Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
Systemic failure and systemic unfairness
See on the mapAbstract
The Robodebt program continued for as long as it did in partly because it was not subject to a superior court determination that the scheme was illegal. There has been much discussion on why a suitable case was not able to reach the Federal Court, or why a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in publicly available form was not made. This article moves beyond speculation about the absence of a suitable test case to ask a different question. Could some of the more innovative approaches of UK public law have provided a useful means to challenge Robodebt? This article considers the UK principles that impose a duty of consultation in limited circumstances, review for inherent or structural unfairness, as well as a novel approach suggested by Lord Sales for processes involving automation.<p></p>