Social Sciences · Education
Dialogical-thinking reading lessons : promoting critical thinking among learning-disabled students
See on the mapAbstract
A study investigated whether reading instruction that emphasizes critical thinking would benefit "learning-disabled" fifth-grade students.Seven students were assigned to an instructional group that participated in a program of 10 dialogical-thinking reading lessons and seven were assigned to a comparison group that remained with the classroom teacher and completed regular classroom assignments.The instructional group was involved in reading a story and discussing a central issue.Students were asked to consider two alternative conclusions regarding the central issue and then asked (a) to identify reasons to support each hypothesis, and (b) to evaluate the truth and relevance of each reason.Two reading comprehension tests and one critical-thinking test were administered to both groups.In addition, each group participated in a base-line and post-dialogical-thinking reading lesson.On the post-dialogical-thinking reading lessons, the instructional group arrived at sound defensible evaluations of the reasons they generated to support the two hypothesized conclusions than did the comparison group.They also gave more comprehensive final conclusions regarding the central issue than did the comparison group.There was no evidence of improvement on the paper and pencil tests of reading comprehension and critical thinking for either group.Comparing the students' performance on paper and pencil tests with their performance in discussion settings revealed significantly differing views of competency.The study lends support to two major conclusions: (a) assessing "learningdisabled" students' reading and thinking should be re-examined from a contextualist perspective; and (b) "learning-disabled" students should receive reading instruction that calls for critical thinking.