Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
Men, Masculinities, and Intersectionality in Forced Migration
See on the mapAbstract
Abstract The chapter traces developments within interdisciplinary scholarship on forcibly displaced men and masculinities by analyzing three systems of sociocultural relations that shape constructions of masculinity: hegemonic masculinity, intersectionality, and caring relations. Singular representations tend to reduce refugee masculine identities and relations to trauma, sense of loss, and violence. Such monolithic images reproduce a gender-essentialist understanding of vulnerability and can be harmful to all migrants given contemporary hostile public and policy discourses that determine the “deservingness” of asylum. Starting with the authoritative concept of “hegemonic masculinity,” the chapter analyzes the theoretical development of multiple and contradictory refugee masculinities, contingent on time and space. Through the idea of spatial intersectionality, it then reviews work that conceptualizes gender identity as a “relational performance,” that is, a gender identity socially constructed in relation to various bodies, differences, identities, social categories, discourses, ideologies, institutions, histories, and geographies. To disentangle this complex web of power hierarchies between and within contemporary gender relations and wider societal structures postmigration, the chapter argues for an intersectional analysis of gender and masculinities that not only considers multiple, intersecting forms of oppression and emancipation but also pays attention to spatial imperatives and everyday practices across geographical scales to highlight nuance. The chapter ends by formulating a research agenda to expand critical research into refugee masculinities as relational constructions by discussing fruitful avenues for research around divisions of care to better understand men and masculinities’ complex relationship with vulnerability.