Distinguishing motivation from efficacy in the critical consciousness framework

Abstract

Abstract Critical consciousness (CC) provides a framework for understanding how children, adolescents, and adults reflect on and act to change systems of oppression. Research on CC has consistently emphasized reflection and action, but other constructs of CC remain less clearly defined. In this article, we highlight 2 of these: reasons for changing systems of oppression (i.e., critical motivation) and beliefs in individual or collective capacity to effect change (i.e., critical efficacy). To strengthen understanding of these constructs across development, we review their origins in CC theory, describe how they have been operationalized, and suggest ways to improve their conceptualization and measurement. This work advances CC’s conceptual and methodological foundations, and encourages a more developmentally informed understanding of how young people make sense of and respond to inequality.