Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
A framework to quantify managed retreat outcomes for households and communities
Hannes Lauer, Ali Jamshed, Daniel Feldmeyer, Katharine J. Mach, Carmeli M.C. Chaves, Jörn Birkmann
See on the mapAbstract
Climate change and escalating hazards are increasing the need for managed retreat and planned relocation from high-risk areas. However, robust and standardized multidimensional measures of retreat outcomes remain underdeveloped. Existing quantitative frameworks on resettlement, vulnerability, resilience and risk do not fully capture retreat-specific processes and outcomes, particularly regarding governance and the quality of the built environment in receiving settlements. We developed a theoretically grounded and empirically informed framework for assessing managed retreat outcomes at the household and community level. Drawing on a structured conceptual synthesis of seminal and recent quantitative frameworks, we identified recurring dimensions and indicators and iteratively refined a tailored retreat-outcome framework through expert workshops, conference feedback and application in a household survey in the Philippines. The resulting framework comprises two outcome dimensions (external and internal to the relocating household), one process dimension (the pathway of the retreat process) and a change component that captures temporal dynamics. Its main contribution is to offer an intuitively structured yet comprehensive architecture that brings together protection from climate-related hazards, built environment conditions, livelihoods and process quality in an operational structure. This moves beyond purely conceptual work and ad-hoc indicator lists by providing clearly organized dimensions, sub-dimensions and concrete indicator sets that can be adapted to different contexts and used for systematic assessment and comparisons of retreat outcomes. In doing so, the framework offers a practice-oriented tool for evaluating retreat interventions, supporting long-term monitoring of outcomes and informing the design of more just and sustainable relocation policies.