Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
1Emergence of Commitments in Public Goods Game: Restricting vs. Avoiding Non-Committers
The Anh Han, Lúıs Moniz Pereira, Tom Lenaerts, Ai Lab Computer Science Department
See on the mapAbstract
Before engaging in a group venture, individuals often secure prior commitments from other members of the group, based on which they can clarify the others ’ preferences and intentions, and devise appropriate strategies to deal with free-riders. Here, we analyze the evolutionary relevance of such strategies of arranging prior commitment in group interaction settings, within the context of in the one-shot Public Goods Games. In addition, we compare two distinct commitment proposing strategies, which differ when facing non-committers: one refuses to interact with such players, while the other arranges, at extra cost, a sufficient restriction of access of such players to the common public good. We show, analytically and numerically, that both these approaches to dealing with non-committers can lead to high levels of cooperation for a wide range of parameters. For the former, the cost of arranging the commitment is the key factor – it must be justified with respect to the benefit of cooperation; while for the latter, the effect of restriction on the non-committers plays the decisive role – it promotes high levels of cooperation only when a sufficiently strict restriction can be brought about. We provide analytical evaluation regarding under which conditions one strategy is better than the other, thereby providing insights on which is the better way to deal with non-committers in a public goods scenario: avoiding them or restricting them.