Social Sciences · Safety Research
A QUALITATIVE STUDY OF DECISION MAKING PROCESS BETWEEN EXPERT AND NOVICE TEACHERS IN TEACHING STUDENTS WITH INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY
Su-hua Ho, Kae Liu, No. De-shou St
See on the mapAbstract
This qualitative research was designed to study the decision making process of expert and novice teachers during three stages of teaching: preactive or planning, interactive or actual teaching, and postactive evaluation or reflection. Four teachers in teaching students with intellectual disability were selected based on the teaching experience, the setting and the severity of the students ’ disabilities. The two novices were the first year teacher and the two experts had more than ten years ’ experiences. Data was collected from multiple sources including semi-structured interviews, participant observations, videotaping, stimulated recall procedure, and inspection of documents. Qualitative analysis methodologies provided rich in-depth descriptions of each teacher’s belief and decision making process. Differences found between decision making of expert and novice teachers most notably involved in two areas: the integration of the information and the estimation of students ’ needs in the preactive stage. During the interactive stage, the decisions that both expert and novice teachers made could be classified into two major categories: instructional and managerial. The expert teachers did better than the novices did in making interactive reflections and immediate decisions to adjust students ’ needs. The major difference between the novices and experts related to the focus and the depth of their reflection in the postactive stage. This study also found that the expert teachers’ decision-making were consistent with their teaching beliefs, however, this was not always true for the novice teachers. Both the expert and novice teachers reported that the stimulated recall interview, watching and discussing their videotaped lessons were very helpful. Recommendations were presented for preservice education programs. 2