Abstract One of the difficult things about reading the political theory of John Locke (1632–1704) is that it seems so familiar, especially to those who have grown up in the American system of government. His Second Treatise of Government (1690) argues that legitimate government is a limited government based on consent, in which the majority rules but may not violate people’s fundamental rights. At first glance, Locke’s theory of government may seem too obvious to be interesting. But its surface familiarity conceals some intriguing questions. For example: Just how limited are the powers of government, according to Locke? A legitimate government may not violate our natural right to life, liberty, and property. But Locke allows that government can legitimately take our property through taxation and require citizens to sacrifice their lives in war.