Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
Don't Mess with Houston, Texas: The Clean Air Act and State/Local Preemption*
See on the mapAbstract
I. Introduction If a city determines that the state is not doing enough to regulate air pollution, what steps may the city take to ensure that its citizens breathe clean air? This is the central question in BCCA Appeal Group v. City of Houston} a case currently pending in Harris County, Texas. The lawsuit arises out of the continuing battle to improve Houston's notoriously poor air quality. In 2007, Mayor Bill White of Houston, frustrated with the slow pace of progress under the inspection regime run by the Texas Commission for Environmental Quality (TCEQ),2 enacted an ordinance that gave the City of Houston (the City) broad powers to register and inspect polluting facilities within the City and to fine them for violations of the Texas Clean Air Act (TCAA).3 In February 2008, the BCCA Appeal Group (BCCAAG), an organization formed to represent the litigation interests of Houston-area refineries and petrochemical companies, brought suit against the City seeking a declaration that the ordinance was preempted by state law.4 The City has responded that the ordinance is a valid exercise of its home-rule authority to protect the health and safety of the public.5 This Note argues that, in many situations, local government may be the level of government that can address air pollution problems most effectively. When a state agency fails to take sufficient action to protect local populations from air pollution, the local government may be the only entity that can take effective action. How far a city can go in regulating air pollution, however, remains an open question. This Note considers this question through the lens of BCCA Appeal Group v. City of Houston. Part II examines the background of the Houston ordinance, in particular the City's growing discontent with the TCEQ enforcement system. Part III presents the legal arguments on both sides and suggests that the court will likely find that the ordinance is not preempted by state law. Part IV considers the question of municipal regulation of air pollution more broadly and asks how similar state/local preemption disputes might play out in other states. While there is a tremendous body of literature on the issues of federal/state preemption, comparatively little work has been done on the issues of state/local preemption.6 This discrepancy may be due to the fact that state/local issues generally do not present the kinds of constitutional dilemmas that make their way into the U.S. Reports, rather than due to a lack of significance of state/local disputes. Indeed, most American citizens have the majority of their government contact with local government: local police departments, local school districts, and local property assessors are likely to have far more impact on the average citizen's daily life than the actions of far-away federal agencies.7 In this vein, perhaps nothing a government can affect has as constant an impact on people's daily lives as the quality of the air they breathe. II. Houston's Air Pollution Problem Houston, the nation's fourth most populous city8 and the center of the nation's petrochemical industry,9 has an air pollution problem. In 2003, the Fifth Circuit noted in a prior case involving BCCAAG - that time concerning the group's challenge to the ozone plan - that Houston-Galveston has one of the most serious ozone problems in the country.10 In 2008, the American Lung Association ranked Houston as the nation's fourth most ozone-polluted city.11 Exposure to high ozone levels can cause coughing, asthma, impaired lung development, increased hospitalizations, and permanent lung scarring from repeated exposure.12 In addition to an ozone problem, Houston has a toxic-chemicals problem. In 2006, Mayor White commissioned a study by public-health experts to evaluate the risk posed by toxic emissions in Houston; the study identified twelve chemicals present in Houston air at levels high enough to pose health risks. …