arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Anthony Perl

27 papers · 1994–2025

1994: 21995: 01996: 01997: 01998: 01999: 02000: 12001: 02002: 12003: 02004: 02005: 12006: 02007: 12008: 02009: 12010: 02011: 02012: 12013: 22014: 22015: 32016: 22017: 22018: 12019: 02020: 12021: 32022: 02023: 02024: 02025: 3
1994peak 3 in 20152025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 27 RSS

Streams and stages: Reconciling Kingdon and policy process theory

Michael Howlett, Allan McConnell, Anthony Perl

Political Science and International Relations · European Journal of Political Research · · cited 194× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Use of metaphors is a staple feature of how we understand policy processes – none more so than the use of ‘policy stages’/'cycles’ and ‘multiple streams’. Yet even allowing for the necessary parsimony of metaphors, the former is often criticised for its lack of ‘real world’ engagement with agency, power, ideology, turbulence and complexity, while the latter focuses only on agenda‐setting but at times has been utilised, with limited results, to understand later stages of the policy process. This article seeks to explore and advance the opportunities for combining both and applying them to the policy‐formation and decision‐making stages of policy making. In doing so it examines possible three, four and five stream models. It argues that a five stream confluence model provides the highest analytical value because it retains the simplicity of metaphors (combining elements of two of…

Moving Policy Theory Forward: Connecting Multiple Stream and Advocacy Coalition Frameworks to Policy Cycle Models of Analysis

Michael Howlett, Allan McConnell, Anthony Perl

Political Science and International Relations · Australian Journal of Public Administration · · cited 149× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The stages/policy cycle, multiple streams, and Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF) approaches to understanding policy processes, all have analytical value although also attracting substantive criticism. An obvious direction for research is to determine whether the multiple streams framework and the ACF can be refined and applied to other dimensions of policy‐making set out in the policy cycle model. This article argues that extending and modifying Kingdon's framework beyond the agenda‐setting stage is best suited to this endeavour. Doing so makes it possible to bring these three approaches into alignment and enhances our understanding, although retaining the core insights of each.

The Changing Role of Consultants in Canadian Policy Analysis

Anthony Perl, Donald J. White

Public Administration · Policy and Society · · cited 84× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article explores the Canadian government's trend toward outsourcing policy analytical and advisory services over the 1980s and 1990s. We test three (not mutually exclusive) hypotheses about why such policy consulting has increased. A combination of New Public Management values and knowledge expansion are shown to drive this trend. In the late 1990s, the federal government significantly decreased the number of in-house operational and administrative support workers. These reductions enabled the government to contract out more while a managerial and administrative cadre remained in place to manage the contracts. The main implication is that contracting out analytical and advisory services does not necessarily lower costs, but does aid government in pursuing other objectives. The growth in Canadian policy consulting corresponded with a stabilization of public service…

Weaving the Fabric of Public Policies: Comparing and Integrating Contemporary Frameworks for the Study of Policy Processes

Michael Howlett, Allan McConnell, Anthony Perl

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis Research and Practice · · cited 77× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

For close to three decades multiple frameworks of policy-making have served as competitive characterizations of policy processes. All claim to provide accounts that capture diverse factors such as changing governance norms, actors and ideas which drive programme interventions and policy outputs. Paradoxically, the resilience of different models such as the policy cycle framework and the multiple streams framework has been accompanied by numerous critiques that they are “incomplete” and even divorced from the real world. This article presents an effort to synthesize and reconcile these frameworks in which the appeal and strengths of each can be retained while going some way to overcoming their weaknesses and limitations. It does so through the introduction of an integrative metaphor for policy-making – what Wayne Parsons termed “weaving” – which can be applied to all stages of public…

Policy Networks and Industrial Revitalization: High Speed Rail Initiatives in France and Germany

James A. Dunn, Anthony Perl

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Public Policy · · cited 31× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT Using Atkinson and Coleman's typology of policy networks, this article shows how many of the differences in policy outcomes can be traced to the structure of the policy environment in each nation. French and Germany policy makers adopted a strategy of investing in high speed passenger transport to revitalize their declining railway sectors. The French TGV was developed in a state-directed policy network which insisted on cost containment and commercial viability. In Germany a corporatist style of policymaking in the rail sector led to delays and higher costs for the ICE train. A separate clientele pluralist network led by the Research Ministry developed the Transrapid maglev option, but in order to finance and deploy an operational system, the Chancellor and cabinet had to create a concertation network. The policy network approach provides a useful framework for conducting…

Rethinking Transport Infrastructure Planning to Extend Its Value over Time

Moshe Givoni, Anthony Perl

Transportation · Journal of Planning Education and Research · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Contemporary transport infrastructure planning typically rests upon the core belief that physical mobility has inherent advantages and that more of it will always yield better socioeconomic outcomes. Such an embrace of maximum growth yields a misguided calculus for planning transport infrastructure. Rather than seeking to meet the demand for future mobility by reflexively expanding the quantity of infrastructure, there is a need to consider alternatives that can support a sustainable future. By applying the “half-life” concept to transport infrastructure, this article explores alternatives to extending its use over time that can open up new possibilities for generating and extending its value to society.

Policy Capacity for Climate Change in<scp>C</scp>anada's Transportation Sector

Joshua Newman, Anthony Perl, Adam Wellstead +1 more

Political Science and International Relations · Review of Policy Research · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract When pursuing change, legacies of policy goals and instruments from an established paradigm often present constraints on fully embracing a newer paradigm, resulting in the layering of new policy goals and instruments on top of the existing base. In this article, we investigate the effect of layered paradigms on policy capacity at three different levels of policy making in the C anadian transportation sector. Using analysis of government publications and budget data, virtual policy network analysis, quantitative analysis of data from a survey of C anadian policy analysts, and direct interviews with policy managers in two provinces, we demonstrate how this layering of legacy goals (and consequent policy in capacity) is occurring at the macro, meso, and micro levels of policy making. We conclude that the layering of a new policy paradigm for climate change on top of the…

Studying policy dynamics: policy cycles and regimes

Anthony Perl

Political Science and International Relations · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The varied perspectives adopted to interpret public policy all rely to some degree on the recognition that policy arises from a multitude of assessments and choices taken by individuals and organizations, who interact both inside and outside government. Structures within government and ideas circulating across civil society transmit norms and expectations regarding the legitimate use of authority in policy-making, both as an input to shape deliberations and as an output to enforce compliance. As a consequence, the structural and cognitive legacy of prior policy initiatives needs to be accounted for when seeking to understand current and future policy. Conceptual tools that facilitate the interpretation of policy development have thus become a mainstay in policy studies and among the most venerable of these heuristics is the policy cycle model.

Reconciling Streams and Stages:Avoiding Mixed Metaphors in the Characterization of Policy Processes

Michael Howlett, Allan McConnell, Anthony Perl

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 5× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Metaphors have much analytical purchase in the policy sciences - none more so than that of the notions of policy stages and multiple streams. Yet there are difficulties, even allowing for necessary parsimony, in applying these individual metaphors to policy processes. This paper attempts to combine metaphors about policy cycles and policy streams in order to provide a more realistic synthesis that can capture diverse factors such as changing governance norms, detailed program interventions and the sheer complexity of policy drivers – ranging from coalition building to ‘garbage can’ solutions. In doing so it examines the difficulties of mixing these two metaphors and the special difficulty of ascertaining how many streams should be conceptualised. We argue that three-stream models such as Kingdon’s may be well suited to understanding one specific stage of policy-making but require…

Institutionalized Inhibition: Examining Constraints on Climate Change Policy Capacity in the Transport Departments of Ontario and British Columbia, Canada

Anthony Perl, Joshua Newman

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian Political Science Review · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper examines the interaction between&#x0D; transportation policy and climate change policy in two Canadian&#x0D; provinces, British Columbia and Ontario. The concept&#x0D; of policy capacity is used to qualitatively measure the&#x0D; effectiveness of instruments in advancing goals in an area&#x0D; where established policy paradigms may not be congruent&#x0D; with new initiatives. A review of official policy documents&#x0D; and budgetary information on policy-related spending, as&#x0D; well as primary interviews with policy managers in relevant&#x0D; provincial ministries, reveals that overlapping policy goals&#x0D; and instruments may have created a situation of institutionalized&#x0D; policy inhibition, in which conflicting layers of policy&#x0D; goals and instruments constrain the available policy capacity.

Transportation politics and policy: a research agenda

Anthony Perl, Rosalie Singerman Ray, Louise Reardon

Transportation · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter provides an introduction to the Handbook of Transportation and Public Policy, which aims to bring politics, policy and transportation research into greater dialogue. In laying the foundation for the multiple, rich contributions to the Handbook, the chapter has three aims. First is to examine why, despite the ongoing interplay between politics and transportation across scales, transport studies to date minimise the role of politics. We identify two reasons for this: the effect of neoliberalism on the transport sector and the myth of objectivity in transport planning. The chapter’s second aim is to examine why the policy studies literature rarely focuses on transportation. We argue this is due to a number of factors, including the pervasiveness of New Public Management and research fashions. The third and final aim is to justify why focusing on politics and policy in the…

Employer-paid transit subsidies and travel behaviour: Experimental evidence from Vancouver hotels

Peter Hall, Anthony Perl, Karen Sawatzky +1 more

Transportation · Journal of Urban Mobility · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

We report findings from an experimental study of the impacts of employer-paid transit subsidies on workers at downtown hotels in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. Partnering with the union and management of seven hotels, the regional transit agency and city government, we collected representative surveys of commuting behavior in three waves, each six months apart, in 2018 and 2019. Four of the hotels had offered a 15% transit subsidy prior to the study. We grouped six of the hotels in three similarly located pairs with the same initial subsidy condition. After the first survey wave, we provided an experimental subsidy at four hotels: 25% at one hotel in each of three pairs, and 15% at the seventh hotel. After the second survey we further increased the subsidy to 50% at two hotels. The larger the transit subsidy offered, the more employees become transit riders and the more…

The role of policy learning in urban mobility adaptation: exploring Vancouver’s plan to remove the Georgia and Dunsmuir viaducts

Devon Farmer, Anthony Perl

Transportation · Urban Research & Practice · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In 2015, Vancouver’s City Council approved a plan for removing the Georgia and Dunsmuir viaducts and replacing 2.6 km of vestigial expressway infrastructure with a surface boulevard, parks, public space, and housing. This article explores whether policy learning from other cities influenced Vancouver’s decision. Using the Dolowitz-Marsh framework, we found evidence that planners,politicians, and the public introduced examples of expressway removal and infrastructure adaptation during Vancouver’s policymaking process and that lesson drawing influenced the outcome. The policy learning revealed here shows how North American cities can advance a more equal redistribution of urban space by removing expressway infrastructure.

Streets Paved with Gold: Urban Expressway Building and Global City Formation in Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver

Jeffrey Kenworthy, Anthony Perl, Matt Hern

Urban Studies · eSpace (Curtin University) · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver are Canada’s most signifi cant locations of global city formation today. Their distinctive spatial development and mobility mix were greatly infl uenced by decisions regarding inner-city expressway building. This article explores the hypothesis that choices made regarding how to move motor vehicles through Canada’s three major metropolitan areas between 1960 and 1980 can be better understood by examining the dynamics of global city formation in these jurisdictions.    Montreal implemented a comprehensive expressway network to align with its status as Canada’s leading global city during the 1960s. Toronto’s attempt to complete an expressway network was partial, reflecting fragmentary global city aspirations during the 1970s. Vancouver, where global city ambitions only began to form during the 1980s, cancelled urban expressway plans and became Canada’s…

Setting One’s Sights: Exploring the Dynamics of Goal Selection in Road Safety Policy

Anthony Perl, Christopher M. Berry

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Travel by automobile is manifestly the most dangerous activity that most citizens of developed economies routinely engage in, highlighting the value of trying to explain why some governments address this risk quite differently than do others. This article compares the ways in which Canada sets objectives for managing risk on its roads with alternative European and American targets. The manuscript tests the hypothesis that countries selecting concrete policy goals, which identify specific targets in terms of specific numbers of road deaths and injuries, will pursue more ambitious outcomes than countries that adopt goals stated in relation to another reference point, such as the number of vehicle-kilometres traveled, or the incidence of particular behaviour such as impaired driving or seat belt use. Relative policy goals are shown to translate into less ambitious anticipated results, thus…

Public Enterprise as an Expression of Sovereignty: Reconsidering the Origin of Canadian National Railways

Anthony Perl

Public Administration · Canadian Journal of Political Science · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Railway nationalization, the anvil on which national public enterprise was hammered together between 1917 and 1923, forms a misunderstood episode in the development of the Canadian state. This article examines the convergence of domestic politics and international economics that facilitated an unprecedented transformation of Canada's capacity to control its economy. State autonomy was used to create public enterprise as an instrument by which the gains of industrial restructuring could be distributed to favoured domestic financiers while its costs were imposed upon foreign investors. This power to manage the gains and losses arising from industrial change formed a new expression of economic sovereignty, one that ought to be viewed as an important step in the transition from imperial to national governance.

Transport, inequality and policy feedback

Xavier J. Harmony, Anthony Perl

Transportation · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Transport inequality is an important topic, but more needs to be done to better understand the temporal dimension of compounding inequalities in transport policymaking. Building on literature on transport disadvantage, political decision-making, and resource distribution, we describe a policy feedback process in transport policymaking that continues a pattern of events biased towards increased inequality over time. This process, a product of political dynamics and civic engagement gaps, produces an inequality loop where those who experience mobility deprivation and suffer from transport disadvantage receive continuously decreasing economic and mobility returns from transport decision-making. We demonstrate how this inequality loop works using examples from public transport before demonstrating how the inequality loop might be broken, at least temporarily, using vignettes from three…

The social meaning of “access”: Lessons in transport governance from cities in developed countries

Jago Dodson, M. Desmond Burke, Neil Sipe +1 more

Transportation · RMIT Research Repository (RMIT University Library) · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the aftermath of the global financial crisis, in the United States and Australia and to a lesser degree in parts of Europe, the transition to more ecologically sustainable, equitable, and integrated transport and urban policies appears to be retreating. Climate change and resource depletion have become less popularly and politically (though not scientifically) important. Urban transport policy in the industrialised North generally remains resistant to change despite widespread acceptance of the need for more sustainable models. The role of urban government in this transition is the focus of this chapter.

International dimensions and dynamics of policy-making

Anthony Perl

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The days when policy researchers could count upon domestic politics and society to contribute sufficient data for a satisfactory analysis are now a memory. Whether policy researchers are prepared to enter another analytical universe or not, the accelerating flow of ideas, information, goods and money across national borders has affected the nature of policy problems, reshaped the attempts to engage these problems and thus reoriented the way in which explanations of policy-making can be productively pursued. The big questions that animate policy studies may not have changed, but the available data and the concepts needed to analyze them have been shifting. This chapter will seek to connect these emerging global dynamics to long recognized drivers of policy-making and present a conceptual framework that can help in understanding the resulting interactions. Enhancing the linkage between…

What value does political science bring to understanding transport policy? Insights from the Handbook of Transportation and Public Policy

Anthony Perl, Rosalie Singerman Ray, Louise Reardon

Political Science and International Relations · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Our Handbook’s assembly of research findings on the ways that policymaking can affect transportation outcomes highlights the influence of government and politics as forces that shape mobility. Through mindful consideration and dialogue, those who study transportation can learn from those who study policymaking and vice versa. This chapter highlights the ways in which politics influence transportation decisions and outcomes through the allocation of authority and resources to advance certain transportation options over other alternatives. It also considers how governmental structures can enable or constrain collaboration and partnerships among public and private agents in delivering transportation options. Some contributions explore contestation at the project or agency level, where the capability to advance goals such as equity, efficiency, or sustainability can vary based on the…

The quality of life effects of enhancing public transport subsidies for hospitality workers in Vancouver, British Columbia

Peter Hall, Anthony Perl, Karen Sawatzky

Transportation · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

What difference do transit subsidies make to the quality of life of workers? We report on the results of a study of the effects of an experimental transit subsidy offered to downtown hotel workers on perceived quality of life. Analysing self-reported quality of life indicators compared before and after an experimental transit subsidy offer, we identify positive outcomes with respect to health, stress and commute predictability among those who accepted the subsidy. The study also paid close attention to occupation and other social differences among workers, showing the invaluable role that transit plays in supporting the quality of life of service workers in the post-industrial urban economy.

Urban Mobility and Transportation Policy — with Anthony Perl

Anthony F. Perl, Am Johal, Fiorella Pinillos +4 more

Transportation · Summit (Simon Fraser University) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

My research crosses disciplinary and national boundaries to explore policy decisions made about transportation, cities and the environment. I have published in dozens of scholarly journals, including Energy Policy, Transport Policy, Transportation Research, Journal of Transport Geography, World Transport Policy and Practice, Journal of Air Transport Management, Transportation Research Record, Journal of Public Policy, Canadian Public Policy, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, Journal of Planning Education and Research, Journal of Urban Technology, Canadian Journal of Political Science and Scientific American. My work has been awarded prizes for outstanding papers presented at the World Conference on Transport Research and the Canadian Transportation Research Forum.&amp;nbsp;\nI have advised governments in Australia, Belgium, Canada, France and the United States on transportation…

Urban Challenges Forum 3 (October 18, 2017)—The Cost of Moving People and Goods: Who Pays?

Daniel Firth, Anthony Perl

Political Science and International Relations · Summit (Simon Fraser University) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Transportation infrastructure is a hot button topic in Metro Vancouver. Paying for transit, bridges, tunnels, roads and moving goods and people costs money. So, who pays for it all? How will mobility pricing work in the City of New Westminster? How will the cost affect the average consumer? Watch the videos from the Urban Challenges Forum 3 to learn how this part of a bigger conversation unfolded at this Urban Challenges Forum.

and the Integrity Gap in Canadian Environmental Policy

Eugene Lee, Anthony Perl, Eugene Lee +1 more

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In trying to understand Canada’s environmental policy making, the relation-ship between what is said and what gets done merits more systematic atten-tion than it has received to date. From global climate change to local air quality, it is worth comparing the ways in which Canada identifies environmental challenges with the means that are adopted to deal with them. The result-ing contrast yields a range of dissonance between policy aims and outcomes that demands explanation. By and large, all levels of Canadian government exhibit a willingness to identify environmental challenges rather than deny their existence or mini-mize their importance. Once problems are recognized, however, Canadian policies often fail to deliver solutions or even launch efforts to attain those solutions. Trying to explain why Canadian environmental policy regularly falls short of acting on identified problems has…

Punctuated Equilibrium and Advocacy Coalitions: Toward a Post Carbon Policy Paradigm for the Automobile in North America

James A. Dunn, Anthony Perl

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Addressing climate change will require breaching the well-fortified redoubts of America’s energy and transportation policy monopolies. This paper explores how such policy transformation might actually unfold, drawing upon the case of recent policy innovations in automotive fuel economy regulation. Even before the economic crisis triggered a government led restructuring of Chrysler and General Motors, the advocacy groups in America’s auto policy subsystem recognized that “things are moving,” and that the status quo of 1980s era fuel economy standards could not be preserved indefinitely. Following the 2006 Congressional elections, the coalition behind Detroit’s policy monopoly became more open to policy changes that would avoid the most damaging outcome of sharp increases in fuel economy regulations. Once Detroit’s lock on policy change was opened, environmental and transportation reform…