Social Sciences · Gender Studies
Beyond Rape Culture? Toward A Theory of the Work of Rape
See on the mapAbstract
The popular and scholarly insistence that rape and sexual assault operate in the realm of the unspeakable has no doubt contributed to the impoverishment of feminist theory on these subjects (Mardorossian 2002). Rana M. Jaleel's The Work of Rape fractures these silences by boldly confronting the ways in which we have become accustomed to thinking about rape. To rethink well-worn theoretical tropes requires an undisciplining of the subject of study. Readers should approach this text with a clear sense of their own disciplinary commitments and an openness to Jaleel's project, which may not align with their own. The author focuses on a particular historical rupture, analyzing rape in relationship to the international legal regimes that coalesced following the civil wars in Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia. These moments allow Jaleel to draw upon queer and feminist theory, as well as notions of racial capital, to shift our understandings of rape and understand the “work” the concept does across a range of geographies and institutions. This allows the reader to then place rape within a set of political possibilities and limitations.In her introduction, Jaleel turns to “rape culture,” a familiar commonplace term in scholarly and activist thinking about sexual violence. She notes that this framework may prove “stultifying” in its universalizing nature (9). Thus, “in the place of rape culture, this book offers a new theoretical concept: the work of rape,” which “directs attention to the legal, geopolitical, economic, and cultural contexts that post–Cold War US domestic and international efforts to combat rape and sexualized violence may enable and that, in turn, create the meaning and terms of their recognition” (15). The terms of recognition that Jaleel explores within this project are rooted centrally within discourses of international law and their dialectical relations with feminist legal activists. In order to situate readers within this terrain, Jaleel develops a method she calls “law beyond law,” a queer method that “bridges theories and operations of international law, governance, and power” (27). The method of law beyond law, Jaleel argues, “directs attention to the making and inner operation of law—the human and nonhuman relations and connections required to theorize harm within the preexisting strictures of available structures and theories of violation” (28). Both the intervention proposed here, of providing a rich and sensitive way to understand the politics of rape through its work, and the method that Jaleel develops in order to achieve this result are offered as intriguing and productive possibilities in the opening of the book, which then moves into four densely populated chapters.In the first chapter, Jaleel traces the rise of the category of “genocidal rape” through the wars in the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda. She shows that this transnational category, which accrues distinctive juridical definitions based on its jurisdictional location, takes on new stakes within US feminist discourses. She works through some key writings by such figures as Catherine MacKinnon, Andrea Dworkin, and Janet Halley, while noting distinctive instances, like a special issue of Signs and federal court cases like Kadic v. Karadzic, in which the category of rape was being revisited in relation to the global context of war. This moment gives rise to what Jaleel labels “the racialization of mass rape” (79). Racialization here involves pathologizing national bodies, while also expanding capitalism through the extension of rights.Chapter 2 compares the orientation of feminist legal activists to sexual violence in the former Yugoslavia, with sexual violence in Latin American dictatorships. Here, Jaleel broadens her analysis to consider the state, particularly in relation to torture. In the third chapter, Jaleel layers on the strata of the war on terror, and particularly the ways in which rape was reconfigured as a legal category, a litmus test fo