the discussion. The first part sets out three key moves in the influential early statements of Dworkin, Arneson, and Cohen: the brute luck/option luck distinction, the specification of brute luck in everyday or theoretical terms and the specification of advantage as resources, welfare, or some combination of these. The second part covers three later developments: the democratic egalitarian critique of luck egalitarianism, the luck egalitarian acceptance of pluralism, and luck egalitarian doubts about the significance of the brute luck/option luck distinction.

Benefiting from Injustice and Brute Luck

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Social Theory and Practice · · cited 52× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Many political philosophers maintain that beneficiaries of injustice are under special obligations to assist victims of injustice. However, the examples favored by those who endorse this view equally support an alternative luck egalitarian view, which holds that special obligations should be assigned to those with good brute luck. From this perspective the distinguishing features of the benefiting view are (1) its silence on the question of whether to allocate special obligations to assist the brute luck worse off to those who are well off as a matter of brute luck but not as a result of injustice, and (2) its silence on the question of whether to allocate assistance to those who are badly off as a matter of brute luck but not as a result of injustice. In this new light, the benefiting view is harder to justify.

Unit-Ideas Unleashed: A Reinterpretation and Reassessment of Lovejovian Methodology in the History of Ideas

Carl Knight

Anthropology · Journal of the Philosophy of History · · cited 48× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article argues for an unconventional interpretation of Arthur O. Lovejoy’s distinctive approach to method in the history of ideas. It is maintained that the value of the central concept of the ‘unit-idea’ has been misunderstood by friends and foes alike. The commonality of unit-ideas at different times and places is often defined in terms of familial resemblance. But such an approach must necessarily define unit-ideas as being something other than the smallest conceptual unit. It is therefore in tension with Lovejoy’s methodological prescription and, more importantly, disregards a potentially important aspect of intellectual history – the smaller conceptual units themselves. In response to this, an alternative interpretation of unit-ideas as ‘elemental’ – as the smallest identifiable conceptual components – is put forward. Unlike the familial resemblance approach, the…

Enough is too much: the excessiveness objection to sufficientarianism

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Economics and Philosophy · · cited 38× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The standard version of sufficientarianism maintains that providing people with enough, or as close to enough as is possible, is lexically prior to other distributive goals. This article argues that this is excessive – more than distributive justice allows – in four distinct ways. These concern the magnitude of advantage, the number of beneficiaries, responsibility and desert, and above-threshold distribution. Sufficientarians can respond by accepting that providing enough unconditionally is more than distributive justice allows, instead balancing sufficiency against other considerations.

The Metaphysical Case for Luck Egalitarianism

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Social Theory and Practice · · cited 33× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The article defends the concept of luck egalitarianism. Luck egalitarianism states that social and economic inequality is justifiable only if the person concerned is responsible for their position. If birth, circumstance or disability results in inequality, then the person is entitled to compensation. Metaphysical arguments are often used to dispute luck egalitarianism. Arguments have been made that given metaphysical libertarianism, i.e. people have free will, those who are inherently lazy or reckless are just as deserving of compensation as the disabled. The article argues that luck egalitarianism can respond to metaphysical concerns by its superior accounting of the role of responsibility, which can be judged by an educated guess.

In Defence of Cosmopolitanism

Carl Knight

Sociology and Political Science · Theoria · · cited 32× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

David Miller has objected to the cosmopolitan argument that it is arbitrary and hence unfair to treat individuals differently on account of things for which they are not responsible. Such a view seems to require, implausibly, that individuals be treated identically even where (unchosen) needs differ. The objection is, however, inapplicable where the focus of cosmopolitan concern is arbitrary disadvantage rather than arbitrary treatment. This 'unfair disadvantage argument' supports a form of global luck egalitarianism. Miller also objects that cosmopolitanism is unable to accommodate special obligations generated by national membership. Cosmopolitanism can, however, accommodate many special obligations to compatriots. Those which it cannot accommodate are only morally compelling if we assume what the objection claims to prove - that cosmopolitanism is mistaken. Cosmopolitanism construed…

Egalitarian Justice and Valuational Judgment

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Moral Philosophy · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Contemporary discussions of egalitarian justice have often focused on the issue of expensive taste. G.A. Cohen has recently abandoned the view that all chosen disadvantages are non-compensable, now maintaining that chosen expensive judgmental tastes—those endorsed by valuational judgment—are compensable as it is unreasonable to expect persons not to develop them. But chosen expensive brute taste—the main type of non-compensable expensive taste on the new scheme—cannot be described in such a way that there is a normative difference between it and chosen expensive judgmental taste. As there are related problems with denying compensation for the other kind of expensive taste that might remain non-compensable, Cohen's position on taste appears to be either implausible or virtually indistinguishable from that of equality of welfare. However, compensation for valuational…

In defence of global egalitarianism

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Global Ethics · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This essay argues that David Miller's criticisms of global egalitarianism do not undermine the view where it is stated in one of its stronger, luck egalitarian forms. The claim that global egalitarianism cannot specify a metric of justice which is broad enough to exclude spurious claims for redistribution, but precise enough to appropriately value different kinds of advantage, implicitly assumes that cultural understandings are the only legitimate way of identifying what counts as advantage. But that is an assumption always or almost always rejected by global egalitarianism. The claim that global egalitarianism demands either too little redistribution, leaving the unborn and dissenters burdened with their societies' imprudent choices, or too much redistribution, creating perverse incentives by punishing prudent decisions, only presents a problem for global luck egalitarianism on the…

Ethnogeography and Change

Carl Knight

Anthropology · Journal of Geography · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Technicians like systems and systematic thinking. It is very tempting to try to rebuild the world into a rational, schematic framework and ask men to fit themselves into it… the wisdom of the researcher … aims at concrete solutions, immediately applicable, designed for men as they are.

The Injustice of Discrimination

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · South African Journal of Philosophy · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Discrimination might be considered unjust on account of the comparative disadvantage it imposes, the absolute advantage it imposes, the disrespect it shows, or the prejudice it shows. This article argues that each of these accounts overlooks some cases of unjust discrimination. In response to this state of affairs we might combine two or more of these accounts. A promising approach combines the comparative disadvantage and absolute disadvantage accounts.

Responsibility and Distributive Justice: An Introduction1

Carl Knight, Zofia Stemplowska

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

<p>Under what conditions are people responsible for their choices and the outcomes of those choices? How could such conditions be fostered by liberal societies? Should what people are due as a matter of justice depend on what they are responsible for? For example, how far should healthcare provision depend on patients' past choices? What values would be realized and which hampered by making justice sensitive to responsibility? Would it give people what they deserve? Would it advance or hinder equality?</p> <p>The explosion of philosophical interest in such questions has been fuelled by increased focus on individual responsibility in political debates. Political philosophers, especially egalitarians, have responded to such developments by attempting to map out the proper place for responsibility in theories of justice. Responsibility and Distributive Justice both…

A pluralistic approach to global poverty

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Review of International Studies · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract A large proportion of humankind today lives in avoidable poverty. This article examines whether affluent individuals and governments have moral duties to change this situation. It is maintained that an alternative to the familiar accounts of transdomestic distributive justice and personal ethics put forward by writers such as Peter Singer, John Rawls, and Thomas Pogge is required, since each of these accounts fails to reflect the full range of relevant considerations. A better account would give some weight to overall utility, the condition of the worst off, and individual responsibility. This approach provides robust support to global poverty alleviation.

Discrimination and Equality of Opportunity

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · PhilPapers (PhilPapers Foundation) · · cited 6× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Discrimination, understood as differential treatment of individuals on the basis of their respective group memberships, is widely considered to be morally wrong. This moral judgment is backed in many jurisdictions with the passage of equality of opportunity legislation, which aims to ensure that racial, ethnic, religious, sexual, sexual-orientation, disability and other groups are not subjected to discrimination. This chapter explores the conceptual underpinnings of discrimination and equality of opportunity using the tools of analytical moral and political philosophy.

Theories of Distributive Justice and Post-Apartheid South Africa

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Politikon · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

South Africa is a highly distributively unequal country, and its inequality continues to be largely along racial lines. Such circumstances call for assessment from the perspective of contemporary theories of distributive justice. Three such theories—Rawlsian justice, utilitarianism, and luck egalitarianism—are described and applied. Rawls' difference principle recommends that the worst off be made as well as they can be, a standard which South Africa clearly falls short of. Utilitarianism recommends the maximization of overall societal well-being, a goal which South Africa again fails to achieve given its severe inequality and the fact of the diminishing marginal value of money—that a given amount of money tends to produce more utility for a poor person than it does for a rich person. The final theory, luck egalitarianism, aims to make distributions sensitive to individual exercises of…

Equal Opportunity for Welfare

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Edinburgh University Press eBooks · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter considers ‘equal opportunity for welfare’, as advocated by Richard Arneson and John Roemer, beginning by identifying the variety or varieties of bad luck that appear to be compensable. It maintains that compensation for ‘bad-price luck’ is appropriate, and that G. A. Cohen 's broader view of which kinds of luck are compensable is unacceptable, for the luck egalitarian at least. The chapter defends the bad-price luck argument against a few objections raised by Ronald Dworkin. This ‘present-mood’ account of welfare focuses on affective states and appears to overcome many of the problems faced by better-known accounts. The discussion also resists Cohen's attempt to reintroduce a resourcist element to egalitarian justice at the close of the chapter.

Mapping Spatial Thematic Accuracy with Fuzzy Sets

Liem Tran, James Wickham, S. Taylor Jarnagin +1 more

Geography, Planning and Development · Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Common thematic map accuracy measures (e.g., error matrix and kappa coefficient) are inadequate for analyzing the spatial variation of thematic map accuracy. This paper presents a method of mapping spatial accuracy of thematic land cover maps using fuzzy sets. First, we define a multi-level agreement between reference data and corresponding pixels on the map. Next, we formulate a discrete, multi-level agreement fuzzy set regarding a particular land-cover type for each pixel on the map. Then, we construct spatial accuracy maps based on information from the multi-level agreement fuzzy sets. We illustrate the method by constructing accuracy maps of several land cover types for the Mid-Atlantic Regionregion. Results show that thematic map accuracy is not spatially homogenous, but varies across a landscape and different land cover types having different spatial patterns of accuracy. The…

Liberal Multiculturalism Reconsidered

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Politics · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article starts by setting out the evaluative criteria provided by Will Kymlicka's liberal account of individual freedom and equality. Kymlicka's theory of cultural minority rights is then analysed using these criteria and found to be defective in two respects. First, his assignment of different rights to national and ethnic groups is shown to be inegalitarian with regard to generations after the first. Second, his recommendation of strong cultural protections is shown in some circumstances to undermine freedom and equality. Towards the end of the article a policy of gradual and inclusive assimilation is described that may effectively promote the freedom and opportunities of members of cultural minorities. In conclusion, group-specific rights may, as Kymlicka says, be justified in liberal terms, but only where they differ in content from those he proposes.

Responsibility, Desert, and Justice1

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter identifies three contrasts between responsibility-sensitive justice and desert-sensitive justice. First, while responsibility may be appraised on prudential or moral grounds, it is argued that desert is necessarily moral. As moral appraisal is much more plausible, responsibility-sensitive justice is only attractive in one of its two formulations. Second, strict responsibility sensitivity does not compensate for all forms of bad brute luck, and forms of responsibility-sensitive justice like luck egalitarianism that provide such compensation do so by appealing to independent moral concerns such as equality. Desert-sensitive justice can deliver the appropriate compensation without relying on external moral resources. Finally, while responsibility-sensitive justice harshly refuses to provide for those whose basic needs are unsatisfied due to their own negligent actions, this…

Distributive Luck

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · South African Journal of Philosophy · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

AbstactThis article explores the Rawlsian goal of ensuring that distributions are not influenced by the morally arbitrary. It does so by bringing discussions of distributive justice into contact with the debate over moral luck initiated by Williams and Nagel. Rawls’ own justice as fairness appears to be incompatible with the arbitrariness commitment, as it creates some equalities arbitrarily. A major rival, Dworkin’s version of brute luck egalitarianism, aims to be continuous with ordinary ethics, and so is (a) sensitive to non-philosophical beliefs about free will and responsibility, and (b) allows inequalities to arise on the basis of option luck. But Dworkin does not present convincing reasons in support of continuity, and there are compelling moral reasons for justice to be sensitive to the best philosophical account of free will and responsibility, as is proposed by the revised…

Equality, Responsibility, and Justice

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Edinburgh University Press eBooks · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The general view inspired by Ronald Dworkin's accomplishment has become known as ‘responsibility-sensitive egalitarianism’, ‘equality of fortune’ or, more commonly, ‘luck egalitarianism’. While it is widely accepted that luck egalitarianism seeks to combine the traditionally radical idea of distributive equality with the traditionally conservative concern for holding people responsible for their actions, there is much disagreement about the specific nature of its objective, the most appropriate way of realizing the objective, and the desirability, from various perspectives, of the objective and its particular realizations. This chapter introduces all three of these issues.

Basic-needs sufficientarianism

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Basic-needs sufficientarianism holds that everyone should have enough in the sense of having their basic needs satisfied. Though a common form of sufficientarianism, basic-needs sufficientarianism is underexplored even by its proponents. This article significantly advances understanding of basic-needs sufficientarianism in three respects. First, it identifies basic-needs sufficientarians’ stances on key issues such as whether basic needs are of fundamental or instrumental value, the grounding of that value, the weighting assigned to basic needs, and the treatment of subthreshold distribution. Second, it argues that the common commitment of these theories to the fundamental value of basic needs is unsustainable whether it is grounded in the universality of basic needs or their connection with autonomy. Third, it proposes an instrumental form of basic-needs sufficientarianism that is…

Anti-homeless Hostile Design as Wrongful Discrimination

Andreas Albertsen, Carl Knight

Sociology and Political Science · British Journal of Political Science · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Philosophical accounts of discrimination distinguish the question of what discrimination is from the question of its wrongfulness. This article addresses these two questions in the context of anti-homeless hostile design of public spaces. Regarding the first question, all forms of anti-homeless hostile design amount to discrimination, with typical cases (for example, anti-homeless spikes or benches) being direct discrimination, but with some cases (for example, CCTV not intended to target the homeless) being indirect discrimination. Regarding the second question, it is argued that all major accounts of the wrongness of discrimination identify the usual, directly discriminatory hostile design as wrongful on account of its harmful or disrespectful character. Most accounts also consider the less common indirectly discriminatory hostile design to be possibly wrongful, especially…

Equality and Information

Carl Knight, Roger Knight

Political Science and International Relations · ENLIGHTEN (Jurnal Bimbingan dan Konseling Islam) · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Traditional outcome-orientated egalitarian principles require access to information about the size of individual holdings. Recent egalitarian political theory has sought to accommodate considerations of responsibility. Such a move may seem problematic, in that a new informational burden is thereby introduced, with no apparent decrease in the existing burden. This article uses a simple model with simulated data to examine the extent to which outcome egalitarianism and responsibility-sensitive egalitarianism (‘luck egalitarianism’) can be accurately applied where information is incomplete or erroneous. It is found that, while outcome egalitarianism tends to be more accurately applied, its advantage is not overwhelming, and in many prima facie plausible circumstances luck egalitarianism would be more accurately applied. This suggests that luck egalitarianism cannot be rejected as utopian.…

Relational Egalitarianism: A Critique

Carl Knight

Political Science and International Relations · Pacific philosophical quarterly · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT Relational egalitarians endorse the positive thesis that achieving equality of social relations is fundamentally important, and sometimes also the negative thesis that distribution has no non‐relational importance. This article rejects both theses of relational egalitarianism. Contrary to the negative thesis, there are strong reasons supporting the non‐relational importance of distribution, as is brought out by considering a country with huge distributive disparities and pervasive poverty but no relational inequality. Two objections to the positive thesis are presented. First, relational equality is consistent with a levelling down of social relations. Second, equal social relations are of no fundamental importance.