Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
IS Research Perspective About Reference Disciplines and Reference Differences: A Critique of Wade et al.
Varun Grover, Ramakrishna Ayyagari, Rahul Gokhale, Jaejoo Lim
See on the mapAbstract
Two articles published in this issue (Wade et al. and ours) through similar analyses reach contrasting conclusions on whether Information Systems, as a field, is evolving toward a reference discipline. In this article, we provide a critique of Wade et al. We first assess our different interpretations of reference discipline, and then discuss the consequences of including highly related disciplines in citation analysis. Finally, we illustrate the sensitivity of Wade et al.’s results to the inclusion and exclusion of certain journals. We also consider potential interpretations of second degree citations. It is hoped that the arguments presented here reconcile the differences as we collectively advance thinking on the state of IS as a reference discipline. The article by Wade et al. (this issue) is a thoughtful and provocative piece on the maturity of the Information Systems (IS) discipline. In this short paper, we engage in a closer examination of the Wade et al. article, evaluating its premise and conclusions with respect to our own article in this issue. Our intent is to explain and reconcile differences as we collectively advance thinking on the state of our discipline. Grover et al./A Critique on Wade et al.