arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science

Performance Evaluation of Recommended Portfolios of Individual Financial Analysts

Xi Li, Paul Chaney, Gordon Hanka, Craig Lewis, Hans Stoll

See on the map

Abstract

Ronald Masulis. I also appreciate seminar participants at Vanderbilt University. I gratefully acknowledge the data Using a database of stock recommendations with extensive coverage of brokerage firms and individual analysts, I examine the performance of portfolios recommended by individual analysts. The analysis allows a more accurate me asurement of analyst performance with extensive risk adjustments. The study shows that portfolios that equally weigh those portfolios recommended by individual analysts generate significant abnormal returns, for both buy and sell recommendations. Individua lly, about 10 % of analysts significantly outperform risk-adjusted benchmarks in their buy recommendations; 6 % of analysts significantly outperform in their sell recommendations. About 3 % of analysts significantly underperform benchmarks for buys or sells. Abnormal performance is generated mainly within a narrow event window from the recommendation date to five trading days later, with no significant return drift thereafter. In addition, analyst performance is predictable according to their characteristics such as the number of recommendations they issue, the size of their brokerage firms, and the number of stocks covered. Surprisingly, the all-star ranking of Institutional Investor does not have much power in predicting analyst performance. In addition, although the II all-star ranking is significantly related to both risk-adjusted performance and raw return performance, its capacity to serve as a performance-based evaluation system for analyst compensation is quite limited. The ranking is affected more by recognition factors and reputation factors

More like this