Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
American and Russian, or Gangsters, Tyrants, and Bombshells: Three Reviews by André Bazin Translated and edited by Bert Cardullo
See on the mapAbstract
André Bazin's impact on film, as theorist and critic, is widely considered to be greater than that of any single director, actor, or producer, despite his early death (at only forty) of leukemia in 1958. He is credited with almost single-handedly establishing the study of film as an accepted intellectual pursuit, as well as with being the spiritual father of the French New Wave. In 1951 Bazin co-founded and became editor-in-chief of Cahiers du cinema, the single most influential critical periodical in the history of the cinema. Among the film critics who came under his tutelage there were four who would go on to become the most renowned directors of the postwar French cinema: François Truffaut, Jean-Luc Godard, Jacques Rivette, and Claude Chabrol. Bazin can also be considered the principal instigator of the equally influential auteur theory: the idea that, since film is an art form, the director of a movie must be perceived as the chief creator of its unique cinematic style. In accordance with his ideas as propounded in the major English-language publication of his work to date—What Is Cinema?, Volumes 1(1967) and 2 (1971)—Bazin has had the critical reputation of being the high priest of realism in film. His ascribed orthodoxy maintains that the cinema has value only as it preserves the transient details of life with a vivid objectivity—exemplified by the techniques of the long take and deep focus—unequaled by any other art form. This continuing image of Bazin the critic as the apostle of cinematic realism retains the attraction of a steady beacon light in the murky waters of film scholarship. Citations can be made quickly and easily, while explanations of Bazin's work may be rendered consistent as well as familiar. Yet it would be unjust not to relish the additional dimensions of Bazin's film-thinking as they are evinced in uncollected review-essays of his such as the following on Ivan the Terrible (Part I, 1944; Part II, 1946), Niagara (1952), and Scarface (1932). Unlike nearly all the other authors of major film theories, it must be said, Bazin was a working or practical critic who wrote regularly about individual films like these by Sergei Eisenstein, Henry Hathaway, and Howard Hawks. He based his criticism on the film actually made rather than on any preconceived aesthetic or sociological principles; and for the first time with him, film theory thereby became a matter not of formalistic pronouncement or realistic prescription, but of catholic description, analysis, and deduction-cum-induction. Indeed, Bazin can be regarded as the aesthetic link between film critics and film theorists. During his relatively short writing career, his primary concern was not to answer questions but to raise them, not to establish cinema as an art but to ask, “What is art?” and “What is cinema?” Most contemporary newspaper reviews answer the insistent question, “Is this movie worth the money?” Bazin's criticism, by contrast, poses the additional question, “If a film is worth seeing, why is it worth seeing as a film?” In theoretical response to the latter question, Bazin paradoxically claims that, of all art forms, films penetrate reality to the fullest, yet become most filmic or artful in the process of doing so. To him, a special effect is most effectively fantastic when it is also the most realistic, and movies are most sacred when working against the medium's affinity for religious iconography. A film like Fellini's I Vitelloni (1953) reveals the most about the souls of its characters as it focuses exclusively on their appearances, while an intensely realistic movie like Scarface seems born from an artful novel or short story that chose instead to become a film. In practical response to the question, “If a film is worth seeing, why is it worth seeing as a film?” Bazin displayed his ability to depict different directors' styles, and to position each style against the greater evolving realism of his time. For example, Eisenstein's Ivan the T