Social Sciences · Law
Restitution in a Contractual Context and the Restatement (Third) of Restitution & Unjust Enrichment
See on the mapAbstract
Table of ContentsI. Introduction 1007II. Performance Under an Indefinite Agreement or Under an Unenforceable Contract Within the Statute of Frauds 1009III. for Diminished Capacity 1016TV. Performance Under a Contract Avoided for Mistake or Discharged by Impracticability 1017V. on Behalf of a Breaching Party 1019VI. Performances Under Protest 1020VII. Illegality 1020VIII. Breach 1021IX. Performance-Based Damages for Breach 1023X. Profit from Opportunistic Breach 1024XI. An Overview 1026I. IntroductionRestitution is frequently said to be a remedy designed to place a party as good a position as he would have been if no contract had been made and restore ... to plaintiff the value of what he parted with.1 If the goal of restitution is really to restore the status quo ante,2 it would lead to a definition of restitution in a contractual context somewhat similar to the following: Restitution is a remedy for an unenforceable, void, or avoided contract that enables a party to recover costs incurred by performing or preparing to perform provided that the plaintiff did part of what was bargained for. This Restatement says: Not so! The performing party may only recover costs that have enriched the defendant. (An exception is made for restitution for breach of contract.)3 It says this often and loudly and clearly. In many cases the unjust enrichment rationale works. If, by mistake, the defendant overbills the plaintiff who proceeds to overpay the defendant by $1,000, the reliance interest of the plaintiff is exactly the same as the defendant's unjust enrichment.4 The defendant is unjustly enriched by $1,000 and the plaintiff's reliance interest is exactly $1,000. Suppose, however, that the defendant requests that a check be dispatched by overnight mail. The plaintiffs reliance interest is now $1,000 plus what was paid for the overnight dispatch of the check. In some cases the reliance interest is far greater than this simple hypothetical. The thrust of the first part of this Article is that plaintiffs reliance interest should trump the defendant's unjust enrichment.II. Performance Under an Indefinite Agreement or Under an Unenforceable Contract Within the Statute of FraudsTo prove its point, this Restatement adopts, in Section 31, the fiction that recovery under this Section follows the familiar rule by which a requested performance is ordinarily deemed to yield a to the defendant equivalent to its market value, without regard to the increase in defendant's assets attributable thereto.5 The Restatement (Third) thus adopts the fiction that a requested performance automatically enriches the requesting party whose wealth may actually be diminished thereby. Let's not overlook the history of this formulation. In 1893, Professor William A. Keener built his system of quasi-contracts based primarily on the idea of unjust enrichment.6 In his 1913 book, Professor Frederic Campbell Woodward criticized the notion that unjust enrichment explained restitution and pointed out that a requested that is received under an unenforceable contract was frequently compensated even if the receiving party was not enriched by the performance.7 He substituted the receipt of benefit notion for the idea of unjust enrichment. …