Computer Science · Computer Networks and Communications
The Fable of the Electric Maps and the Mutating Territory
See on the mapAbstract
Once upon a time there was a territory. And people lived in the territory, quite happily. They had maps, oral and written, which described the different boundaries of the territory. They had time to study their written maps, and a representative government to legislate changes on the maps if necessary. When a map adequately describes a territory, it is a very useful thing. It helps people know where they are, who they are, where they are going, and where they can't go. If everybody is working with the same set of maps, they coordinate their behavior effortlessly - social harmony seems the natural state of affairs. But then one day a new kind of mapping technology arrived. It was called electricity. At first it just provided small, very localized maps - but these electric maps were created very quickly, and gave some people advantages over others. Eventually everyone wanted access to the new electric maps, because the new maps were changing how certain people acted, which meant that the new maps were changing the territory. New things were possible, new regions of behavior and coordination were opening up, social harmony was becoming problematic. And the electric maps just grew and grew. Soon they spanned the globe and entered everybody's home. The new electric maps had sounds and pictures, movement, and characters. The old print and oral maps seemed pale, dry, unexciting by comparison. Plus the old maps took so much time and effort to study. The new electric maps were right there, right now. In fact, some people said that the new electric maps were going to displace the old print maps completely. Young people stopped using the print maps, despite the promptings of their elders. All the action was moving to electricity, it seemed. And the electric maps got more and more sophisticated. Giant electric brains were developed, which processed in volumes and at speeds incomprehensible to the naked brain. These electric-brain maps seemed to promise to make even the oral maps obsolete. People were becoming redundant, unnecessary in the new electric-map-augmented territory. Humans were just inferior machines-slower, less reliable, more expensive. There was a lot of violence in the electric maps. And people started noticing more violence in the territory as well. Could there be a connection, they wondered? Could a map actually recreate the territory in its own image? (The electric mapmakers discounted this idea. What, they asked, could be less substantial than an electric map? What power could it possibly have to shape material territories? Still, the debate went on.) The electric maps provided all sorts of about people and society. In fact, soon people started talking about overload, anxiety, the age. Even the print maps started piling up; nobody could keep track of them all. With so much information out there, it was harder to control, harder to shape. So all sorts of institutions which depended on information control of some sort found themselves losing respect, if not also losing power. (Parents trying to control information for children; schools trying to control information for students; governments trying to control information for citizens; privileged groups trying to control information for the less privileged; image-makers trying to control information for various publics - all of these suffered a loss of status, a lessening of effectiveness. Suddenly it seemed there was less respect to go around.) Even the representative government of the territory found itself on shifting ground because of the new electric maps. The old mapping skills seemed suddenly useless, as the electric stage outshone all others in brilliance. Those who learned how to use the new electric stages were the new winners. (And it was a strange thing, but in order to use the electric stage to best advantage, to reach incredibly huge numbers of people, you learned to whisper, to understate, to keep it short, to give off quick impressions. …