arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Computer Science · Software

Towards Canonical and Minimal Solutions in a Constraint-Based Plan-Space Planner

Arthur Bit-Monnot, Roland Godet

· Frontiers in artificial intelligence and applications

See on the map

Abstract

Temporal planning is the problem of selecting and scheduling a set of actions in order to achieve a distant objective from an initial state. Constraint Programming (CP) has historically played an important role in many automated temporal planners based on the Plan-Space Planning (PSP) algorithm. In a nutshell, PSP would drive the search for a plan by selecting which actions to add and how to resolve conflicts, with an embedded CP engine in charge of ensuring the coherence of the plan. In this paper, we consider an existing encoding of temporal planning into constraint programming that adheres to a plan-space approach, but encodes the decision of the PSP algorithm as decision variables of the CSP, thus letting the CP engine entirely drive the search for a solution plan. Analyzing the encoding, we show that the induced search space contains many symmetries that would be absent from the original PSP algorithm. Another caveat of the encoding is that it allows for non-minimal solutions, i.e., solutions in which some actions may be removed without invalidating it. We propose to extend the encoding with additional symmetry breaking constraints to enforce canonicity of the considered plans. The encoding is further improved with additional constraints to limit the presence of non-minimal plans. We show the extended encoding to very substantially improve the performance of the original version and to be competitive with state-of-the-art state-space temporal planners on the considered benchmarks.

More like this