Abstract
The quality of the asymptotic normal approximation to the distributions of instrumental variables estimators in the linear IV regression model depends on the extent to which the instruments are relevant. If the instruments are weak, so that the system is nearly unidentified for a given sample size, then the sampling distribution can be quite different from its Gaussian limit. This raises a practical problem: under what circumstances can an applied researcher be confident that identification is “good enough, ” that is, that the instruments are not weak? This problem has been addressed previously (informally) when there is a single endogenous regressor. This paper considers the problem of two or more included endogenous regressors. The paper has two specific contributions. First, we characterize sets of weak instruments in terms of specific population measures on quality of inference based on two stage least squares; these sets in turn depend on eigenvalues of the concentration matrix. Second, we provide a statistical procedure to test for whether the instruments at hand are weak, where the probability of a false negative (concluding that instruments are not weak, when in fact they are) is controlled