arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Andrew Defty

54 papers · 1995–2025

1995: 11996: 11997: 01998: 01999: 02000: 02001: 02002: 02003: 02004: 02005: 02006: 12007: 72008: 12009: 12010: 32011: 12012: 52013: 42014: 112015: 22016: 12017: 32018: 42019: 32020: 22021: 12022: 02023: 12024: 02025: 1
1995peak 11 in 20142025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 54 RSS

'New Mechanisms of Independent Accountability': Select Committees and Parliamentary Scrutiny of the Intelligence Services

Hugh Bochel, Andrew Defty, Jennet Kirkpatrick

Political Science and International Relations · Parliamentary Affairs · · cited 22× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Oversight of intelligence and security agencies has become of significant interest in recent years. In the UK the principal mechanism for providing parliamentary oversight of the agencies is the Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC). However, until 2013 the ISC was a constitutional anomaly: as a statutory committee appointed by the Prime Minister it was a committee of parliamentarians, but not a committee of Parliament. In recent years a number of parliamentary select committees have undertaken inquiries involving scrutiny of the work of the intelligence agencies and the government's use of intelligence. Some select committees have also argued that Parliament should play a greater role in the scrutiny of intelligence. In 2011 the ISC proposed that it should become a committee of Parliament, an idea taken up in the Justice and Security green paper and which became reality in 2013.…

Coming in from the cold: bringing the Intelligence and Security Committee into Parliament

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Intelligence & National Security · · cited 21× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The establishment of the Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) in 1994 for the first time allowed British parliamentarians access to intelligence agency staff and records. However, as a committee of parliamentarians, but not a parliamentary committee, the ISC was a constitutional anomaly. In 2013, significant reforms reconstituted the ISC as a parliamentary committee, with enhanced powers and an expanded mandate. Drawing on interviews with ISC members and detailed examination of committee business, this article examines the impact of recent reforms. It argues that while reform has had a significant impact on the committee, in a number of respects it remains strongly constrained by government.

MPs' Attitudes to Welfare: A New Consensus?

Hugh Bochel, Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Social Policy · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The post-war ‘consensus’ on welfare was based largely in the perceived agreement of leading politicians of Conservative and Labour parties on the role of the mixed economy and the welfare state. However, from the late 1970s economic and demographic pressures and ideological challenges, particularly from the New Right, led to cuts in spending on welfare, increased private involvement and an emphasis on more individualistic and selectivist approaches to provision. Recently some scholars have begun to discuss the emergence of a ‘new liberal consensus’ around welfare provision. Drawing upon interviews with 10 per cent of the House of Commons, this article examines the extent to which a new political consensus upon welfare can be identified. In addition to analysing responses to questions on welfare issues, it considers the extent to which MPs themselves believe there to be some degree of…

Educating Parliamentarians about Intelligence: The Role of the British Intelligence and Security Committee

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Parliamentary Affairs · · cited 18× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Journal Article Educating Parliamentarians about Intelligence: The Role of the British Intelligence and Security Committee Get access Andrew Defty Andrew Defty Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Google Scholar Parliamentary Affairs, Volume 61, Issue 4, October 2008, Pages 621–641, https://doi.org/10.1093/pa/gsn024 Published: 11 July 2008

16. The Westminster Model of Accountability

Martyn Atkins, Andrew Defty, James Strong

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 17× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter focuses on the ‘Westminster Model’ through which government ministers, civil servants, parliamentarians, and voters play distinct but complementary roles in a single chain of accountability. It outlines the three different areas of parliament’s accountability role: financial accountability, explanatory accountability, and sacrificial accountability. The chapter goes on to consider changes which have weakened the Westminster Model: changes to the size and structure of the state, the growth of organized political parties and the fact that some government powers exist beyond the reach of parliamentary scrutiny. It concludes that although genuine accountability exists through the Westminster Model, this is not the same as control. The case study of the use of the ‘humble address’ mechanism in the House of Commons demonstrates how parliamentary accountability mechanisms do…

Assessing policy success and failure: targets, aims and processes

Philip Begley, Catherine Bochel, Hugh Bochel +6 more

Political Science and International Relations · Policy Studies · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Assessing policy success and failure is a significant challenge. This article seeks to address this by utilizing two case studies of legislation from the United Kingdom Parliament, the National Minimum Wage Act 1998 and the Academies Act 2010, so as to develop a nuanced understanding of how and in what ways policies have been successful, or otherwise. Drawing on these two case studies, and the work of a variety of authors, the article illustrates the complex nature of the challenge, but suggests that by identifying “targets”, “aims” and “processes” it is possible to make reasonable judgements about the relative success of a policy. It concludes that this framework therefore has considerable potential utility.

‘A More Representative Chamber’: Representation and the House of Lords

Hugh Bochel, Andrew Defty

Gender Studies · Journal of Legislative Studies · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Since 1997 there has been substantive reform of the House of Lords in an effort to make the chamber ‘more democratic and more representative’. Whilst the Labour government failed to press ahead with any of the proposed plans for further reform following the removal of the bulk of the hereditary peers in 1999, it remained committed to the notion that such reform must make the second chamber ‘more representative’. The coalition government's programme advocates a long-term aspiration for a House wholly or mainly elected on the basis of proportional representation, and a short-term approach based on additional appointments to ensure a balance of the parties. What is clear in all of these proposals for reform is a desire for the House of Lords to become more representative than it is at present. However, what is less clear is what is meant by ‘representative’ – who the House of Lords is…

Can You Tell What It Is Yet? Public Attitudes Towards ‘the Big Society’

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Social Policy and Society · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

‘The big society’ was a central theme in the Conservative's 2010 general election campaign. Opinion polls at the time of the election suggested that ‘the big society’ had little resonance with the public. Nevertheless, ‘the big society’ has been the subject of a number of prominent re-launches since the election. It appeared to underpin the Coalition government's policies in a range of areas and the Prime Minister invested considerable personal capital in it. This article examines public attitudes towards ‘the big society’. Drawing on public opinion data, it focuses on public recognition and understanding of ‘the big society’ and more broadly on whether the government's approach to rolling back state provision has prompted an increased public appetite for involvement in the delivery of services.

From committees of parliamentarians to parliamentary committees: comparing intelligence oversight reform in Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the UK

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Intelligence & National Security · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Some form of legislative oversight of intelligence has become the norm in most democratic states. The near universal acceptance of the need for democratic oversight does not, however, mark the end of a process of intelligence accountability. In many states following a period of establishment and then consolidation, intelligence oversight mechanisms have begun to evolve as oversight committees have sought extra powers and developed new roles. This article examines reforms in parliamentary intelligence oversight committees in Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the UK, focusing on the form, mandate, membership, powers and resources of the committees as well as their engagement with other parliamentary actors.

Tapping the Telephones of Members of Parliament: The ‘Wilson Doctrine’ and Parliamentary Privilege

Andrew Defty, Hugh Bochel, Jane Kirkpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · Intelligence & National Security · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In 1966, in what has become known as the Wilson Doctrine, the Prime Minister, Harold Wilson, informed Parliament that he had issued an instruction that the telephones of parliamentarians were not to be intercepted by the intelligence and security agencies. Subsequent Prime Ministers have all expressed their continued commitment to the Wilson Doctrine. This article examines the nature and limitations of the Wilson Doctrine, and its continued application in the context of recent legislative changes and a number of prominent recent cases. It focuses on apparent changes to the scope and attempts to set aside the Wilson Doctrine under the Blair government and the implications of the interception of the communications of Sinn Fein Members of Parliament, and the bugging of meetings involving the Labour MP Sadiq Khan.

Having security chiefs give evidence to Parliament isprogress, but future sessions must dig deeper

Andrew Defty

Sociology and Political Science · London School of Economics and Political Science Research Online (London School of Economics and Political Science) · · cited 7× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Last week was the first time that the heads of Britain’s security services have appeared in public in front of the newly reformed Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC). Andrew Defty argues that although the session was in and of itself significant, in future the ISC members must exert a greater degree of scrutiny if the committee is to be an effective check on the security services.

A Question of Expertise: the House of Lords and Welfare Policy

Hugh Bochel, Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Parliamentary Affairs · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The expertise of its members is often cited as one of the distinctive features of the House of Lords. It is frequently argued that, in particular, because of its composition, and in particular the existence of the Crossbench Peers, debates in the Lords are more informed than in the Commons. Peers, it has been claimed, bring professional experience and expertise to the scrutiny of legislation, and have the time to maintain their expertise, in contrast to the Commons, where MPs, because of the demands of re-election and constituency business, are sometimes seen as being required to know a little about a wide range of subjects. Moreover, the presumed expertise of the Upper House has also been central to debates about the reform of the House of Lords, with assertions that any further reform should retain the Lords' ability to provide distinctive and informed scrutiny. Drawing on a series of…

‘Familiar but not intimate’: executive oversight of the UK intelligence and security agencies

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Intelligence & National Security · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Studies of the relationship between ministers and UK intelligence agencies have tended to focus on the government’s use of intelligence, while studies of intelligence oversight have focused almost exclusively on the work of parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee. This article examines the role of the executive in the oversight of the UK intelligence and security agencies. It traces the evolution of ministerial accountability for the UK intelligence and security agencies and raises questions about the capacity of ministers to provide effective scrutiny in this area, focusing on ministers’ knowledge and understanding of intelligence, ministerial workload and potential conflicts of interest.

Safe as Houses? Conservative Social Policy, Public Opinion and Parliament

Hugh Bochel, Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · The Political Quarterly · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Social policy is of key importance to contemporary society, accounting for two thirds of public expenditure and, through provision such as the NHS, pensions, benefits, schools, universities and social care, touching on the lives of much of the population on a daily basis. It has also been one of the areas where the Conservative party have sought to change their image, and to some extent policies, under David Cameron. Drawing upon a range of evidence, including interviews with more than ten per cent of the House of Commons and the House of Lords, this article examines the potential challenges for a Conservative government of either stance, focusing on the extent of possible support for the Conservatives' approach to social policy amongst three key groups: the public, MPs, and members of the House of Lords.

Public and Parliamentary Attitudes to Welfare

Hugh Bochel, Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Legislative Studies · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

One of the core functions of parliament in the United Kingdom is arguably to represent the views of the people. While opinions differ as to the precise nature of this representation, one would expect to find a broad measure of comparability between public opinion and the opinions of those representing the public in parliament. This article examines the extent to which shifts in political attitudes towards the welfare state have been reflected in public opinion, particularly since the election of New Labour in 1997. Using data derived from a series of interviews with MPs from all sides of the House of Commons, and information on public attitudes to welfare collated from the British Social Attitudes survey, it seeks to identify and explain areas of disagreement and consensus in public and parliamentary attitudes to welfare. It focuses in particular on questions regarding commitment to…

Evidence-informed or value-based? exploring the scrutiny of legislation in the UK Parliament

Philip Begley, Catherine Bochel, Hugh Bochel +6 more

Public Administration · Journal of Legislative Studies · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article argues that three types of factor – process, subject and political circumstance – are likely to affect the extent to which claims of evidence are made during legislative scrutiny. It draws upon case studies of the National Minimum Wage Act 1998, the Academies Act 2010 and the Welfare Reform and Work Act 2016, utilising interviews with those involved and information from Hansard. The article concludes that these cases highlight that while there might be potential benefits from a yet more robust legislative scrutiny process, including greater use of pre-legislative scrutiny and the ability of public bill committees to take evidence from a wider range of witnesses and on all bills, subject and political factors would be likely to mean that the use of claims of evidence would continue to vary widely.

The Conservatives, social policy and public opinion

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Policy Press eBooks · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter provides an assessment of public attitudes to the Conservatives’ policies and public opinion. First, it draws on data from British Social Attitudes surveys to assess whether what some have identified as a rightward shift in public attitudes may have created a climate of opinion in which the election of a Conservative government became more likely. It then describes more recent public opinion data to evaluate public attitudes towards Conservative policies in the run-up to and following the 2010 general election. The outcome of the 2010 general election suggested that the public remained to be convinced that the Conservatives were yet ready for government. There is still evidence for a strong and enduring public commitment to state provision in a range of sectors, which calls into question the extent of potential support for Conservative policies designed to roll back state…

Power without Representation? The House of Lords and Social Policy

Hugh Bochel, Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Social Policy and Society · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the past the House of Lords has generally, and arguably for good reasons, been ignored in discussions of the making and scrutiny of welfare. However, it has always played some role in this field, particularly in the scrutiny and passage of legislation, and since the removal of the bulk of hereditary Peers in 1999, some writers have argued that the House has become more assertive. This article examines the attitudes of Peers, including a comparison with the views of Members of Parliament, and draws a number of conclusions about the role of the upper House in relation to social policy.

The delayed publication of the Russia Report demonstrates why reform is needed to preserve the Intelligence and Security Committee’s independence

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · London School of Economics and Political Science Research Online (London School of Economics and Political Science) · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Events surrounding the publication of the Russia Report reveal as much about the poor state of the government’s relations with Parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) as those with Russia, writes Andrew Defty. He sets out an agenda for reform to restore the independence of the ISC and put relations between the government and the ISC on a more constructive footing.

When will the government respond to the Intelligence and Security Committee’s report on UK lethal drone strikes in Syria?

Andrew Defty

Sociology and Political Science · London School of Economics and Political Science Research Online (London School of Economics and Political Science) · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

It is two years since the Intelligence and Security Committee published its report into UK lethal drone strikes in Syria. Despite a commitment to ‘respond substantively to any report by the ISC within 60 days’ the government has yet to produce a detailed reply to this report. Andrew Defty examines the government’s record in responding to ISC reports and the changing nature of its commitment to doing so.

4. Parliamentary Oversight of Intelligence Agencies: Lessons from Westminster

Hugh Bochel, Andrew Defty

Sociology and Political Science · Open reports series · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The 2014 Referendum on Scottish independence sparked debate on every dimension of modern statehood. Levels of public interest and engagement were unprecedented, as demonstrated by record-breaking voter turnout. Yet aside from Trident, the issue of security was relatively neglected in the campaigns, and there remains a lack of literature on the topic. In this volume Andrew Neal has collated a variety of interdisciplinary perspectives on security and constitutional change in Scotland and the UK, including writing from experts in foreign policy analysis, intelligence studies, parliamentary studies, and journalism.

The delay in appointing a new Intelligence and Security Committee threatens to undermine its work before it has even begun

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · London School of Economics and Political Science Research Online (London School of Economics and Political Science) · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In February of this year, the then-Chair of the Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) – the body which oversees the UK’s three main intelligence agencies – was caught in a journalistic sting operation. Since then, the ISC seems to have been inactive. It is now two months since the General Election and the Government (who take the lead in ISC membership nominations) have also been inactive in beginning the nomination process. Andrew Defty argues that the delay threatens to undermine the important work of the ISC at a critical time before it has even begun.

‘The Government Does Not Comment…’: Parliament and the Intelligence Services

Hugh Bochel, Andrew Defty, Jane Kirkpatrick

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Although the British intelligence and security agencies have a longer history than most, the UK was rather late in subjecting the agencies to parliamentary scrutiny. For most of their 100-year history the intelligence and security agencies operated with relative anonymity and impunity. In the official history of MI5, published to mark the agency’s centenary in 2009, the historian Christopher Andrew observed that until recently the work of British intelligence and security agencies had been underpinned by two constitutional doctrines. The first of these was that the existence of intelligence agencies should never be officially acknowledged. As the historian Sir Michael Howard observed in 1986, ‘so far as official government policy is concerned, enemy agents are found under gooseberry bushes, and our own intelligence is brought by storks’ (quoted in Andrew, 1988). The second…

The future of the British intelligence memoir

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Intelligence & National Security · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

"<p>A review article of three British intelligence memoirs: Desmond Bristow, A Game of Moles; Nicholas Elliott, Never Judge a Man by His Umbrella; and Nicholas Elliott, With My Little Eye. Reviews the books in the context of other British intelligence memoir literature and assesses the official position on intelligence memoirs post-Spycatcher.</p>"

Turning up the thermostat: the Conservatives, social policy and public opinion

Andrew Defty

Political Science and International Relations · Policy Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the period leading up to the 2010 general election, there was evidence of declining support for public spending and a hardening of attitudes towards benefits recipients, which aligned with the austerity agenda of the incoming Coalition government. This chapter examines shifts in public opinion in the period since 2015, following five years of austerity under the Coalition. Drawing on data from the British Social Attitudes survey and opinion polling, it traces shifting public attitudes towards tax and spend, changes in public priorities for state support and a softening of attitudes towards benefits recipients. It also examines public attitudes towards inequality in the context of the government's 'levelling up' agenda as well as the impact of COVID-19 on public attitudes towards state provision.