arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Communication

Symposium on Deliberative Democracy)

Ilya Somin, Ilya Somin

See on the map

Abstract

ABSTRACT: Advocates of ‘‘deliberative democracy’ ’ want citizens to actively participate in serious dialogue over political issues, not merely go to the polls every few years. Unfortunately, these ideals don’t take into account widespread political ignorance and irrationality. Most voters neither attain the level of knowledge needed to make deliberative democracy work, nor do they rationally evaluate the political information they do possess. The vast size and complexity of modern government make it unlikely that most citizens can ever reach the levels of knowledge and rationality required by deliberative democracy, even if they were better informed than they are at present. Deliberative democracy is one of the most influential ideas in modern political thought. Advocates want citizens to actively participate in the democratic process by seriously deliberating over important issues, not merely voting for or against candidates put forward by political parties. They hope that voters will not only develop a solid factual understanding of political issues, but will also debate the moral principles at stake in a rational and sophisticated fashion. Deliberative democrats expect more of voters than merely acting to ‘‘throw the bums out’ ’ if things seem to be going badly. These high aspirations are admirable and appealing. Unfortunately, they run afoul of the reality of widespread voter ignorance and

More like this