Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
Uncertainty and the limits of narrative: An introduction
Marco Caracciolo, Kristin Ferebee, Shannon Lambert, Heidi Toivonen, Gry Ulstein
See on the mapAbstract
Uncertainty is not an easy word to unpack.Partial knowledge of the past or present can create uncertainty, but so can the inability to form a coherent image of the future.Cognitive scientist Andy Clark (2016) argues that our brains are prediction machines, and that they evolved to cope with (and even benefit from) the constant failure of our predictions-that is, the world's inherent uncertainty.In individual terms, uncertainty is part and parcel of everyday life, a background to our interactions with the world that barely registers in consciousness-unless, of course, our predictions break down in spectacular ways.This brings us to uncertainty on the level of whole societies.The COVID-19 pandemic has familiarized much of the world with abrupt changes threatening to uproot one's way of life.Sociologist Anthony Giddens (1990) introduced the term "ontological security" to refer to the degree to which people can count on the stability and continuity of their lives.This kind of security doesn't just depend on an individual's material and psychological conditions but entails trust in institutions and shared social practices that were rapidly called into question by the pandemic: scenarios we know from postapocalyptic or dystopian literature-emptied-out supermarkets, deserted streets, etc.-suddenly felt uncomfortably close.This destabilization created specific, and for many people unprecedented, forms of uncertainty.Even in the aftermath of the pandemic, the world we live in is traversed by numerous other instabilities that bear on ontological security: from the war in Ukraine, with its catastrophic impacts both locally and globally (e.g., on the world's food supply), to geopolitical tensions between the US and China.Perhaps most importantly, though, anthropogenic climate change is jeopardizing the future of human societies either directly (though rising sea levels and global temperatures) or by making catastrophic weather events more likely, and more devastating, around the world. 1 The climate crisis is also a crisis of confidence, particularly among younger generations, in the governmental and international institutions that cannot agree on coherent and effective mitigation strategies, or that fail to acknowledge the existence of the problem in the first place.Indeed, environmental studies scholar and educator Sarah Jaquette Ray notes how the students she teaches are part of a "climate generation" so "frozen by their fears" that they are often unable to "even form a mental image of the path ahead, much less a future that they could thrive in" (Ray 2020: 2).