arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Adam Wyner

74 papers · 2007–2025

2007: 22008: 12009: 22010: 92011: 52012: 82013: 102014: 42015: 62016: 82017: 42018: 02019: 42020: 12021: 42022: 12023: 02024: 22025: 3
2007peak 10 in 20132025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 74 RSS

Identification of Rhetorical Roles of Sentences in Indian Legal Judgments

Paheli Bhattacharya, Shounak Paul, Kripabandhu Ghosh +2 more

cs.IR · · cited 126× · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

Automatically understanding the rhetorical roles of sentences in a legal case judgement is an important problem to solve, since it can help in several downstream tasks like summarization of legal judgments, legal search, and so on. The task is challenging since legal case documents are usually not well-structured, and these rhetorical roles may be subjective (as evident from variation of opinions between legal experts). In this paper, we address this task for judgments from the Supreme Court of India. We label sentences in 50 documents using multiple human annotators, and perform an extensive analysis of the human-assigned labels. We also attempt automatic identification of the rhetorical roles of sentences. While prior approaches towards this task used Conditional Random Fields over manually handcrafted features, we explore the use of deep neural models which do not require…

On Rule Extraction from Regulations

Adam Wyner, Wim Peters

Artificial Intelligence · Frontiers in artificial intelligence and applications · · cited 84× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Rules in regulations such as found in the US Federal Code of Regulations can be expressed using conditional and deontic rules. Identifying and extracting such rules from the language of the source material would be useful for automating rulebook management and translating into an executable logic. The paper presents a linguistically-oriented, rule-based approach, which is in contrast to a machine learning approach. It outlines use cases, discusses the source materials, reviews the methodology, then provides initial results and future steps.

A formalization of argumentation schemes for legal case-based reasoning in ASPIC+

Henry Prakken, Adam Wyner, Trevor Bench‐Capon +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · Journal of Logic and Computation · · cited 80× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this article we offer a formal account of reasoning with legal cases in terms of argumentation schemes. These schemes, and undercutting attacks associated with them, are formalized as defeasible rules of inference within the ASPIC+ framework. We begin by modelling the style of reasoning with cases developed by Aleven and Ashley in the CATO project, which describes cases using factors, and then extend the account to accommodate the dimensions used in Rissland and Ashley's earlier HYPO project. Some additional scope for argumentation is then identified and formalized.

OASIS LegalRuleML

Tara Athan, Harold Boley, Guido Governatori +3 more

Artificial Intelligence · · cited 78× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this paper we present the motivation, use cases, design principles, abstract syntax, and initial core of LegalRuleML. The LegalRuleML-core is sufficiently rich for expressing legal sources, time, defeasibility, and deontic operators. An example is provided. LegalRuleMLis compared to related work.

Recognizing cited facts and principles in legal judgements

Olga Shulayeva, Advaith Siddharthan, Adam Wyner

Political Science and International Relations · Artificial Intelligence and Law · · cited 71× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In common law jurisdictions, legal professionals cite facts and legal principles from precedent cases to support their arguments before the court for their intended outcome in a current case. This practice stems from the doctrine of stare decisis, where cases that have similar facts should receive similar decisions with respect to the principles. It is essential for legal professionals to identify such facts and principles in precedent cases, though this is a highly time intensive task. In this paper, we present studies that demonstrate that human annotators can achieve reasonable agreement on which sentences in legal judgements contain cited facts and principles (respectively, $$\kappa =0.65$$ and $$\kappa =0.95$$ for inter- and intra-annotator agreement). We further demonstrate that it is feasible to automatically annotate sentences containing such legal facts and principles in a…

Semi-Automated Argumentative Analysis of Online Product Reviews

Adam Wyner, Jodi Schneider, Katie Atkinson +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · Frontiers in artificial intelligence and applications · · cited 71× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Argumentation is key to understanding and evaluating many texts. The arguments in the texts must be identified; using current tools, this requires substantial work from human analysts. With a rule-based tool for semi-automatic text analysis support, we facilitate argument identification. The tool highlights potential argumentative sections of a text according to terms indicative of arguments (e.g. ‘suppose’ or ‘therefore’) and domain terminology (e.g. camera names and properties). The information can be used by an analyst to instantiate argumentation schemes and build arguments for and against a proposal. The resulting argumentation framework can then be passed to argument evaluation tools.

Argument Schemes for Legal Case-based Reasoning

Adam Wyner, Trevor Bench‐Capon

Artificial Intelligence · International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Information Systems · · cited 53× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this paper we use the notion of argument schemes to analyse some leading approaches to case-based reasoning in Law. We identify a set of argument schemes that can express the argument provided by such systems and draw attention to some important differences between the various approaches.

Thirty years of artificial intelligence and law: the third decade

Serena Villata, Michał Araszkiewicz, Kevin D. Ashley +4 more

Political Science and International Relations · Artificial Intelligence and Law · · cited 52× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The first issue of Artificial Intelligence and Law journal was published in 1992. This paper offers some commentaries on papers drawn from the Journal’s third decade. They indicate a major shift within Artificial Intelligence, both generally and in AI and Law: away from symbolic techniques to those based on Machine Learning approaches, especially those based on Natural Language texts rather than feature sets. Eight papers are discussed: two concern the management and use of documents available on the World Wide Web, and six apply machine learning techniques to a variety of legal applications.

A Semi-automated Ontology Construction for Legal Question Answering

Biralatei Fawei, Jeff Z. Pan, Martin J. Kollingbaum +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · New Generation Computing · · cited 43× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The internet and the development of the semantic web have created the opportunity to provide structured legal data on the web. However, most legal information is in text. It is difficult to automatically determine the right natural language answer about the law to a given natural language question. One approach is to develop systems of legal ontologies and rules. Our example ontology represents semantic information about USA criminal law and procedure as well as the applicable legal rules. The purpose of the ontology is to provide reasoning support to a legal question answering tool that determines entailment between a pair of texts, one known as the background information (Bg) and the other question statement (Q), so whether Bg entails Q based on the application of the legal rules. The key contribution of this paper is the methodology and the semi-automated legal ontology generation…

Towards formalising argumentation about legal cases

Adam Wyner, Trevor Bench‐Capon, Katie Atkinson

Artificial Intelligence · Cronfa (Swansea University) · · cited 27× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this paper we offer an account of reasoning with legal cases in terms of argumentation schemes. These schemes, and undercutting attacks associated with them, are expressed as defeasible rules of inference that will lend themselves to formalisation within the AS-PIC+ framework. We begin by modelling the style of reasoning with cases developed by Aleven and Ashley in the CATO project, which describes cases using factors, and then extend the account to accommodate the dimensions used in Rissland and Ashley's earlier HYPO project. Some additional scope for argumentation is then identified and formalised.

Semantic models for policy deliberation

Katie Atkinson, Trevor Bench‐Capon, Dan Cartwright +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · · cited 27× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Semantic models have received little attention in recent years, much of their role having been taken over by developments in ontologies. Ontologies, however, are static, and so have only a limited role in reasoning about domains in which change matters. In this paper, we focus on the domain of policy deliberation, where policy decisions are designed to change things to realise particular social values. We explore how a particular kind of state transition system can be constructed to serve as a semantic model to support reasoning about alternative policy decisions. The policy making process includes stages that support the construction of a model, which can then be exploited in reasoning. The reasoning itself will be driven by a particular argumentation scheme for practical reasoning, and the ways in which arguments based on this scheme can be attacked and evaluated. The evaluation…

Arguments, Values and Baseballs: Representation of Popov v. Hayashi

Adam Wyner, Trevor Bench‐Capon, Katie Atkinson

Artificial Intelligence · International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Information Systems · · cited 26× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The first 10 years of a primary health service in the Cape Peninsula are reviewed. The importance of primary care and self-care with regard to health resources is stressed. For such a service to be effective and co-ordinated with hospital specialist services requires the input of specialist expertise, which is timely but not timeless. The results of such paediatric and obstetric specialist input and the "bait" of care for current illness to involve patients in preventive and self-care measures are shown.

Summarising the points made in online political debates

Charlie Egan, Advaith Siddharthan, Adam Wyner

Artificial Intelligence · Open Research Online (The Open University) · · cited 24× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Online communities host growing numbers of discussions amongst large groups of participants on all manner of topics. This user-generated content contains millions of statements of opinions and ideas. We propose an abstractive approach to summarize such argumentative discussions, making key content accessible through 'point' extraction, where a point is a verb and its syntactic arguments. Our approach uses both dependency parse information and verb case frames to identify and extract valid points, and generates an abstractive summary that discusses the key points being made in the debate. We performed a human evaluation of our approach using a corpus of online political debates and report significant improvements over a highperforming extractive summarizer.

Argument schemes for reasoning with legal cases using values

Trevor Bench‐Capon, Henry Prakken, Adam Wyner +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · · cited 24× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Argument schemes can provide a means of explicitly describing reasoning methods in a form that lends itself to computation. The reasoning required to distinguish cases in the manner of CATO has been previously captured as a set of argument schemes. Here we present argument schemes that encapsulate another way of reasoning with cases: using preferences between social values revealed in past decisions to decide cases which have no exact matching precedents when the cases are described in terms of factors. We provide a set of schemes, with variations to capture different ways of comparing sets and varying degrees of promotion of values; we formalise these schemes; and we illustrate them with some examples.

Lexical Semantics and Expert Legal Knowledge towards the Identification of Legal Case Factors

Adam Wyner, Wim Peters

Political Science and International Relations · Frontiers in artificial intelligence and applications · · cited 22× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Legal case factors are textually represented facts which are represented in reported legal case decisions. Precedent decisions contribute to the decision of a case under consideration. As textually represented facts, factors linguistically encode semantic properties and relationships among the entities which can be leveraged to identify and extract the legal case factors from decisions. We integrate legal and linguistic resources in a text analysis tool with which we annotate textual passages. Using annotations tailored to legal case factors, the legal researcher can rapidly zero in on textual spans which represent specific combinations of factors, participants, and semantic properties which bear on who played what role with respect to a factor. The research reports progress on the development of a tool.

A Framework for Enriched, Controlled On-line Discussion Forums for e-Government Policy-making

Adam Wyner, Tom van Engers

Artificial Intelligence · · cited 21× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The paper motivates and proposes a framework for enriched on-line dis-cussion forums for e-government policy-making, where pro and con state-ments for positions are structured, recorded, represented, and evaluated. The framework builds on current technologies for multi-threaded discus-sion lists by integrating modes, natural language processing, ontologies, and formal argumentation frameworks. With modes other than the stan-dard “reply comment”, users specify the semantic relationship between a new statement and the previous statement; the result is an argument graph. Natural language processing with a controlled language constrains the domain of discourse, eliminates ambiguity and unclarity, allows a log-ical representation of statements, and facilitates information extraction. However, the controlled language is highly expressive and natural. On-tologies represent the knowledge of the…

Argumentation based tools for policy-making

Maya Wardeh, Adam Wyner, Katie Atkinson +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · · cited 17× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Citizens have a variety of ways to consult with their representatives about policy proposals, seeking justifications, objecting to all or part of it, or making a counter-proposal. For the first, the representative needs only to state a justification. For the second, the representative would want to understand the objections, which may involve asking some questions. For the third, the citizen would have to provide a well formulated proposal that can then be critiqued from the standpoint of the government's own policy proposal. At the end of such a consultation, users will have aired their proposals, understood the implications, and received feedback on how their proposals contrast to that of the government.

Working on the argument pipeline: Through flow issues between natural language argument, instantiated arguments, and argumentation frameworks

Adam Wyner, Tom van Engers, Anthony Hunter

Artificial Intelligence · Argument & Computation · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In many domains of public discourse such as arguments about public policy, there is an abundance of knowledge to store, query, and reason with. To use this knowledge, we must address two key general problems: first, the problem of the knowledge acquisition bottleneck between forms in which the knowledge is usually expressed, e.g., natural language, and forms which can be automatically processed; second, reasoning with the uncertainties and inconsistencies of the knowledge. Given such complexities, it is labour and knowledge intensive to conduct policy consultations, where participants contribute statements to the policy discourse. Yet, from such a consultation, we want to derive policy positions, where each position is a set of consistent statements, but where positions may be mutually inconsistent. To address these problems and support policy-making consultations, we consider recent…

Argumentation Schemes for Reasoning about Factors with Dimensions

Katie Atkinson, Trevor Bench‐Capon, Prakken Henry +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · Frontiers in artificial intelligence and applications · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In previous work we presented argumentation schemes to capture the CATO and value based theory construction approaches to reasoning with legal cases with factors. We formalised the schemes with ASPIC+, a formal representation of instantiated argumentation. In ASPIC+ the premises of a scheme may either be a factor provided in a knowledge base or established using a further argumentation scheme. Thus far we have taken the factors associated with cases to be given in the knowledge base. While this is adequate for expressing factor based reasoning, we can further investigate the justifications for the relationship between factors and facts or evidence. In this paper we examine how dimensions as used in the HYPO system can provide grounds on which to argue about which factors should apply to a case. By making this element of the reasoning explicit and subject to argument, we advance our…

Towards Annotating and Extracting Textual Legal Case Elements

Adam Wyner

Political Science and International Relations · Cronfa (Swansea University) · · cited 16× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In common law contexts, legal cases are decided with respect to precedents rather than legislation as in civil law contexts. Legal professionals must find, analyse, and reason with and about cases drawn from a set of cases (a case base). A range of particular textual elements of a case may be relevant to query and extract. Commercial providers of legal information allow legal professionals to search a case base by keywords and meta data. However, the case base and the search tools are proprietary, of limited, non-extensible functionality, and are restricted access. Moreover, no provider applies natural language processing techniques to the cases for text analysis, XML annotation, or information acquisition. In this paper, we discuss an initial experiment in developing and applying natural language processing tools to cases to produce annotated text which can then support information…

A Case Study on Legal Case Annotation

Adam Wyner, Wim Peters, Daniel Katz

Political Science and International Relations · Frontiers in artificial intelligence and applications · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The paper reports the outcomes of a study with law school students to annotate a corpus of legal cases for a variety of annotation types, e.g. citation indices, legal facts, rationale, judgement, cause of action, and others. An online tool is used by a group of annotators that results in an annotated corpus. Differences amongst the annotations are curated, producing a gold standard corpus of annotated texts. The annotations can be extracted with semantic searches of complex queries. There would be many such uses for the development and analysis of such a corpus for both legal education and legal research.

An Empirical Approach to the Semantic Representation of Laws

Adam Wyner, Bos Johan, Valerio Basile +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · Frontiers in artificial intelligence and applications · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

To make legal texts machine processable, the texts may be represented as linked documents, semantically tagged text, or translated to formal representations that can be automatically reasoned with. The paper considers the latter, which is key to testing consistency of laws, drawing inferences, and providing explanations relative to input. To translate laws to a form that can be reasoned with by a computer, sentences must be parsed and formally represented. The paper presents the state-of-the-art in automatic translation of law to a machine readable formal representation, provides corpora, outlines some key problems, and proposes tasks to address the problems.

A Study on Translating Regulatory Rules from Natural Language to Defeasible Logic

Adam Wyner, Guido Governatori

Political Science and International Relations · Cronfa (Swansea University) · · cited 13× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract. Legally binding regulations are expressed in natural language. Yet, we cannot formally or automatically reason with regulations in that form. Defeasible Logic has been used to formally represent the semantic interpretation of regulations; such representations may provide the abstract specification for a machinereadable and processable representation as in LegalRuleML. However, manual translation is prohibitively costly in terms of time, labour, and knowledge. The paper discusses work in progress using the state-of-the-art in automatic translation of a sample of regulatory clauses to a machine readable formal representation and a comparison to correlated Defeasible Logic representations. It outlines some key problems and proposes tasks to address the problems. 1

Sentiment–topic modeling in text mining

Chenghua Lin, Ebuka Ibeke, Adam Wyner +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In recent years, there has been a rapid growth of research interest in natural language processing that seeks to better understand sentiment or opinion expressed in text. There are several notable issues in most previous work in sentiment analysis, among them: the trained classifiers are domain‐dependent; the labeled corpora required for training can be difficult to acquire from real‐world text; and dependencies between sentiments and topics are not taken into consideration. In response to these limitations, a new family of probabilistic topic models, namely joint sentiment–topic models, have been developed, which are capable of detecting sentiment in connection with topic from text without using any labeled data for training. In addition, the sentiment‐bearing topics extracted by the joint sentiment–topic models provide means for automatically discovering and summarizing opinions from…

Identifying consumers' arguments in text

Jodi Schneider, Adam Wyner

Artificial Intelligence · · cited 12× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract. Product reviews are a corpus of textual data on consumer opinions. While reviews can be sorted by rating, there is limited support to search in the corpus for statements about particular topics, e.g. properties of a product. Moreover, where opinions are justified or criticised, statements in the corpus indicate arguments and counterarguments. Explicitly structuring these statements into arguments could help better understand customers ’ disposition towards a product. We present a semi-automated, rule-based information extraction tool to support the identification of statements and arguments in a corpus, using: argumentation schemes; user, domain, and sentiment terminology; and discourse indicators.