arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science

British Methodist Revivalism and the Eclipse of Ecclesiology

Tim Woolley

· Wesley and Methodist Studies

See on the map

Abstract

British Methodist historians have often seen the separated Methodisms of the nineteenth century as ecclesiological aberrations from the intentions of Methodism’s founder, designating them as ‘Non-Wesleyan’, affirming, however subconsciously, that what they were not was more significant than what they were. James Pedlar, a Canadian Free Methodist scholar, has an interest and expertise in nineteenth-century British Methodism and its engagement with revivalism. He has written a study that takes a refreshingly different approach to nineteenth-century Methodisms and their ecclesiology, focusing as much on their continuities with Wesley as their deviance from him.Pedlar begins by examining John Wesley’s own view of the church, and this shapes to a large degree the rest of the book. He argues that Wesley sat lightly to most aspects of the Church of England’s ecclesial life, with the notable exception being Holy Communion. This alone Wesley saw as significant as a means of grace in regular Anglican practice and he allowed no place for the structures or courts of the church as a means of grace (even though his understanding of conferring could have allowed some church bodies to have exercised such a role). Wesley’s example, Pedlar contends, thus set an example for nineteenth-century Methodists in their relationship with the parent Wesleyan Methodist Connexion.Pedlar’s focus is on revivalist manifestations of Methodism, and he begins with the events that produced the largest separated British connexion, the Primitive Methodists. He notes how founder Hugh Bourne was exposed to a number of formative influences alongside that of the Wesleyan Methodist Connexion to which he belonged. These included the untrammelled revivalism of Lorenzo Dow, the maverick American Methodist evangelist whose visit to the North and Midlands of England in 1805–07 inspired the holding of camp meetings, which led to the ‘Prims’ becoming a separate body in the face of hostility from the Wesleyan Connexion. Pedlar also highlights the influence of Quaker spirituality on Bourne, through his friendship with Peter Phillips and other early figures in what became Independent Methodism. Both Dow and the Quaker tradition placed a high value upon the inward leading of the Spirit, which took precedence over ecclesial discipline, and Pedlar contends that while Wesley paid lip service to the courts of Anglicanism, there had been plenty in his actions to encourage Bourne also to sit lightly to any ecclesial structures that he saw as hindering the work of the Spirit in revival.Pedlar next considers the case of James Caughey, another American evangelist who visited the United Kingdom with great success in the 1840s and 1850s. Caughey was eventually barred from Wesleyan pulpits by order of the Conference, and Pedlar shows how in parallel to Wesley’s theoretical loyalty to the Church of England, Caughey sought to reassure Wesleyan authorities of his intention to respect their discipline while continuing to accept invitations from dissenting Wesleyan Methodist congregations, as well as preaching for separated Methodists, including the growing number of Reform congregations appearing in the early 1850s. This chapter is a helpful reminder that sitting lightly to Wesleyan connexional discipline was not necessarily the only route revivalism took; Pedlar contrasts the outlook of Caughey with Wesleyan ministers James Miller and James Dixon, whose passion to see revival was matched by their fidelity to Wesleyan discipline.For Pedlar, the apogee and indeed the logical outcome of Methodist revivalism sidelining ecclesial authority comes with the formation of the Salvation Army by William Booth, a former Methodist New Connexion minister. The choice of military nomenclature, the act of commissioning rather than ordaining, and the early decision not to include even Wesley’s means of grace Holy Communion in the life of the new community all took Salvationists a big step further away from traditi

More like this