Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND BEHAVIOR Mendias, Kehoe / ENGAGEMENT OF POLICING IDEALS ENGAGEMENT OF POLICING IDEALS AND THEIR RELATIONSHIP TO THE EXERCISE OF DISCRETIONARY POWERS
Claudia Mendias, E. James Kehoe
See on the mapAbstract
For four vignettes that described minor criminal incidents, police officers indicated whether they would make an arrest and ranked the importance of four policing ideals in justifying their deci-sion. These ideals were law enforcement, peace maintenance, procedural compliance, and assessing whether the protagonist accepted responsibility. Although an arrest was always war-ranted, the overall arrest rate was 56%, and only 10 % of the officers always indicated an arrest. In justifying an arrest, law enforcement was ranked first on only 31 % of occasions. Across arrests and nonarrests, the officers justified 66 % of their actions using two combinations of ideals: law-procedure and peace-procedure. Hence, the officers appeared to exercise their discretionary powers using one of two cognitive schemas to appraise each incident.