arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Adam B. Mantz

76 papers · 2007–2026

2007: 22008: 12009: 42010: 02011: 32012: 82013: 22014: 52015: 42016: 52017: 52018: 32019: 92020: 32021: 42022: 42023: 22024: 22025: 32026: 7
2007peak 9 in 20192026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 76 RSS

Snowmass 2021 CMB-S4 White Paper

Kevork Abazajian, Arwa Abdulghafour, Graeme E. Addison +353 more

astro-ph.CO · · cited 71× · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

This Snowmass 2021 White Paper describes the Cosmic Microwave Background Stage 4 project CMB-S4, which is designed to cross critical thresholds in our understanding of the origin and evolution of the Universe, from the highest energies at the dawn of time through the growth of structure to the present day. We provide an overview of the science case, the technical design, and project plan.

A Gibbs Sampler for Multivariate Linear Regression

Adam B. Mantz

astro-ph.IM · · cited 19× · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

Kelly (2007, hereafter K07) described an efficient algorithm, using Gibbs sampling, for performing linear regression in the fairly general case where non-zero measurement errors exist for both the covariates and response variables, where these measurements may be correlated (for the same data point), where the response variable is affected by intrinsic scatter in addition to measurement error, and where the prior distribution of covariates is modeled by a flexible mixture of Gaussians rather than assumed to be uniform. Here I extend the K07 algorithm in two ways. First, the procedure is generalized to the case of multiple response variables. Second, I describe how to model the prior distribution of covariates using a Dirichlet process, which can be thought of as a Gaussian mixture where the number of mixture components is learned from the data. I present an example of multivariate…

Coping with Selection Effects: A Primer on Regression with Truncated Data

Adam B. Mantz

astro-ph.IM · · cited 8× · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

The finite sensitivity of instruments or detection methods means that data sets in many areas of astronomy, for example cosmological or exoplanet surveys, are necessarily systematically incomplete. Such data sets, where the population being investigated is of unknown size and only partially represented in the data, are called "truncated" in the statistical literature. Truncation can be accounted for through a relatively straightforward modification to the model being fitted in many circumstances, provided that the model can be extended to describe the population of undetected sources. Here I examine the problem of regression using truncated data in general terms, and use a simple example to show the impact of selecting a subset of potential data on the dependent variable, on the independent variable, and on a second dependent variable that is correlated with the variable of interest.…

The Future Landscape of High-Redshift Galaxy Cluster Science

Adam B. Mantz, Steven W. Allen, Nicholas Battaglia +6 more

astro-ph.CO · · cited 0× · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

Modern galaxy cluster science is a multi-wavelength endeavor with cornerstones provided by X-ray, optical/IR, mm, and radio measurements. In combination, these observations enable the construction of large, clean, complete cluster catalogs, and provide precise redshifts and robust mass calibration. The complementary nature of these multi-wavelength data dramatically reduces the impact of systematic effects that limit the utility of measurements made in any single waveband. The future of multi-wavelength cluster science is compelling, with cluster catalogs set to expand by orders of magnitude in size, and extend, for the first time, into the high-redshift regime where massive, virialized structures first formed. Unlocking astrophysical and cosmological insight from the coming catalogs will require new observing facilities that combine high spatial and spectral resolution with large…

The observed growth of massive galaxy clusters

David Rapetti, Steven W. Allen, Adam Mantz +1 more

Artificial Intelligence · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This is the third of a series of papers in which we derive simultaneous constraints on cosmolog-ical parameters and X-ray scaling relations using observations of the growth of massive, X-ray flux-selected galaxy clusters. Our data set consists of 238 clusters drawn from the ROSAT All-Sky Survey and incorporates extensive follow-up observations using the Chandra X-ray Observatory. Here we present improved constraints on departures from general relativity (GR) on cosmological scales, using the growth index, γ, to parametrize the linear growth rate of cosmic structure. Using the method of Mantz et al. (Paper I), we simultaneously and self-consistently model the growth of X-ray luminous clusters and their observable–mass scaling relations, accounting for survey biases, parameter degeneracies and the impact of systematic uncertainties. Such analysis of the survey and follow-up data is…

CARMA Measurements of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect in RXJ1347.5-1145

Thomas J. Plagge, Daniel P. Marrone, Zubair Abdulla +10 more

astro-ph.CO · · cited 0× · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We demonstrate the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect imaging capabilities of the Combined Array for Research in Millimeter-wave Astronomy (CARMA) by presenting an SZ map of the galaxy cluster RXJ1347.5-1145. By combining data from multiple CARMA bands and configurations, we are able to capture the structure of this cluster over a wide range of angular scales, from its bulk properties to its core morphology. We find that roughly 9% of this cluster's thermal energy is associated with sub-arcminute-scale structure imparted by a merger, illustrating the value of high-resolution SZ measurements for pursuing cluster astrophysics and for understanding the scatter in SZ scaling relations. We also find that the cluster's SZ signal is lower in amplitude than suggested by a spherically-symmetric model derived from X-ray data, consistent with compression along the line of sight relative to the plane…

RNDR noise modeling in first-generation Single electron Sensitive Readout (SiSeRO) devices

Tonya L. Peshel, Abigail Y. Pan, Tanmoy Chattopadhyay +18 more

astro-ph.IM · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

Flagship observatories require single-photon detectors with ultra-fast readout, sub-electron noise performance, and scalable large-format architectures. The X-ray Astronomy and Observational Cosmology group at Stanford, in collaboration with the MIT Kavli Institute and MIT Lincoln Laboratory, is developing readout technologies for next-generation detectors. Prototypes employing Single-electron Sensitive Readout (SiSeRO) amplifiers demonstrate excellent read noise and spectral performance using repetitive non-destructive readout (RNDR), achieving 0.5 e$^-$ noise in under 57 cycles. We have modeled noise for longer RNDR cycles, exploring probabilistic mechanisms such as thermal leakage and impact ionization. Here we present our model results, including statistical limits on dark current-like signals. Maturation of SiSeRO technology will improve detector performance at soft X-ray energies…

Clusters Hiding Under Millimeter Sources (CHUMS) I: Extreme CHUMS

Harshda Saxena, Adam B. Mantz, Jack Sayers +2 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

Galaxy cluster abundance provides a powerful probe of the $Λ$CDM model and enables precise constraints on cosmological parameters. Millimeter-wavelength surveys detect clusters through the Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) effect, and are particularly effective at high redshifts. However, the SZ signal can be significantly contaminated by emission from Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN), particularly AGN within the Central Galaxies (CGs). This contamination reduces the SZ signal strength at the frequencies most accessible from the ground, which reduces detection significances or converts cluster detections to non-detections, thereby diminishing survey completeness and introducing biases in cosmological analyses. In this work, we analyze three clusters that host bright AGN in their CGs using 30 and 90 GHz observations from the Combined Array for Research in Millimeter-wave Astronomy (CARMA). In each case…

The Cluster Evolutionary Reference Ensemble at Low-$z$ (CEREAL) Sample of Galaxy Clusters I: X-ray Morphological Properties and Demographics

Laurel White, Michael McDonald, Steven W. Allen +8 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

With rapid improvements in the assembly of large samples of galaxy clusters, we are approaching the ability to study clusters at $z\gtrsim2$. Evolutionary studies comparing these distant clusters to the clusters in our local universe depend heavily on the reliability of low-redshift cluster samples, most of which are subject to X-ray selection effects, biasing them to relaxed, cool core clusters. Here, we introduce the Cluster Evolutionary Reference Ensemble At Low-$z$ (CEREAL) sample, composed of Chandra X-ray observations of 169 galaxy clusters that have been selected from the Planck Sunyaev-Zel'dovich catalog. CEREAL has a simple and well-understood selection function, spans an order of magnitude in mass at $z\sim0.15$, and has uniform, high-resolution X-ray follow-up. We present the full sample and provide results based on X-ray surface brightness properties, finding significantly…

SPT-CL J0417-4748: A Deep Chandra Study of a Relaxed Galaxy Cluster Without Central Star Formation

Taweewat Somboonpanyakul, Adam B. Mantz, Steven W. Allen +7 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We present an in-depth Chandra X-ray analysis of the galaxy cluster SPT-CL J0417$-$4748 (hereafter SPT J0417), at z = 0.58, with a focus on its thermodynamic properties and the apparent absence of central star formation. Utilizing a total Chandra exposure of 103 ks, we find that the large-scale X-ray morphology is consistent with a dynamically relaxed, cool-core system. The intracluster medium (ICM) shows a central density of 0.08+/-0.01 cm^{-3}, a central pseudo-entropy of 26^{+6}_{-5} keVcm^{2} and a central cooling time of 515^{+96}_{-75} Myr, values typical of massive cool-core clusters. Despite these conditions, no evidence of recent or ongoing star formation is detected in the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG). Spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting of DES photometry indicates that the bulk of the stellar population formed at z~1.25, with no significant star formation over the…

Multiwavelength Characterization of a Dynamically Relaxed Cool Core Galaxy Cluster at $z=1.5$

Anthony M. Flores, Adam B. Mantz, Steven W. Allen +5 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We present imaging and spectroscopic analyses of Chandra and XMM-Newton observations of ACT-CL J0123.5$-$0428, one of the most massive, highest redshift galaxy clusters detected within the survey fields of the Atacama Cosmology Telescope. The Chandra data are sufficient to characterize the morphology of this cluster and constrain the geometrically deprojected temperature in 2 spatial bins out to $r_{2500}$, revealing a dynamically relaxed system whose temperature drops to $kT = 1.8\pm0.6$ keV in the inner $\sim40$kpc. Within this same inner radius, the surface brightness and density of the ICM is sharply peaked, and the cooling time falls to $t_\mathrm{cool}=280^{+150}_{-120}$ Myr. A novel forward-modeling analysis of the XMM data extends imaging and spectroscopic measurements of this system out to $r_{500}$, constraining the redshift to $z=1.50\pm0.03$, with a mean temperature of $kT =…

Deep Chandra Observations of the z = 1.16 Relaxed, Cool-core Galaxy Cluster SPT-CL J2215-3537

Haley R. Stueber, Adam B. Mantz, Steven W. Allen +10 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

Galaxy clusters serve as a unique and valuable laboratory for probing cosmological models and understanding astrophysics at the high-mass limit of structure formation. Clusters that are dynamically relaxed are especially useful targets of study because of their morphological and dynamical simplicity. However, at redshifts z > 1, very few such clusters have been identified. We present results from new Chandra observations of the cluster SPT-CL J2215-3537 (hereafter SPT J2215), at z = 1.16, the second most distant relaxed, cool-core cluster identified to date. We place constraints on the cluster's total mass profile and investigate its thermodynamic profiles, scaling relations (gas mass, average temperature, and X-ray luminosity), and metal enrichment, resolving the cool core and providing essential context for the massive starburst seen in its central galaxy. We contextualize the…

Initial Investigations of the Outskirts of XLSSC 122

Eleanore. B. Todd, Jon. P. Willis, Rebecca. E. A. Canning +7 more

astro-ph.GA · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We investigate the redshift 1.98 galaxy cluster XLSSC 122 using the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) from the core of the cluster out to 3 Mpc, a scale equivalent to 10 times the R500 = 295 kpc radius. We present an expanded photometric and spectroscopic catalogue of the cluster, bringing the total number of spectroscopically classified member galaxies to 74, with 35 new member galaxies added in the outer regions of the cluster. We compute the radial galaxy number density profile in the cluster, and observe no clear evidence of infalling groups or cosmic filaments. We observe a clear bimodal colour relation in member galaxies, with red fraction increasing towards the cluster centre. This rapid increase of red fraction upon infall is indicative of a fast quenching mechanism, such as ram pressure stripping, as galaxies enter the cluster centre. We fit a luminosity function to the cluster…

Ruminations Upon the Modeling of X-ray Foregrounds, Backgrounds and Faint Sources

Adam B. Mantz, Anthony M. Flores, Taweewat Somboonpanyakul +4 more

astro-ph.IM · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

With the goal of extracting as much information as possible from Chandra and XMM-Newton observations of faint, diffuse sources such as galaxy clusters, as well as those of future X-ray telescopes, we present a strategy for forward modeling all the foreground and background signals present in these data. This work leverages widespread efforts to understand the soft X-ray emission from the Galaxy, as well as the cosmic X-ray background and instrument-specific, particle-induced backgrounds. Statistically, a forward model of the foregrounds and backgrounds is preferable to alternatives because it requires no binning of the data, and allows straightforward marginalization over systematic uncertainties. We apply these methods to several galaxy clusters at intermediate-to-high redshifts, spanning a range of masses and morphologies, using Chandra and/or XMM-Newton data. Our results suggest a…

The Advanced X-ray Imaging Satellite (AXIS) Community Science Book

Michael Koss, Nafisa Aftab, Steven W. Allen +395 more

astro-ph.HE · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

The AXIS Community Science Book represents the collective effort of 592 scientists worldwide to define the transformative science enabled by the Advanced X-ray Imaging Satellite (AXIS), a next-generation X-ray mission selected by NASA's Astrophysics Probe Program for Phase A study. AXIS will advance the legacy of high-angular-resolution X-ray astronomy with ~1.5'' imaging over a wide 24' field of view and an order of magnitude greater collecting area than Chandra in the 0.3-12 keV band. Combining sharp imaging, high throughput, and rapid response capabilities, AXIS will open new windows on virtually every aspect of modern astrophysics, exploring the birth and growth of supermassive black holes, the feedback processes that shape galaxies, the life cycles of stars and exoplanet environments, and the nature of compact stellar remnants, supernova remnants, and explosive transients. This…

Measuring the Temperature of Extremely Hot Shock-Heated Gas in the Major Merger MACS J0717.5+3745 With Relativistic Corrections to the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect

Benjamin J. Vaughan, Jack Sayers, Locke Spencer +10 more

astro-ph.GA · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

The conversion of gravitational potential to kinetic energy results in an intracluster medium (ICM) gas with a characteristic temperature near 10 keV in the most massive galaxy clusters. X-ray observations, primarily from Chandra and XMM-Newton, have revealed a wealth of information about the thermodynamics of this gas. However, two regimes remain difficult to study with current instruments: superheated gas well above 10 keV generated by shocks from major mergers, and distant systems strongly impacted by cosmological dimming. Relativistic corrections to the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect (rSZe) produce a fractional spectral distortion in the cosmic microwave background at submillimeter and millimeter wavelengths that could offer a complementary probe of both high-temperature and high-redshift ICM gas. Here we describe multiband measurements of the rSZe, including observations from the…

A Generative Model for Realistic Galaxy Cluster X-ray Morphologies

Maya Benyas, Jordan Pfeifer, Adam B. Mantz +2 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

The X-ray morphologies of clusters of galaxies display significant variations, reflecting their dynamical histories and the nonlinear dependence of X-ray emissivity on the density of the intracluster gas. Qualitative and quantitative assessments of X-ray morphology have long been considered a proxy for determining whether clusters are dynamically active or "relaxed." Conversely, the use of circularly or elliptically symmetric models for cluster emission can be complicated by the variety of complex features realized in nature, spanning scales from Mpc down to the resolution limit of current X-ray observatories. In this work, we use mock X-ray images from simulated clusters from THE THREE HUNDRED project to define a basis set of cluster image features. We take advantage of clusters' approximate self similarity to minimize the differences between images before encoding the remaining…

Optical Photometric Indicators of Galaxy Cluster Relaxation

Madeline C. Casas, Ky Putnam, Adam B. Mantz +2 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

The most dynamically relaxed clusters of galaxies play a special role in cosmological studies as well as astrophysical studies of the intracluster medium (ICM) and active galactic nucleus feedback. While high spatial resolution imaging of the morphology of the ICM has long been the gold standard for establishing a cluster's dynamical state, such data are not available from current or planned surveys, and thus require separate, pointed follow-up observations. With optical and/or near-IR photometric imaging, and red-sequence cluster finding results from those data, expected to be ubiquitously available for clusters discovered in upcoming optical and mm-wavelength surveys, it is worth asking how effectively photometric data alone can identify relaxed cluster candidates, before investing in, e.g., high-resolution X-ray observations. Here we assess the ability of several simple photometric…

SPT-CL J2215-3537: A Massive Starburst at the Center of the Most Distant Relaxed Galaxy Cluster

Michael S. Calzadilla, Lindsey E. Bleem, Michael McDonald +14 more

astro-ph.GA · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We present the discovery of the most distant, dynamically relaxed cool core cluster, SPT-CL J2215-3537 (SPT2215) and its central brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) at z=1.16. Using new X-ray observations, we demonstrate that SPT2215 harbors a strong cool core, with a central cooling time of 200 Myr (at 10 kpc) and a maximal intracluster medium cooling rate of 1900+/-400 Msun/yr. This prodigious cooling may be responsible for fueling extended, star-forming filaments observed in Hubble Space Telescope imaging. Based on new spectrophotometric data, we detect bright [O II] emission in the BCG, implying an unobscured star formation rate (SFR) of 320^{+230}_{-140} Msun/yr. The detection of a weak radio source (2.0+/-0.8 mJy at 0.8 GHz) suggests ongoing feedback from an active galactic nucleus (AGN), though the implied jet power is less than half the cooling luminosity of the hot gas, consistent…

The Concentration-Mass Relation of Massive, Dynamically Relaxed Galaxy Clusters: Agreement Between Observations and $Λ$CDM Simulations

Elise Darragh-Ford, Adam B. Mantz, Elena Rasia +5 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

The relationship linking a galaxy cluster's total mass with the concentration of its mass profile and its redshift is a fundamental prediction of the Cold Dark Matter (CDM) paradigm of cosmic structure formation. However, confronting those predictions with observations is complicated by the fact that simulated clusters are not representative of observed samples where detailed mass profile constraints are possible. In this work, we calculate the Symmetry-Peakiness-Alignment (SPA) morphology metrics for maps of X-ray emissivity from THE THREE HUNDRED project hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy clusters at four redshifts, and thereby select a sample of morphologically relaxed, simulated clusters, using observational criteria. These clusters have on average earlier formation times than the full sample, confirming that they are both morphologically and dynamically more relaxed than typical.…

Chandra measurements of gas homogeneity and turbulence at intermediate radii in the Perseus Cluster

Martijn de Vries, Adam B. Mantz, Steven W. Allen +6 more

astro-ph.HE · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We present a Chandra study of surface brightness fluctuations in the diffuse intracluster medium of the Perseus Cluster. Our study utilizes deep, archival imaging of the cluster core as well as a new mosaic of 29 short 5 ks observations extending in 8 different directions out to radii of r_500 ~ 2.2r_2500. Under the assumption that the distribution of densities at a given radius is log-normally distributed, two important quantities can be derived from the width of the log-normal density distribution on a given spatial scale: the density bias, which is equal to the square root of the clumping factor C; and the one-component turbulent velocity, v_(k, 1D). We forward-model all contributions to the measured surface brightness, including astrophysical and particle background components, and account for the Poisson nature of the measured signal. Measuring the distribution of surface…

The Evolution and Mass Dependence of Galaxy Cluster Pressure Profiles at 0.05 $\le z \le$ 0.60 and $4 \times 10^{14}$ M$_{\odot}$ $\le \textrm{M}_{500} \le 30 \times 10^{14}$ M$_{\odot}$

Jack Sayers, Adam B. Mantz, Elena Rasia +5 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We have combined X-ray observations from Chandra with Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect data from Planck and Bolocam to measure intra-cluster medium pressure profiles from 0.03R$_{500}$ $\le$ R $\le$ 5R$_{500}$ for a sample of 21 low-$z$ galaxy clusters with a median redshift $\langle z \rangle = 0.08$ and a median mass $\langle \textrm{M}_{500} \rangle = 6.1 \times 10^{14}$ M$_{\odot}$ and a sample of 19 mid-$z$ galaxy clusters with $\langle z \rangle = 0.50$ and $\langle \textrm{M}_{500} \rangle = 10.6 \times 10^{14}$ M$_{\odot}$. The mean scaled pressure in the low-$z$ sample is lower at small radii and higher at large radii, a trend that is accurately reproduced in similarly selected samples from The300 simulations. This difference appears to be primarily due to dynamical state at small radii, evolution at intermediate radii, and a combination of evolution and mass dependence at large…

X-ray morphology of cluster-mass haloes in self-interacting dark matter

Xuejian Shen, Thejs Brinckmann, David Rapetti +4 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We perform cosmological zoom-in simulations of $19$ relaxed cluster-mass haloes with the inclusion of adiabatic gas in the cold dark matter (CDM) and self-interacting dark matter (SIDM) models. These clusters are selected as dynamically relaxed clusters from a parent simulation with $M_{\rm 200} \simeq 1\operatorname{-}3\times 10^{15}\,{\rm M}_{\odot}$. Both the dark matter and the intracluster gas distributions in SIDM appear more spherical than their CDM counterparts. Mock X-ray images are generated based on the simulations and are compared to the real X-ray images of $84$ relaxed clusters selected from the Chandra and ROSAT archives. We perform ellipse fitting for the isophotes of mock and real X-ray images and obtain the ellipticities at cluster-centric radii of $r\simeq 0.1\operatorname{-}0.2\,R_{\rm 200}$. The X-ray isophotes in SIDM models with increasing cross-sections are…

Cosmological Constraints from Gas Mass Fractions of Massive, Relaxed Galaxy Clusters

Adam B. Mantz, Steven W. Allen, Rebecca E. A. Canning +14 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We present updated cosmological constraints from measurements of the gas mass fractions ($f_{gas}$) of massive, dynamically relaxed galaxy clusters. Our new data set has greater leverage on models of dark energy, thanks to the addition of the Perseus Cluster at low redshifts, two new clusters at redshifts $z>0.97$, and significantly longer observations of four clusters at $0.6<z<0.9$. Our low-redshift ($z<0.16$) $f_{gas}$ data, combined with the cosmic baryon fraction measured from the cosmic microwave background (CMB), imply a Hubble constant of $h = 0.722 \pm 0.067$. Combining the full $f_{gas}$ data set with priors on the cosmic baryon density and the Hubble constant, we constrain the dark energy density to be $Ω_Λ= 0.865 \pm 0.119$ in non-flat $Λ$CDM (cosmological constant) models, and its equation of state to be $w = -1.13_{-0.20}^{+0.17}$ in flat, constant-w models, respectively…

Measurement of the Relativistic Sunyaev-Zeldovich Corrections in RX J1347.5-1145

Victoria Butler, Richard M. Feder, Tansu Daylan +8 more

astro-ph.CO · · arXiv ↗ · more like this ·

We present a measurement of the relativistic corrections to the thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect spectrum, the rSZ effect, toward the massive galaxy cluster RX J1347.5-1145 by combining sub-mm images from Herschel-SPIRE with mm-wave Bolocam maps. Our analysis simultaneously models the SZ effect signal, the population of cosmic infrared background (CIB) galaxies, and galactic cirrus dust emission in a manner that fully accounts for their spatial and frequency-dependent correlations. Gravitational lensing of background galaxies by RX J1347.5-1145 is included in our methodology based on a mass model derived from HST observations. Utilizing a set of realistic mock observations, we employ a forward modelling approach that accounts for the non-Gaussian covariances between observed astrophysical components to determine the posterior distribution of SZ effect brightness values consistent…