arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Anthropology

Women in the Aeneid : Foreign, Female, and a Threat to Traditional Roman Society or Examples of Model Male Citizens?

Colleen Reilly

· Carroll Collected (John Carroll University)

See on the map

Abstract

When asked to consider the role of women in ancient Greece and Rome, most people are quick to picture "the ideal Roman woman," that is a woman who dutifully sits at home, cares for the children, spends her days weaving at the loom and tending to household tasks, and is characterized by typical feminine traits.In considering the role of men, most would conjure up an image of a man both a fearless warrior and a dedicated statesman.In the classical world, few would imagine a woman who possesses not feminine traits, but instead those traits characteristic of a prominent male citizen.In his epic poem the Aeneid , written between 29 and 19 B.C., Vergil intentionally portrays characters in a way that serves simultaneously as a threat to traditional 1 gender roles in Roman society while also providing an example of ideal Roman values.Specifically, the characters that are both foreign and female, despite embodying certain Roman virtues, threaten the standard cultural norms of ancient Rome.Dido, the queen of Carthage, Penthesilea, an Amazon warrior queen, and Camilla, another female warrior, represent women who, while possessing certain Roman qualities, are doomed to fail in a world that is, according to societal standards of the time, rightly dominated by males.Vergil uses his epic poem as a means to describe a national identity that was distinctly Roman to identify the qualities characteristic of Roman citizens to serve as a warning as to what happens when certain limits are surpassed and to reinforce gender roles.The Aeneid , then, serves not only to establish a Roman identity that acknowledges, however grudgingly, that women are a physically necessary component to that continued existence, but also what happens when their role extends too far.It also addresses the problem of assimilation and the incorporation of other cultures into a Roman society.1 Throughout my argument, I will spell Vergil as such.However, in citing other authors who chose to spell the author's name "Virgil" I have intentionally left their spellings. Reilly 3Women in the ancient world had a single function that defined their existence, that is, to produce children, and male children at that.They experienced few, if any, legal and political rights and were believed to be inferior to men in every aspect.Gender stereotypes were prevalent in the classical world and not only stemmed from preconceived notions held by the common people but were even legitimated by philosophical thought which justified gender stereotypes.Thus, women were relegated to the world of household tasks such as spinning, weaving, and caring for children.Due to their supposed physical, mental, and even emotional inferiority, they had absolutely no place in the public realm of politics and warfare.Aristotle said that "the male is by nature fitter for command than the female."This was the way of thought that dominated 2 classical society and much of history.Women's bodies were physically suited for the task of child rearing and consequently were restricted to that role, as "the dominant medical image of women reflected contemporary conceptions of female nature and women's role in society." 3 Classical society held that women's bodies were built for the purpose of carrying, birthing, and nurturing children.Differences between men and women were not only in physical construction but also in mental capacity, as Hippocratic theory argued that the physical differences between males and females directly accounted for the difference in mental ability between the two genders.To ancient Romans and Greeks, a weak body was synonymous with a weak mind.Galen, another important philosopher and physician, supported this in stating that "the female is less perfect than the male for one principal reason, because she is colder, for if among animals the warm one 2 Aristotle, "The female role" in Politics , in Women's Life in Greece and Rome, Mary R.

More like this