arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Anthropology

Challenging Monuments

Johanna Blokker

See on the map

Abstract

Recent years have seen commemorative monuments become the focus of unusually heated public debate. 1 The question of whether statues of colonial rulers, slave owners and slave traders, or of Confederate soldiers and generals, should or should not be removed from the urban landscape has been widely discussed in the media, in politics, and in academia, not just in the United States but also internationally.The issue is not new, but with the murder of George Floyd by a white police officer in Minneapolis in May 2020 and the global wave of public protest it set in motion under the banner of the Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement, the question of monuments in our cities and our society has become a topic of urgent and almost universal interest.In the clamor of public discussion over the past three years, however, and among all the statements and opinions of activists, experts, and opinion leaders that have been voiced and printed and broadcast, the perspective of those in society whose primary responsibility and daily business it is to deal with monuments-namely, conservationists and scholars of heritage-has rarely been canvassed or heard.Yet this perspective is highly relevant to the issues at the core of the current debate.For heritage conservation is not solely, as many might assume, a matter of "technical practices of conservation and processes of heritage management, " that is, the preservation of the material substance of historic artifacts such as statues, although this too is an important concern.Rather, in the words of British heritage researcher Rodney Harrison, it is about "critical discussion of the nature of heritage and why we think particular objects, places and practices might be considered … [worthy] of conservation and protection." 2 Heritage scholars ask about the functions and effects of historic objects in society and the processes of remembering and forgetting, appropriating and rejecting, that they manifest and support. 3Put another way: "Monuments are … values made visible." 4 It is of course values that are at the center of current debates about racism and discrimination in many countries around the world, as manifested in the international BLM movement, and it is precisely because monuments stand for values that they have become focal points in these debates.In this contribution I will therefore introduce the special perspective of heritage conservation into the current discussion about the handling of public monuments dedicated to personalities of the colonial era and representatives of colonialism.I will outline some of the theoretical principles underlying conservation practice and, on this basis, critically examine some of the measures being proposed for dealing with statues and other artifacts.In doing so, I will refer primarily to examples from Germany, Great Britain, and the United States, drawing liberally on the research and insights of colleagues from these countries.It will come as little surprise that the consensus within the field is decidedly in favor of preserving commemorative monuments,

More like this