arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Safety Research

Testing Cognitive Hierarchy Theories of Beauty Contest Games

P. Richard Hahn, Kristian Lum, Carl Mela

See on the map

Abstract

Behavioral game theory experiments consistently reveal that individuals deviate from theoretically optimal (Nash equilibrium) strategies even in simple games. The α-beauty contest is among the simplest games that elicit such non-optimal behavior; accordingly, there is substantial interest in formally characterizing the observed play for this game. Several authors, beginning with the works of Stahl and Wilson (1995, 1994) and Nagel (1995), have proposed an intuitively appealing and formally elegant cognitive hierarchy (CH) model of strategic reasoning for these instances where Nash equilibrium is patently unrealistic. In a CH model the player population is partitioned according to how many steps of iterated reasoning players perform when strategizing and each subpopulation plays conditionally optimally according to their level of strategic foresight. In this paper we specifically consider two common instantiations of the general CH model, the CH-Poisson model of Camerer et al. (2004) and the level-k model as described in Crawford and Iriberri (2007), evaluating how well each succeeds at describing empirical beauty contest data. Our evaluation proceeds by first developing a highly flexible semiparametric CH model which includes these two commonly studied models as special cases. We then describe an experiment

More like this