arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Law

A Retrospective on <em>Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council</em>: Public Policy Implications for the 21st Century

Connolly, Kim Diana

· eYLS (Yale Law School)

See on the map

Abstract

In 1992, the United States Supreme Court held that David Lucas' two beachfront lots on the northern end of the Isle of Palms had been "taken" by the State of South Carolina.'Twelve years later, as the nation moves forward into the 2 1 st century with booming coastal development and rising sea levels, 2 certain fundamental issues that underlie the Lucas debate 3 soon will resurface and require resolution.The following reflection on Lucas is meant to help enlighten decision-makers as they confront the inevitable beachfront and land use challenges of the, coming decades.This retrospective begins by providing a brief overview of the laws governing takings, including the Lucas decision, as well as an analysis of the outcomes of the decision.It then examines the economic and geologic contexts of the Lucas case and the response (or lack thereof) of the U.S. Supreme Court to these factors.In addition, this retrospective briefly summarizes the origins of the constitutional protection of property and the Court's applications of these principles to Lucas.The paper concludes by pointing out the power of public subsidies to distort the free market and the regulatory process, and the urgent need for state legislatures, not courts, to resolve this radical divergence of public fiscal policy and government regulation.

More like this