Transparency as an Offence: Rights Lawyering for Open Government Information in China Special Issue: Transparency Challenges Facing China

Abstract

Rights lawyering has been developing in China. From spontaneous response to proactive organization, from litigation to civil society networking, from using law as shield to using it as a sword, and from individual cases to policy change, Chinese rights lawyers, through social-legal activism, have been formidable social force in holding the state accountable to its rhetoric. This article examines the three ways rights lawyers in China use transparency as a tool to pursue legal activism and social campaigns: open government information (OGI) application, on-line mobilization, and off-line action. For rights lawyers, transparency is both as an end and a means to address a wide range of social-political issues. The chapter finds that the formal OGI institutions have created new legal opportunities and resources for rights lawyering, which has proved to be resilient in promoting government accountability and restraining arbitrary exercise of public powers. However, the political vulnerability of legal institutions and their lack of political will and ability in accommodating the demands from the civil society has given rise to extra-institutional, extra-legal mobilization in the form of variety of organized street actions by rights lawyers. The extra-institutional lawyering has invited retaliation from the state, however, leading to further restrictions on lawyers’ right to know and crackdowns on rights lawyering.