arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

Reading Multiculturalism in the United States and Canada: The Anthological vs the Cognitive

Adam Paul West

· University of Toronto Quarterly

See on the map

Abstract

This article examines the differing meanings of multiculturalism in the United States and Canada, and how this difference affects multicultural readings of literary works that have implications for national identity. Although I argue that Canada has a longer tradition of multicultural reading than the United States, and that what the United States' academy is today calling multiculturalism may not be multiculturalism at all, it is not correct to read this paper as favouring one nation (or the reading practices of one nation) over the other. This argument is not an American or Canadian nationalist argument; rather, it is a North American comparatist one. It operates in a framework where American Studies is, as John Carlos Rowe puts it, `a comparatist discipline that will respect the many different social systems and cultural affiliations of the ``Americas" '; in this case, especially `how the many different Americas and Canada have historically influenced and interpreted each other' (Rowe, 13–14). Plural nations constantly face the foundational problem of whether they should persist as unified entities, or resolve themselves into their separate — and sometimes oppositional — constituent parts. This is something that American nations have in common; indeed, it is a fact that is constitutive of the very idea of `America.' To study it comparatively is not to advance the cause of national competition, but of international understanding. As Walter Benn Michaels explains in Our America, the problem for the United States is what to do when `confronted with the imminent possibility of dissolution: What makes the nation one nation? What makes Americans Americans?' (15). The same problem exists in Canada, a nation notorious for its ongoing drama of imminent dissolution.

More like this