arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science

Modelling Alcohol Consumption and Abuse: The Powers and Pitfalls of Economic Techniques

Alan Maynard

See on the map

Abstract

This chapter examines the question of whether speculative econometrics in a world characterised by uncertainty about causal relationships and all too naive policy-makers, is useful. The debate amongst economists about the methodology of their discipline has been long and, at times, quite heated. Unfortunately economics, like all the social sciences, is in an early stage of its development. Economics is thus concerned with the formulation of theories which give good predictions. The economist is concerned with the testing and retesting of theories and discarding those whose predictive performance is inferior to their rivals. The data, as the authors indicate, are not without their limitations, e.g. they accept the reservations about the Jellinek formula. The analysis of advertising effects concentrates on prohibition/no prohibition effects only, i.e. a dummy variable is used. The simulation of policy changes in the chapter shows that the imposition of prohibition leads to substitution out of beer and into spirits with a fall in alcoholism.

More like this